To save real Pakistan, our unreal world must perish

Published May 14, 2015
There are moments whose memory or the lack thereof defines people in the time to come. The attack on Ismaili community was precisely that moment. —AFP
There are moments whose memory or the lack thereof defines people in the time to come. The attack on Ismaili community was precisely that moment. —AFP

Ismailis, among the first Muslims to arrive in the subcontinent, are under attack today in a country that was founded to safeguard the interests of Muslims.

The attack on the community is not only utterly and overwhelmingly disturbing, but also ironic; the assailants attacked a people who introduced Islam to the subcontinent. The attackers labelled them ‘kafir’ in a country founded by a political party whose first president, Sir Aga Khan, himself was an Ismaili Imam.

This contemporary nihilistic violence is a clear break from our past and history. It is not only the mortals that are getting killed at the hands of the perpetrators, but also the past; anything good and beautiful that is left amidst us is perishing slowly.

Editorial: Attack on Ismaili community

These recurring episodes of violence have given rise to a frightening sense of estrangement and exclusion among many of the indigenous communities living in Pakistan. They are a people too diverse, too integrated, and too many to be compartmentalised as minorities.

The only thing more alarming than the current state of affairs is our collective national attitude to hush up everything that has gone wrong with state policies, and our attempts to find scapegoats that don’t exist.

The Others

There are moments whose memory or the lack thereof defines people in the time to come. The attack on the Ismaili community is precisely one such moment.

For some, it is nothing they would remember hereafter.

For some, it is everything they would never forget.

The people of remembrance and the people of forgetfulness can never be the same people again. They are the 'others' for each other.

The 'others' among us transcend sect, ethnicity, race and religion. The lovers of Jesus of Nazareth, the admirers of Ali ibn Abi Talib, the devotees of Sufis, the sons of the mighty Sindhu, the homeless of tribal areas, the missing persons of Balochistan, the Ahmadis, the political dissidents; we are surrounded by the 'others'.

No so-called paradigm shift whatsoever in the state's policy can take away the scars and stigmas of this otherness. No rehabilitation can bring them back to the national dream that was not there in the first place.

Two parallel worlds exist in today's Pakistan. One is real, it is bloody and horrific. The other is unreal, it is rosy and feel-good.

Our reality is a logical upshot of the central ideology of Pakistan, rooted in religion. Children are shot at point-blank in this world. Shias are butchered. Thousands get killed mercilessly without any apparent reason. People cry. Blood flows. Trees burn. Birds go silent. Homes are burnt. Atrocity feels mundane.

Then, there is this unreal world.

The unreal world is a make-believe setting; also an upshot of the central ideology of Pakistan, but only wishful.

This world exists in textbooks, military headquarters, in the drawing-rooms of the elite, in the minds of the educated urban middle-class.

The army is the saviour here. Angels exist. Information is knowledge. The Ummah is the only reality. Sugar-coated hypocrisy is a norm. Mediocrity is the new genius. People bleed green and red blood does not exist.

These two parallel worlds are mutually exclusive. For one to exist, the other will have to perish.

As I write these sentences, I witness the real world perishing drop by drop.

To save the real world, the red blood, the green trees, the chirping birds; the unreal one will have to be dismantled.



Last call
23 Sep 2021

Last call

Times looked good back then. The rupee had risen and the current account deficit had eased. But all was not well in the background
Appeasing terrorists
Updated 22 Sep 2021

Appeasing terrorists

The policy of appeasement has not worked in the past and it certainly will not work now.


23 Sep 2021

Dialogue, at last

SANITY appears to have at last prevailed in the matter of electoral reforms. On Tuesday, at a meeting of National...
AUKUS controversy
Updated 23 Sep 2021

AUKUS controversy

Instead of flexing its military muscle, the Western bloc needs to engage China at the negotiating table.
23 Sep 2021

Provocative act

MAULANA Abdul Aziz appears to relish provoking the state — and getting away with it. For the third time since Aug...
22 Sep 2021

Interest rate hike

THE State Bank’s decision to raise its key interest rate by 25bps to 7.25pc underpins its acceptance of emerging...
PCB chief’s challenge
Updated 22 Sep 2021

PCB chief’s challenge

The Taliban takeover of Afghanistan has propelled fears of regional insecurity.
22 Sep 2021

No need for secrecy

THE government should not make a mountain out of the Toshakhana molehill. That would only encourage speculation of...