Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Tough law sees acid conviction rate triple in Pakistan


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Pakistani plastic surgeon Hamid Hassan (R) talk with acid attack survivor, Naziran Bibi prior to her eye surgery at the Hassan Surgical Clinic in Rawalpindi. — Photo by AFP

ISLAMABAD: Few have much faith in the Pakistani courts, but campaigners say the conviction rate for acid attacks has tripled since tough new penalties were signed into law in late 2011.

Dozens of people, mostly women, but also men and children, are disfigured every year by one of the most brutal forms of domestic violence in a country where women are often treated as second-class citizens.

Campaigners have praised the government, which will this month become the first in Pakistan to complete a full-term in office, for passing legislation in support of human rights, even if immense challenges remain in implementation.

Parliament outlawed domestic violence last year. In 2011, it introduced a minimum sentence of 14 years in jail and a fine of one million rupees ($10,000) for those found guilty of throwing acid.

Statistics are patchy but Valerie Khan Yusufzai, chair of the Pakistan branch of the Acid Survivors Foundation, says the conviction rate rose from an average of six percent before the amendment to 18 percent in 2012.

Lawyer Sikander Naeem said: “It has become much easier to get a conviction because the Supreme Court has (also) taken a special interest in such matters. The statement of a victim alone is sufficient for the conviction of any accused.”

But victims, left with horrendous injuries and often blind, say the penalties are still too light.

Sidra Javed was attacked in June 2011 for spurning the advances of a son of her boss at a factory, where she earns $46 a month making water dispensers. Her family sacrificed almost everything to get her attacker jailed in July 2012.

“I was very relieved and happy for my father that his efforts paid off given everything he did. But when I think about how I'm living, how disfigured I am, I think it (the punishment) should have been much worse.” Her father repairs television sets, but distracted by the case and with Pakistan gripped by crippling power cuts his business dried up.

“Sometimes there wasn't even enough money for one meal a day,” she says.

Now 15 years old, clumps of her hair are burnt to the scalp. Half her arm, her chest and her leg are burnt. There are splash burns on her feet.

She is blind in her right eye and partially sighted in the left.

She has had six operations, needs reconstruction work on her lips and ears, and requires a hair transplant.

Javed hates meeting new people, despises talking about the attack and feels weak if she exerts herself too much. Apart from travelling for medical treatment, she never leaves home in the eastern city of Lahore.

Lawyers and campaigners admit challenges remain.

Naeem wants a special court set up to deal specifically with acid crimes, to make the legal process easier and he says compensation needs to be paid more quickly to help the victims get treatment.

Awareness can be another problem.

Last December, a couple who confessed to murdering their 15-year-old daughter with acid in Pakistan-administered Kashmir later insisted she committed suicide and with no witnesses or evidence, the judge released them on bail.

Pakistan's leading human rights group said nearly 1,000 women and girls were murdered in 2011 after being accused of bringing shame on their families.

It was extreme family pressure that ultimately led Naziran Bibi, a mother of two, to accept an out of court settlement for $4,000 in 2009.

Her tale underlines the difficulties faced by many victims, particularly those who are poorly educated in rural areas and who are dependent on relatives and terrified of their husband's families taking away their children.

She grew up in Bahawalpur in southern Punjab, said to be a recruiting ground for extremist militant groups, and was sold into marriage when she was 13 years old.

Her husband died, leaving her with two daughters under two. Bibi's abusive in-laws forced her to marry their other son, who already had a wife.

“His first wife was really angry. She never lost an opportunity to insult me and threatened to throw acid at me, to ruin me,” she told AFP, her face swathed in bandages after an operation to rebuild her eyelids.

“Then three months after we got married, at 2:00 am while I was asleep, she threw acid at me, on my face, neck, chest half my stomach and my left arm,” she said.

Bibi, now 26, was left blind. Her face was destroyed.

Her husband refused to register his wife as the culprit and her in-laws demanded she settle out of court. So did her brother. Eventually she settled.

“I didn't want to at all, but one of my sisters is also married to my in-laws and they threatened to ruin her life. My life was already ruined, but her's shouldn't have to be as well.

“And when I realised that the real perpetrator wouldn't even be going to jail, I didn't want to carry on so I got the 400,000 rupees and bought a plot for myself and now I've got a little grocery shop,” she added.

Today, she sends her daughters to school and is still on speaking terms with her husband, but has never again spoken to his first wife.

“If I could see I wouldn’t have (spoken to her husband), but they need a father and it’s important to have a man in the house sometimes,” she said.

But does she wish the new law had come into effect in time for her?

“The only punishment that can make this OK is if acid is thrown at them,” she said.

Comments (12) Closed

KHK Mar 05, 2013 01:38am
I am living in west for more than 45 years. what I see here is deplorable, I am not shore what experience you have of west and which Muslim country you are comparing west with?
Rakesh Mar 04, 2013 09:54pm
Good piece. There are two reasons cited for why this increase in conviction rate has happened: 1. Increased interest by supreme court 2. Easier to get conviction now, because the victim's statement suffices. I can see that 1) can not be quantified. But I would like to see more details about 2), i.e. how many convictions (exact numbers) were a result of victims pointing out the accused? Also, what are the exact numbers in general? (How many such cases reach the courts?) Numbers are important when the article starts with a lead on that. The background material is good in establishing context, but would have really liked to see more data reported in this piece.
raghunath Mar 05, 2013 03:38pm
heart breaks , this barbaric act is in india too
Silajit Mar 04, 2013 05:29pm
Good job, Pakistan! Hope laws improve in India as well. Sometimes the severity of the punishment limits the conviction rate because it involves more burden of proof on a person that is already severely crippled and more often than not, blinded. Hopefully society will look upon the perpetrator poorly for the rest of his/her life.
SanCha Mar 04, 2013 05:26pm
People are misinterpreting religion. Women should be more empowered.
G.A. Mar 04, 2013 02:15pm
How about an eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth? Perpetrators are not afraid of jail. They might be afraid if their punishment is disfigurement for themselves too. Punish a few attackers this way and I bet acid attacks would drop in a heartbeat.
fimmi Mar 05, 2013 12:38pm
do not compare modern day muslims with the religion islam! ... they can be completely different things Gerry.... hence the reason why muslims are so degraded....
Gerry D'Cunha Mar 04, 2013 09:00am
Islam gives equal rights to women!! in reality is this true?, looking at the present scenarios of womens in pakistan and around the whole islamic countries? as compaired to womens in the western world!!!!
shahid Mar 04, 2013 12:42pm
I wish our law makers have more time for such initiatives to tackle this madness instead of trying to make alliances for winning elections
Shaharyar Latif Mar 05, 2013 08:53am
Its not the law makers its us. You & me & everyone living in this country. The country that was taken in the name of Islam. We are the culprits. I have never stepped out of my comfort zone, my home to raise my voice against the people not only who commit this hideous crime infact any other crime, lie, deception, corruption. It is time to change ourselves rather blaming others.
Jeet Mar 05, 2013 09:44am
There are two types of Islam.The liberal sufi type of Islam which flourishes in India and the Taliban type of Islam which flourishes in Afghanistan, Pakistan.Naturally such incidents are highly uncommon among muslims in India whereas this articles tells you about the state of women In Pakistan.
Nazir K Ali Mar 06, 2013 03:58am
Some change is better than no change in this derelict country. Only the sentient and emphatic humans feel the pain and suffering acid victims undergo for the rest of their lives. Allah Almighty bless the Supreme Court for its increasing interest in these inhuman cases and the statement by the aggrieved woman sufficing to convict the accused and make him a criminal in society. In addition, the need for domestic courts dealing with such issues cannot be overemphasized and all governments until today have shied away from increasing the number of courts and judges. Any change for the better is welcome. Salams