Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Coal-based power generation and environmental degradation

Updated Mar 31, 2014 09:28am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

- File Photo
- File Photo

The signing of an agreement with the Chinese for construction of four 660MW power plants at Gadani has come at a time when Pakistan’s three major cities — Lahore, Peshawar and Quetta — have been declared by the World Health Organisation to be among the 10 most polluted cities in the year 2011.

In fact, the 2014 Environmental Performance Index ranks Pakistan at 148 among 178 countries, and 127 in terms of human health from environmental damage and air quality. Today, Karachi, with a pollution index of 96.42, is the seventh worst among 261 cities of the world.

While the country faces serious environmental challenges, the government has embarked upon an ambitious plan to meet future electricity needs through coal-based power generation, which would add to environmental degradation.

Handling, storage and burning of coal in large quantities will result in huge emissions of air pollutants. Several coal-fired power plants, of cumulative capacity of over 23,000MW, are planned to be constructed within few years.

The Pakistan Power Park at Gadani envisages establishing 10 units of combined capacity of 10,660MW on imported coal. China signed an agreement on March 18 for construction of four units each of 660MW, and has committed to set up another two units of same capacity in the second phase.

Earlier, a UAE company signed a MoU on March 5 for two units of 1,320MW total capacity at Gadani. The Asian Development Bank signed an agreement on February 13 to finance the imported coal-based Jamshoro Coal Power project of 1,200MW. Recently, a Letter of Interest has been issued to a Qatar-China joint venture for establishing 1320 MW coal-based power plants at Port Qasim, Karachi.

Simultaneously, the development of indigenous coal resources for power generation has been launched. Construction of the first phase of the 1,200MW integrated mining-cum-power generation project at Thar was inaugurated on January 31.

Meanwhile, Punjab plans to construct power plants of 6,000MW cumulative capacity at six locations — Sahiwal, Sheikhupura, Jhang, Kasur, Rahim Yar Khan and Muzaffargarh — with the help of the private sector. The provincial government has already signed an agreement with the Chinese for coal exploration and development.

Plans are also underway to convert existing oil-based thermal power plants to coal. This month, K-Electric (formerly KESC) awarded a contract to a Chinese company to convert two units (420 MW) of the Bin Qasim power station. K-Electric is also setting up a greenfield coal power plant of 660MW capacity.

Hubco has decided to establish a 600MW power plant based on imported coal, while conversion of its existing furnace oil-based plant is also under consideration.

Gradually, more oil-based plants, like Lalpir Power and PakGen Power in Muzaffargarh, and Saba Power at Sheikhupura, will be converted to coal. In addition, a number of small coal-based power plants in the range of 25-50MW each of the cement industry, industrial estates and other organisations are either in operation or in the pipeline.

Yearly consumption of coal by a 600MW power plant is around 1.8 million tonnes, depending on its quality, which amounts to about 5,000 tonnes per day. Currently, Karachi port handles two million tonnes coal annually, primarily to meet the cement industry’s requirements.

Consequently, Karachi port facilities are being upgraded to increase its capability to import coal in larger quantities. A coal cargo terminal able to handle 4-8 million tonnes of coal annually in the first phase is being constructed at Port Qasim.

Logistics will also require a complete supply-chain of thousands of trucks and hundreds of railway wagons every day for transporting coal to proposed power plants in different parts of the country, except for the Gadani complex, which will have a dedicated jetty for coal handling.

The total incremental concentration of conventional and hazardous pollutants of the planned power stations will be a major source of carbon dioxide emission and effluents, and affect air quality and water resources, with an adverse impact on human and marine life and wildlife. All these projects have been launched without conducting environmental impact assessment, a pre-requisite under the law.

Some emissions can be significantly reduced with the adoption of mitigation measures, like carbon capture and storage, and the application of advanced combustion technology.

Employing state-of-the-art, highly efficient and low-carbon advanced technology, developed and deployed in the USA, Germany, Denmark, South Korea and Japan, is highly critical. China has also established a few power plants that are based on Western ultra-supercritical technology.

The writer is a former chairman of the State Engineering Corporation


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (1) Closed

Muhammad Imran Mar 31, 2014 02:46pm

The analysis in the article do not cover all the socio-economic perspective on the issue. Although Pakistan is choosing a relatively less efficient fossil fuel for energy generation as compared to developed world, yet its obvious like recently announced supercritical coal power plant at Jamshoro is using high efficiency clean coal technology. And that is the reason world bank and other financiers Have come to support this. Regionally Pakistan's green house gas emissions are far below than China and INdia in any respect. China alone is producing more than 5,00,000 mw electricity from coal based power plants and India on the other hand gets 60% of its electricity from coal fired power plants. Importantly, majority of These coal fired plants in India--- china do not use supercritical boilers which Pakistan is using and which is internationally recommended for coal power plants because of higher efficiency. Therefore, I think Pakistan has made very timely and appropriate decision of using coal baSed low cost energy an alternative to gasoline based Power generation. Apart from that in more recent days Pakistan has also initiated many renewable energy projects. So, Over all despite criticism govt took nice steps in energy Sector