SAN JUAN (Puerto Rico), Nov 20: For the first time, defence lawyers have been allowed to see a section of the Guantanamo prison that is so restricted that even its location on the US base is secret.

Two military lawyers for Ramzi Binalshibh, an alleged plotter of the Sept 11 attacks, were granted 90 minutes on Tuesday evening to view Camp 7, a section for “high value” detainees that has been shrouded in mystery since it opened two years ago.

The attorneys are trying to determine if their client is mentally competent to stand trial and to gauge the effects of the prison-within-a-prison on a man who, according to court documents, is so unstable that he believes his bed shakes and noxious odours are pumped into his cell.

Both lawyers, Navy Cmdr Suzanne Lachelier and Lt Richard Federico, said they were barred from revealing what they saw on the tour.

“It was helpful. It was worthwhile,” Lachelier told The Associated Press in one of the few comments she could make about the visit.

In a phone interview on Wednesday from Guantanamo, Lachelier said she and co-counsel Lt Richard Federico viewed the cell of Binalshibh, the adjacent cells, medical facilities and a room where detainees can watch movies.

They were taken to the camp in the same type of closed van used for prisoners, to conceal their route.

Binalshibh, who is from Yemen, was captured in September 2002 after a shootout in Pakistan, has been in Camp 7 since September 2006 when the US transferred a group of alleged terrorists to Guantanamo from secret locations overseas.

They have been held separately from other prisoners to prevent disclosure of national security information, and have received visitors from the International Committee of the Red Cross, said Navy Cmdr Jeffrey Gordon, a Pentagon spokesman.

In recently filed court papers, military prosecutors say Binalshibh has complained of the bed shaking and strange smells. They also say he claims guards manipulate the cell temperature to make him uncomfortable and make noises to keep him awake.

The prosecutors, without providing details about the camp, deny Binalshibh’s allegations and say he is not subjected to “prolonged” isolation. “He has available to him outdoor recreation, socialisation with a recreation partner, the ability to exercise, access to library books twice a week, the privilege of watching movies and may meet his attorneys upon request should he so choose,” prosecutors wrote in a motion opposing the defence request to see his conditions.

Binalshibh and four other Guantanamo detainees have been charged in the attacks that killed 2,973 people, the bloodiest terrorist strikes ever on US soil. The charges carry a possible death sentence.

A judge has ruled there are enough questions about Binalshibh’s mental health to require a competency hearing to determine if he can stand trial. Military doctors have evaluated him but their findings are secret.

His lawyers have previously said he has been given medicine used to treat schizophrenia but have not disclosed his exact mental condition. A hearing on his competency has not yet been scheduled.

The US holds about 250 men at Guantanamo, including 16 men in Camp 7. The military has said it intends to prosecute about 70 prisoners in war crimes trials.—AP

Opinion

Editorial

Half measures
Updated 14 Dec, 2024

Half measures

The question remains: Were suspects' prolonged detention, subsequent trial, and punishments ever legal in eyes of the law?
Engaging with Kabul
14 Dec, 2024

Engaging with Kabul

WHILE relations with the Afghan Taliban have been testy of late, mainly because of the feeling in Islamabad that the...
Truant ministers
Updated 14 Dec, 2024

Truant ministers

LAWMAKERS from both the opposition and treasury benches have been up in arms about what they see as cabinet...
A political resolution
Updated 13 Dec, 2024

A political resolution

It seems that there has been some belated realisation that a power vacuum has been created at expense of civilian leadership.
High price increases
13 Dec, 2024

High price increases

FISCAL stabilisation prescribed by the IMF can be expensive — for the common people — in more ways than one. ...
Beyond HOTA
13 Dec, 2024

Beyond HOTA

IN a welcome demonstration of HOTA’s oversight role, kidney transplant services have been suspended at...