Holocaust denial

Published April 18, 2010

A BRITISH Roman Catholic bishop, who had been excommunicated and rehabilitated, was fined 10,000 euros by a German court on Friday for denying the Holocaust during a Swedish television interview.

Richard Williamson was found guilty of incitement for saying he did not believe millions of Jews were killed during the Second World War and that “only 200,000 to 300,000” had died in Nazi death camps.

Court spokesman Bernhard Schneider said that Judge Karin Frahm said in her ruling that the bishop could not have expected that the clip would show up on YouTube and be seen directly in Germany. She had therefore reduced the fine.

Williamson had been barred from attending the hearing in the Bavarian city of Regensburg or making media statements by the order of which he is a member, the ultra-conservative Society of St Pius X. Denying the Holocaust is a hate crime in Germany but Williamson's lawyer, Matthias Lossmann, said he had explicitly told the Swedish crew conducting the interview not to broadcast it there.

The journalists who conducted the interview also ignored a court order to attend the trial, Lossmann claimed, leaving the judge to rely on written statements as testimony. The bishop's comments were made in 2008 but gained publicity in January last year, soon after Pope Benedict XVI repealed an order by his predecessor Pope John Paul II that excommunicated the bishop for his rightwing views.

The decision to welcome him back into the church caused an outcry from Jews, German chancellor Angela Merkel, and some in the Roman Catholic hierarchy. The Vatican, while condemning Williamson's remarks, said it was unaware of his views about the Holocaust when his excommunication was reversed.

He had been cast out in 1988 when he was ordained as a bishop by rebel French archbishop Marcel Lefebvre. His return into the Catholic church had been seen as an olive branch to traditionalists.

— The Guardian, London

Opinion

Editorial

Growth below target
15 May, 2026

Growth below target

Pakistan lacks the export-oriented industrial expansion that has driven sustained high growth in other economies.
Limited openings
15 May, 2026

Limited openings

FOR years, even the smallest suggestion of engagement with Pakistan would trigger outrage in India’s political...
Meetings denied
15 May, 2026

Meetings denied

FORMER prime minister Imran Khan and his wife, Bushra Bibi, continue to be held incommunicado inside Adiala Jail....
Trump in Beijing
Updated 14 May, 2026

Trump in Beijing

China is no longer just a rising economic power.
Growing numbers
14 May, 2026

Growing numbers

FORWARD-looking nations do not just celebrate their advantages; they turn them into tangible gains. They also ...
No culling
14 May, 2026

No culling

CRUELTY implies an administrative failure to adopt humane solutions. Despite the Lahore High Court’s orders to use...