Court rules against Berlin in Afghan resettlement case

Published Updated
Afghan nationals board a bus as they arrived in Germany from Pakistan at Hannover Airport, after legal and diplomatic pressure pushed Germany to resume a scheme that allows the entry of vulnerable Afghans, in Hannover, Germany, September 1, 2025. — Reuters
Afghan nationals board a bus as they arrived in Germany from Pakistan at Hannover Airport, after legal and diplomatic pressure pushed Germany to resume a scheme that allows the entry of vulnerable Afghans, in Hannover, Germany, September 1, 2025. — Reuters

BERLIN: Germany’s constitutional court backed an Afghan woman’s appeal on Friday against an interior ministry decision to deny her a visa, ruling that the government cannot row back on resettlement pledges it had made to Afghans who fear persecution because they helped Western forces.

The woman had initially been accepted under a refugee scheme set up by the previous German government.

Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s administration has tried to row back on the scheme since taking office last year as part of its tougher stance on immigration.

The plaintiff was one of more than 600 Afghans whose previous approvals the interior ministry had reversed as “invalid” in December.

While thousands of people were admitted under the scheme, hundreds more found themselves stuck in limbo in Pakistan as they waited for entry visas for Germany.

The woman concerned in Friday’s case had been approved for entry, along with her two children, because of her human rights work, but had been stuck in Pakistan since late 2024 awaiting a German visa.

Friday’s constitutional court ruling said the ministry had acted in an “arbitrary” fashion by not reviewing the details of her case.

Published in Dawn, July 25th, 2026

Opinion

Editorial

Rampant lawlessness
Updated 25 Jul, 2026

Rampant lawlessness

THE brutal slaying of a judge and his guard in Mastung is the latest in a series of blood-drenched events that have...
Daily fuel pricing
25 Jul, 2026

Daily fuel pricing

THE government’s move to daily petroleum price adjustments should make fuel pricing more transparent and more...
The drug problem
25 Jul, 2026

The drug problem

WHILE Islamabad Police chase low-level peddlers, the capital’s kingpins have quietly taken their operations ...
A new chokepoint
Updated 24 Jul, 2026

A new chokepoint

WITH free transit of vessels through the Strait of Hormuz blocked due to the US-Iran conflict, a new chokepoint has...
Improved rating
24 Jul, 2026

Improved rating

S&P GLOBAL’S decision to upgrade Pakistan’s long-term sovereign credit rating to ‘B’ with a stable...
More firetraps
24 Jul, 2026

More firetraps

WHILE it was already apparent that death traps dot Karachi, a safety audit by the Sindh government has thrown up...