Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Protest against entire system

Published Jul 16, 2012 02:04am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

THE recent strike by young doctors in Punjab has thrown up some uneasy questions for all sides. Do doctors have the moral right to take such extreme steps? Is it a question of ethics or professional rights?

Does a government — in this case, the government of Punjab — have the moral responsibility to call out the police and make arrests after having repeatedly gone back on its words?

The only thing on which there is no confusion was the public outrage because regardless of whether the government or the striking doctors were at fault, it is the masses who suffered for no fault of their own. They suffered and they suffered seriously.

Doctors should never go on strike. They cannot refuse patients at any time and for any reason. The medical profession has its own dynamics. It deals directly with human lives, and when people do their job properly and professionally, they get direct appreciation from their patients. The community of medical practitioners cannot behave like any other professional body.

The problems highlighted by the young doctors are simply indicative of how unchanged things have remained over the years. It is the same set of issues that we used to grumble against in our youth though without resorting to strikes.

The demands are genuine and the exploitation of their services is condemnable. All these years, no government in — federal, provincial, civil, military, permanent, ad hoc or whatever — has given serious consideration to the problems of doctors or patients.

The patients have stuck it out for lack of opportunities, but doctors in their thousands have left the country for better working conditions. And who has replaced them? The ever-growing menace of quackery in Pakistan may have an answer to that question.In India, the federal government from the very beginning decided to provide a career structure for doctors, and initiated a system of medical education and training based on merit and audit.

The Indian Medical Council was set up and was made responsible for the regularisation and standardisation of medical education and training with merit as the guiding policy. Over time, this resulted in the establishment of a system which now produces brilliant doctors who are providing the highest quality of healthcare in the country.

No wonder India is now one of the most popular spots for medical tourism and people from all over the world go there for medical and surgical procedures. This would not have been possible had the system not recognised the significance of the career structure and ensured a process of growth for its young doctors.

The Indian government also organised its alternative health system by putting in place an authority to monitor various health practices. This went a long way towards eliminating quackery from society. And all this happened because there was a vision dictating the political commitment of the government.

Because of such an attitude, the vested-interest group of doctors and business people there were compelled to follow rules and regulations. They do have problems there, but also mechanisms to deal with them.

Malaysia has not done too badly on this count either. Therefore, we do have relevant examples before us to set things right in our own midst.

The authorities must understand that the medical profession is not a part-time entity. A system of medical education run by part-time faculty members and consultants will only produce half-baked, glorified MBBS quacks with no ethical considerations.

That is what is happening in Pakistan. The recent episode in Punjab is not just about career structure, but a protest against the entire system. It is time the government looked into the matter and introduced revolutionary changes in the existing medical education and professional conduct. Unfortunately, as things stand, this may prove next to impossible.

This government, like its predecessors, has little knowledge of the sensitivities of the medical profession and medical education. It has already abolished the federal health ministry and there is nobody or no authority to ensure uniformity of policy at any tier and in any direction. Nobody knows what the country needs and what resources it has to fulfil those needs.

The only way out of this mess is for the government to put in place a high-powered commission to review the entire system of healthcare and medical education for the two are intertwined.

From the basic health centres in the rural areas to major teaching hospitals in the cities, the whole structure needs a critical, professional and sincere review without the interference of vested interests.

It is time to get rid of the part-time mentality because it has already played havoc with the system. There is only one medical university in Karachi which operates as a full-time facility like elsewhere in the civilised world, and the results are there for all to see.

Pakistan, and, indeed, Pakistanis deserve a healthcare system where doctors should work on a full-time basis without having to worry about their private practice.

We should have a system where these doctors can continue with their own professional improvement in the shape of continuous medical education (CME) in the interest of their patients. We need the system to work for the patients, and not for the benefit of the mighty, wealthy doctors.

Healthcare is not on the priority list of most political parties. It is not even an election issue. It is time for the political parties to show some commitment by highlighting their vision on this key issue in their manifestos. If this doesn’t happen, those who can will continue to leave the country. The rest will continue with their strikes.

The writer is a former secretary general of the Pakistan Medical Association.


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Author Image

Shershah Syed is the former Secretary General of the Pakistan Medical Association and a member of the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council.

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (8) Closed

Indian Jul 16, 2012 04:12am
" The Doctors should not strike" agreed. But what should then be done to ask for our rights in the uncaring society where the politicians are corrupt and would readily paint doctors as murders rather than helping doctors out? Do doctors get a special discount when they go to buy groceries? Are doctors given cheaper fuel? Are doctors given cheaper housing? the answer is a big NO. Doctors inspite of slogging so hard in their lives have to counter the same problem that a common man does , then why cannot he protest like a commoner? When politicians have rights to organise bandhs are doctors more responsible than the people who run nations? Its a shame on the society that doctors and teachers ( people who hold the society at its seams ) are relegated to the bottom of the ladder where previledges are concerned. utter Shame shame shame be it in India or in pakistan. These are signs of a diseased mind. bania mentality on part of the politicians and not the doctors.
zaman khan Jul 16, 2012 09:47am
hats of to doctor sahib. more power to elbow
Umesh Bhagwat Jul 16, 2012 05:17am
India and Pakistan's expenditure, as a percentage of GDP is among the lowest in the world! Even Afghanistan and Burma spend a higher percentage than India and Pakistan.
akhter husain Jul 16, 2012 06:08am
It is neither the question of ethics or professionalism but management system.Right type of service structure motivates people to give their best during their duties.We, as a nation, expect others to be ethical and dutiful, but forget to give what is due to others.In my opinion Health Care should have been the subject of the center for a uniform system all over the country.
S.R.H. Hashmi Jul 16, 2012 06:25am
An excellent article by a committed doctor who knows the subject inside out and who has devoted his life to serving mankind, rather than making money, and whose service to the less-privileged patients are acknowledged worldwide. However, the article is unlikely to move those in authority who unfortunately happen to be the decision-makers in Pakistan, because public welfare, even their suffering, have been the least of their concerns and rank nowhere in their list of priorities. Perhaps things could improve with a new setup coming to power with fresh elections, that could rid the suffering Pakistanis of our traditional politicians who have been doing their rounds alternately and inflicting well-deserved punishment on the masses for making the choices that they made.
Shahnawaz Mangrio Jul 16, 2012 08:10am
Besides, other civil & political rights, the provision of healthcare system is also one of the fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution. The men in power should realize this right seriously and take necessary steps accordingly, in the light of recommendations made in the above article.
Vaqar Jul 16, 2012 06:22pm
Great article and a very rational annalysis.
Aamir Jul 17, 2012 02:25pm
1. First of all no education after grade 12 should be free PD 2. For sure, we need to change this corrupt leaders and bring some change about. Could be done only if we all come out on the election day and use our power of VOTE. 3. Once people will pay for the education, then yes, they should be given organisational structure. That will help all new student to pick and chose what is best for them. 4. Then, any action against the law must be treated as crime, no matter who does it from top to bottom. IF WE WANT TO IMPROVE OUR LIVING STANDARDS AND IMPROVE THE NATIONAL IMAGE.