Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Locked and reloaded, already?


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

NOW that that’s over, let’s try and figure out what it meant.

First, the soft option. Qadri was launched to achieve several things.

One: activate the non-Wahabis/Deobandis. Battered and bruised by the Wahabi-Deobandi combine, the establishment is looking for a counter-narrative, the senior generals concerned that extremism is threatening to bubble over.

Numerically, the Barelvis and Shias are a bigger cohort and a safer bet, but they’re politically inactive or split. Meanwhile, the Deobandis have their mosque and madressah network to spread their tentacles in both state and society.

The Wahabi-Deobandi combine has fomented instability and now it’s time to try and rescue the army rank and file and society at large from the more dangerous elements of that combine.

Qadri’s march has put him on the map, the first step in the long road to politically mobilising the Barelvi community, historically riven by inter-pir rivalries.

Two: discredit the politicians. Suddenly, with general elections on the horizon, we’re being reminded that all politicians are, well, scum.

They lie, they cheat, they defraud, they avoid paying taxes, they’re tyrannical, they’re loathsome, they’re Not To Be Trusted, they’re the reason Pakistan is the mess it is today.

The people may elect them again, but they sure as hell will be under no illusion that the representatives they will elect could, at some level, be decent people or even adequate leaders if given the time and space.

Who wins when the politicians-are-scum trope is peddled so furiously? Someone’s got to run the place; do we really need to ask what’s the alternative?

Three: a partial cleaning-up. The focus on Articles 62/63, tweaked and energised by men in uniform when in-charge, is a cudgel to whack at least some politicians over the head with.

The worst-of-the-worst, the serial offenders, the detritus that clings barnacle-like to the creaking hull of the state — they exist in greater numbers than can be stomached.

If you can’t get all the politicians, at least pull the incorrigibly ugly out of the game. They do exist: politicians whose sole aim is to maximise personal profit and in doing so expose the public to maximum losses.

Left to their own devices, the politicians will never clean up their own house. A Qadri-like jolt to the system could force their hand though, winning some concessions that more normal circumstances would never bring.

Four: an apolitical caretaker set-up. The PPP and PML-N’s choice for interim prime minister will necessarily be someone who favours politics, politicians and the democratic process.

While the caretaker government’s mandate is limited and term short, it will still be the government and the prime minister will still have a very large megaphone — meaning, they can push back.

Push back against whom? In Fata, KP and Balochistan, the army will have some role come election time — a reality guaranteed by the presence of troops in those areas.

And that’s before a decision is taken on whether to try and shape overall results and mould the incoming assemblies to serve certain purposes.

Even if the army chooses to remain passive during the election cycle, it is still vulnerable to a politically selected caretaker set-up: what if the interim prime minister, and the team he selects, is avowedly against the army’s political role? The army could find itself clubbed over the head by crusading caretakers with nothing to lose. So better an apolitical caretaker set-up — even better, an anti-political one — just in case.

So much for the soft option. Surely, though, the grand spectacle that is Qadri was not launched just to achieve some second-tier effects.

Second-tier effects are desirable but they are only a consolation prize.

The big prize remains the same: delay the elections indefinitely; bring in a team of competents; and effect change on two fronts.

First, stabilise the economy and implement a series of well-known and much-needed reforms. Second, counter the strands of extremism and terrorism that pose a direct threat to the state’s interests as articulated by the army.

They’ve failed, right? The big prize is out of grasp now, isn’t it?

The assemblies have just weeks to go before their terms are up and general elections are just a handful of months away.

Even in the land where anything is possible, some things are more possible than others, right?

Maybe not.

Crises in Pakistan have a gestation period. Qadri was able to circumvent the rule of thumb of three-to-six months before a crisis becomes full-blown with the massive amounts of money available to him.

He could buy his way to insta-crisis status in a way few others can. As for those few, unknown, others, they have a problem: now that Qadri’s done it, another outsider will have to find another novel way to break in. You can’t just replicate crises.

But put your ear to the ground and the PPP and the PML-N remain unsettled. They think there’s more to come yet.

More to come, but from where exactly? Three names pop up: MQM, PML-Q, PTI.

All three are already in the game, all have crisis-generating abilities, and all are a bit like Lance Armstrong until earlier this week: you know which camp they belong to, but have to suffer their denials in the absence of public proof.

Can the PPP resist and the PML-N continue to stand tall? Possibly.

But their reluctance to go for elections immediately is hurting them, because more time in power means more time for opponents to plot their downfall.

Locked and reloaded, there’s more to come yet. Though Pakistan being Pakistan, it’s difficult to guess when and from where exactly.

The writer is a member of staff. Twitter: @cyalm

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (11) Closed

Zahid chadhar Jan 20, 2013 04:53am
Down with PPP! Bring a government of technocrats and pull the country out of existential crisis. Do it for the sake of Pakistan,s survival.
NASAH (USA) Jan 20, 2013 05:20pm
My dear Cyril -- you are writing too many columns too frequently for us to read and digest the content -- please slow down. Elections are weeks away -- MQM and PML(Q) are tied to the PPP wagon they will have to go along -- don't know about the PTI -- it is asking the President to resign first! Does Imran want to sit through this election as well?
RHS Jan 21, 2013 09:17am
Excellent analysis!
Dr Emile Unjom. Jan 20, 2013 05:27pm
Nothing is conclusive and pridctable about Pakistani politics.
akhter husain Jan 20, 2013 07:59pm
Ousting thepoliticians,in the name of setting things right would be dangerous and a catalyst of chaos,It is better that the government machinery works to its potential and resist illegal and harmful orders without fear and greed.The elections must take place as required by law.The ECP should ensure that no inelligible person participate as candidate in the comming elections come what may.
Muhammad raza Jan 21, 2013 03:59pm
If you cannot guess what and from where exactly, dont write.
Mustafa Razavi Jan 20, 2013 08:29pm
Deep state of status quo.
uh547242242 Jan 20, 2013 08:33am
Very poor analysis. Some street walker,s views
I. Ahmed Jan 20, 2013 08:19am
Well Cyrill, you missed out one more point which should be point 5: 5. Ensure continuity of President after the next general elections. The current 'democratic political forces will not open any new legal or constitutional pandora's box to delay elections beyond May 2013. True in the land of pure most of the conspiracies were hatched by the army, judiciary and bureaucrats (you always miss a direct reference to last one!). Qadri, with his politico-religious stance enhances options for the PPP: a) divide the right wing support of PML-N in Punjab - adding to help they are presuming from PML (Q) and PTI in next general elections; and b) provide another option to delay the elections till September 2013. The declaration of D-Square will ensure knocking at the doors of ECP and then to Supreme Court on the clarification of articles 62 and 63, that will automatically lead to delay in elections! Maybe this time the past powerful manipulators are actually not behind the scenes and we have a dawn of new era of manipulators who are hand in hand with the past master????
India Jan 21, 2013 08:11am
Your articles are like fine wine smooth and silky. Thanks mate for this wonderful article loaded with metaphors, love reading it again and again. Cheers.
raika45 Jan 20, 2013 01:52pm
One man from nowhere comes into your country and creates such a ruckus that sends your information media into a turmoil.All sorts of comments and opinions fly all over the place [Dawn included].In the end what happened? Nothing.Now I read that Imran Khan is going to follow suit and bring a tsunami.