MELBOURNE, Dec 28: South African captain Graeme Smith has escaped punishment despite breaching one of Test cricket’s laws in taking a contentious catch against Australia at the MCG.

Smith overstepped the line when he motioned for the umpires to refer a decision to the television replay when he took a catch at first slip in the first session of second day in the second Test on Saturday.

Unsure whether Australian tailender Nathan Hauritz’s edge had carried to him on the full or not, Smith motioned he did not know.

But he then signalled to umpire Billy Doctrove at square leg to call for the television umpire to officiate.

Under cricket’s laws, players are not allowed to call for decisions to be referred to the third umpire. Only umpires can do so.

Doctrove and colleague Aleem Dar convened before Aleem referred the decision upstairs, and third umpire Bruce Oxenford eventually ruled Smith had got his fingers underneath the ball and taken a catch.Hauritz’s departure for 12 earned Dale Steyn a five-wicket haul.

Despite Smith technically breaching the rules by calling for television replays to be used, the ICC will not sanction the Proteas skipper.

It is understood the umpires did not consider the breach serious, and took a common-sense approach to Smith’s appeal given the decision was clearly line-ball.

The crowd was never informed via the big screen that Hauritz was out until he began walking towards the pavilion.—Agencies

Opinion

Editorial

A difficult story
Updated 12 Jun, 2026

A difficult story

Unless productivity becomes the dominant target of economic policy, Pakistan will continue to oscillate between crises and fragile recovery.
Rough waters
12 Jun, 2026

Rough waters

AMONGST the key potential triggers for fresh conflict in South Asia is water. The Indian state is behaving in an...
Politicised football
12 Jun, 2026

Politicised football

ALMOST three-and-half years since Lionel Messi led Argentina to FIFA World Cup glory, the latest edition of...
GB polls’ aftermath
Updated 11 Jun, 2026

GB polls’ aftermath

The new administration must address the region’s issues proactively.
Peace in retreat
11 Jun, 2026

Peace in retreat

THE ceasefire announced in April was supposed to create space for negotiations. Instead, it has been repeatedly...
A few good men
11 Jun, 2026

A few good men

IT was a brave move, no doubt. This Tuesday, in the land of the Afghan Taliban, a few good men decided to take a...