Four die, 18 fall unconscious due to ‘toxic gas’ in Keamari

Published December 24, 2020
Paramedics personnel shift a patient on a stretcher into the hospital in Karachi on February 18, 2020, after a gas leak killed 7 people and sickened dozens of others in Keamrai, a coastal residential area in the port city of Karachi. – AFP
Paramedics personnel shift a patient on a stretcher into the hospital in Karachi on February 18, 2020, after a gas leak killed 7 people and sickened dozens of others in Keamrai, a coastal residential area in the port city of Karachi. – AFP

KARACHI: A mysterious gas leakage, which had claimed more than a dozen lives earlier this year in Keamari, is feared to have taken place again in the densely populated neighbourhood as a key area hospital said on Wednesday it had received 22 patients in less than a week from the same vicinity with the same symptoms and complaints and so far four of them have died.

The incident came under the spotlight when the Dr Ziauddin Hospital formally released a statement raising alarm over the worsening situation that had so far failed to attract the attention of the authorities, who even failed to determine the reasons behind the previous deadly incident and left many question unanswered.

“Last night [Tuesday] two people were brought to the hospital in critical condition,” said the statement. “They died during the treatment. Apart from them, 11 other patients were also brought to the hospital. They all had breathing problem and were feeling pungent odour in the air.”

It said that all of them had the same symptoms witnessed earlier this year in February in Keamari, where several people died due to same complaints including breathing problem.

Confusion still prevailed over the earlier incident in Keamari as the federal and provincial authorities preferred to blame each other for the incident instead of finding out the exact causes of the deadly episode that has apparently re-emerged.

Authorities are still clueless about the current and a previous incident in which 14 persons died in the same area 10 months ago

‘Soya bean dust’

While a report of Karachi University’s International Centre for Chemical and Biological Sciences (ICCBS) had suspected that “soya bean dust (aeroallergens)” may have caused the deaths, the claim was widely ruled out by other experts and the authorities themselves.

It may be noted that on Dec 19, the Karachi Port Trust had released a photograph showing its top authorities inspecting a vessel that brought imported soya bean here.

Some 14 people died and more than 250 people fell ill due to suspected leakage of gas in Keamari. Authorities were alerted to the incident when people in the Keamari area began rushing to nearby hospitals with severe breathing problems. Since the bodies were not brought to any government hospital, the exact causes of the deaths were not ascertained.

More than 150 people were brought to Dr Ziauddin Hospital in the February 2020 incident. The mystery remained unresolved amid growing political tension between the federal and provincial governments which shared the administrative control of the old neighbourhood located along the Karachi Port.

“An initial investigation into the incident by the Sindh Environmental Protection Agency (Sepa) had showed that a toxic gas leaked from the terminal/s storing crude oil and petroleum products located within the residential areas,” said a source citing history of the probe into the February incident and its results.

“Then came the ICCBS report blaming soya bean dust [aeroallergens] as cause of the deadly incident but it was also rejected by experts and officials. They questioned if the soybean dust caused deaths and illness, why did it not affect 369 workers involved in offloading of the consignment at the port and the ship crew? Considering seriousness shown in the past, this can give you an idea about the fate of the future of this mystery,” the source said.

Published in Dawn, December 24th, 2020

Opinion

Editorial

Unquiet Lebanon
Updated 21 Jun, 2026

Unquiet Lebanon

Either Israel must silence its guns and withdraw from all of Lebanon, or face isolation and boycott from the international community.
Mothers at risk
21 Jun, 2026

Mothers at risk

FOR years, efforts to reduce maternal deaths have focused heavily on postpartum haemorrhage — the severe bleeding...
Political budget
21 Jun, 2026

Political budget

THE KP budget does not read like a document of a province getting its fiscal house in order. Revenue is projected at...
Pakistan’s moment
Updated 20 Jun, 2026

Pakistan’s moment

Pakistan’s diplomats are second to none, and if these states seek to engage this country constructively, a new modus vivendi for the subcontinent can be reached.
Menacing water plans
20 Jun, 2026

Menacing water plans

IN April last year, India suspended the decades-old Indus Waters Treaty, which contains no provision allowing it to...
World Refugee Day
20 Jun, 2026

World Refugee Day

WORLD Refugee Day, observed today around the globe, marks 75 years since the adoption of the 1951 convention ...