Mogul Weinstein made sex attack victims ‘feel small’, jury told as retrial opens

Published April 23, 2025
Former film producer Harvey Weinstein appears in court for his retrial at Manhattan Criminal Court in New York City, US on April 23. — Reuters
Former film producer Harvey Weinstein appears in court for his retrial at Manhattan Criminal Court in New York City, US on April 23. — Reuters

Prosecutors opening Hollywood mogul Harvey Weinstein’s rape and sexual assault retrial described on Wednesday how he ignored his victims’ pleas to stop and abused his position to make them “feel small.”

The trial, which began with jury selection last week, will force survivors who helped spark the “MeToo” movement to testify against Weinstein once more.

The former Miramax studio boss is charged with the 2006 sexual assault of former production assistant Mimi Haleyi and the 2013 rape of aspiring actress Jessica Mann. He also faces a new count for an alleged sexual assault of a 16-year-old in 2006.

Assistant District Attorney Shannon Lucey recounted Weinstein’s alleged attacks in graphic detail, saying all three women had begged him to stop, but that he had “all the power … He made all these women feel small.”

The prosecutor described how Weinstein pestered Haleyi with multiple requests for massages and sexual favours before she found herself alone with him in an apartment one day in 2006.

“The defendant, three times [her] size, kissed her, groped her, and she told him again she was not interested,” Lucey said. “He pulled Mimi towards him … She quickly realised he was not going [to] take a no for an answer,” the prosecutor added.

Lucey detailed how Weinstein then forced himself on Haleyi, performing oral sex on her despite her pleas for him to stop.

The award-winning movie producer, who was brought into Manhattan criminal court in a wheelchair and wore a dark business suit, glanced occasionally at the jury as the trial got underway.

Lucey described the defendant as “one of the most powerful men in … show business,” telling the majority-female jury that “when he wanted something, he took it.”

More than 80 accusers

Kaja Sokola, who was not part of the previous trial, was an aspiring model and just 16 years old at the time that she alleges Weinstein sexually assaulted her at a hotel in Manhattan.

Accusers describe the impresario as a predator who used his perch atop the cinema industry to pressure actresses and assistants for sexual favours, often in hotel rooms.

But Arthur Aidala, Weinstein’s defence attorney, stressed that the prosecution’s opening statement was not “the whole movie”, arguing that the jury would hear no evidence of the use of force or a lack of consent.

He said Mann had introduced Weinstein to her mother after the alleged rape, and that Haleyi had “consensual sex” with Weinstein after her alleged attack.

“Not guilty, not guilty, not guilty,” he told the jury.

Weinstein’s 2020 convictions over Haleyi and Mann were overturned last year by the New York Court of Appeals, which ruled that the way witnesses were handled in the original New York trial was unlawful.

Presentation of the evidence in the retrial is expected to last five to six weeks. The 73-year-old has said he hopes his case will be judged with “fresh eyes”, more than seven years after his spectacular downfall and a global backlash against predatory abusers.

Weinstein is already serving a 16-year prison sentence after being convicted of raping and assaulting a European actress more than a decade ago.

The producer of a string of box office hits such as Sex, Lies and Videotape, Pulp Fiction and Shakespeare in Love, Weinstein has battled health issues. He has never acknowledged any wrongdoing and has always maintained that the encounters were consensual.

Since his downfall, Weinstein has been accused of harassment, sexual assault or rape by more than 80 women, including Angelina Jolie, Gwyneth Paltrow, Lupita Nyong’o and Ashley Judd.

Opinion

Editorial

Hostilities cease, at last
Updated 11 May, 2025

Hostilities cease, at last

It is Islamabad and New Delhi that will have to do the heavy lifting thesmselves to secure peace.
Second IMF tranche
11 May, 2025

Second IMF tranche

THE IMF board’s approval of the second tranche of its ongoing $7bn funding arrangement and a new climate ...
War and lies
Updated 10 May, 2025

War and lies

Media on this side of the border is also not above blame.
Alarming indifference
10 May, 2025

Alarming indifference

US VICE President J.D. Vance’s comments that a possible war between Pakistan and India would be “none of our...
Civil readiness
10 May, 2025

Civil readiness

AMID rising regional tensions, there has been some discussion on the need for people to be better prepared in the...
Time for restraint
Updated 09 May, 2025

Time for restraint

Jingoism is evident in both countries, but elements in India’s media, cultural and political sphere have been egging on their country in confrontation.