Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


No quick fixes: Mission Karachi

Published Sep 05, 2013 06:56am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

WITH the prime minister’s arrival in Karachi on Tuesday and the numerous meetings Nawaz Sharif attended during his time here, the broad contours of government action to restore order to the metropolis are emerging. We already knew the MQM’s demand for army action in the Sindh capital did not sit well with Mr Sharif or the PPP administration in the province. It now appears that the prime minister favours primarily tasking the Rangers with improving security in Karachi, while he was critical of the police’s performance in comments made on Wednesday. While the Rangers have been given similar tasks by previous administrations, the results have not been very encouraging. The fact remains that the police must be at the forefront of law-enforcement efforts in Karachi for long-lasting peace, which requires both capacity building as well as depoliticisation of the force.

Karachi’s problems, as Mr Sharif must have realised, are many and complex and there are no silver-bullet solutions. A range of violent crime takes place in the city, from armed muggings to extortion rackets and frequent targeted killings. In fact, the numbers speak for themselves: according to figures published in this paper, over 2,000 people were killed in the city last year. This year, nearly 1,900 have already died so far. So whatever law-enforcement mechanism is in place has certainly failed. Also, there are nebulous alliances among organised crime syndicates, religious and sectarian militants and armed wings of political parties. Hence, the state needs a holistic approach; all weak links in law enforcement — policing, intelligence, prosecution — need to be addressed.

We agree with the prime minister’s assertion that there must be no rush to conduct an operation. The city’s affairs are so complicated that only well-planned action — with the federal and Sindh governments as well as the law-enforcement bodies, intelligence agencies and political actors on board — can succeed. The police and politicians have a particular role to play: there must be no political meddling in police investigations and action, and if suspects with political links are arrested parties should not pull strings to get ‘their’ people released. It will be interesting to see whether Mr Sharif flies back to Islamabad with greater understanding of the Karachi puzzle, or if he returns even more confused. In any case, one thing is clear: the success of any strategy will be in its implementation and we will remain cautious until all this noble rhetoric from our politicians and others translates into tangible results and peace in Karachi becomes a reality.

Comments (3) Closed

The Spirit of Karachi Sep 05, 2013 11:30am

Mr Editor, while indeed there is no silver bullet to Karachi's issues there is one which is as near to it as possible; a strong metropolitan government with transport and police under it on the pattern of other major metropolitan centres of the world of similar size and configuration. The police should be metropolitan and manned by permanent residents of the city. To prevent fillng in by cronies of local parties, a joint federal and provincial government panel can ensure that persons are recruited only on the basis of merit and competency. These steps will provide the required structural changes in the set up of Karachi.

What is surprising and shocking is the silence of all participants of the recent dialogues on these core issues including a respected paper like yours and anchor persons at Dawn News.

Ahmad Sep 05, 2013 01:11pm

The only way to cure Karachi's problems is to bring the Capital back to Karachi.

Aaftaab Soomro Sep 05, 2013 04:47pm

Agree with most of whats written here. My 2-cents worth: the government needs to refocus its energies from fighting the symptoms of strife to fighting the causes of strife in Karachi. The problems of Karachi emanate from over-population.

Increasing population in general and over-population in select areas, ANYWHERE, results in individuals having a dminished share in the overall resources available in a society. The resources being: nutrition, housing, education, transportation, entertainment, healthcare etc. etc. Why diminished share? Because, as far as we know, the planet earth has not expanded along with its burgeoning human population.

What would people, in general, do if their access to resources / essentials got harder and harder with each passing month? To stay viable, would they resort to using corrupt methods: embezzlement, fraud, cheating, robbery, thuggery, 'bhutta', extortion, bribery, gangsterism, killing, murder...?