Why are Indian farmers protesting, and what can Modi do?

Published December 12, 2020
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi faces potentially the trickiest challenge yet to his authority and reform agenda. — AFP
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi faces potentially the trickiest challenge yet to his authority and reform agenda. — AFP

As an army of resolute Indian farmers keeps up its blockade of New Delhi, Prime Minister Narendra Modi faces potentially the trickiest challenge yet to his authority and reform agenda.

With the protests entering their third week, here's a look at the background to new farm laws, why they are sparking such opposition and Modi's limited options.

What is the state of Indian agriculture?

India's farming sector is vast and troubled.

It provides a livelihood to nearly 70 per cent of the country's 1.3 billion people and accounts for around 15pc of the $2.7 trillion economy.

The “Green Revolution” of the 1970s turned India from a country facing regular food shortages into one with a surplus — and a major exporter.

But for the past few decades, farm incomes have remained largely stagnant and the sector is in sore need of investment and modernisation.

More than 85pc of farmers have less than two hectares (five acres) of land. Fewer than one in a hundred farmers own over 10 hectares, according to a 2015-16 agriculture ministry survey.

India hands out an estimated $32 billion in subsidies to farmers annually, according to the finance ministry.

How are farmers coping?

Water shortages, floods and increasingly erratic weather caused by climate change, as well as debt, have taken a heavy toll on farmers.

According to a Punjab government report in 2017, the northern state will use up all its groundwater resources by 2039.

More than 300,000 farmers have killed themselves since the 1990s. Nearly 10,300 did so in 2019, according to the latest official figures.

Farmers and their workers are also abandoning agriculture in droves — 2,000 of them every day according to the last census in 2011.

What did Modi promise?

Indian governments have long made big promises to farmers — a crucial vote bank — and Modi is no exception, vowing to double their incomes by 2022.

In September, parliament passed three laws that enabled farmers to sell to any buyer they chose, rather than to commission agents at state-controlled markets.

These markets were set up in the 1950s to stop the exploitation of farmers and pay a minimum support price (MSP) for certain produce.

The system has led to farmers sometimes growing crops unsuited to the local climate, such as thirsty rice in Punjab, and can be fertile ground for corruption.

But many farmers see the MSP as a vital safety net, and fear being unable to compete with large farms and being paid low prices by big corporations.

“The laws will harm the farmers and in turn destroy our livelihood,” said Sukhwinder Singh, a farm worker who cycled 400 kilometres to the protests.

“Land, cattle and farmers will be enslaved by rich people. This government wants to finish us,” he said.

What can Modi do?

Modi has drawn fire before — a disastrous withdrawal of large banknotes in 2016, for example — but his popularity has held up, winning a landslide re-election in 2019.

From late 2019, there were months of protests against a citizenship law imposed by Modi's Hindu-nationalist BJP government that was seen as discriminatory to Muslims.

But the BJP, with its clout in traditional and social media, was able to depict the demonstrators as “anti-nationals” before Covid-19 eventually snuffed out the protests.

Modi, 70, has tried to brush off the current agitation as being stoked by an opportunistic opposition “misleading” the farmers.

Some in his party have upped the ante by branding the protesters — many of whom are Sikhs — as “hooligans, Sikh separatists and anti-nationals”.

But with the farmers, it is different.

They enjoy widespread support among Indians and ignoring them clashes with Modi's self-styled image as a champion of the poor.

In rural areas, where 70pc of Indians live, there is already a growing perception that Modi is cosy with big business and billionaire industrialists such as Mukesh Ambani, Asia's richest person.

“There are many things which are outdated in the agriculture sector. But reforms cannot be pushed like this,” Arati Jerath, a political analyst, told AFP.

“This is so far the biggest challenge to the government [...] It will have to find a way to walk back and save face at the same time.“



‘Draconian’ law
06 Oct, 2022

‘Draconian’ law

THE debate over what it means to be ‘sadiq’ and ‘ameen’ has reignited after the incumbent Supreme Court ...
Welcome clarity
Updated 06 Oct, 2022

Welcome clarity

There needs to be consensus amongst all political actors that matters of governance should be the exclusive domain of civilians.
Car purchases
06 Oct, 2022

Car purchases

IF we are in the market to buy a new car, we end up paying a significantly large amount as premium over the sticker...
More than economics
Updated 05 Oct, 2022

More than economics

Ishaq Dar’s appointment is but a sign of the paradigm shift in economic policymaking.
Dens of corruption
05 Oct, 2022

Dens of corruption

MOST prisons in Pakistan are a microcosm of the inequitable and exploitative world outside their walls. A probe by...
Football tragedy
05 Oct, 2022

Football tragedy

SPORTS arouses the rawest of human emotions. Football is no exception — in fact, the passions on display at...