Trump’s plan to “ethnically cleanse” Palestinians in Gaza is absurd, says Hassan Mneimneh, a scholar and analyst with the Middle East Institute.

“It is obscene. But in terms of it being proposed, we’ve witnessed more than a year of impunity on the part of Israel, enabled by the United States,” Mneimneh tells Al Jazeera.

“The Biden administration was somehow shy in this enablement and participation in war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza because it pretended that there were higher purposes at play. With the Trump administration, the pretension and claims are not there,” he said.

Mneimneh said Trump’s comments are an abject display of force that ignores and bypasses any law and speaks of Palestinian territory in a trivial fashion as if the US is entitled to claim Gaza the way he has made claims on Greenland and Panama.

The difference, he added, is that tens of thousands of people have been killed in Gaza and their way of life has been destroyed by Israel’s invasion.

“Can he actually take action? Evidently, because in support of Israel, he would do that. There will absolutely be resistance. It’s not a done deal but it’s a passing from the rules-based order towards a new reality in which the US and Israel present themselves as being right.”

A Palestinian man views the rubble of buildings destroyed during the Israeli offensive, amid a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip on February 4. — Reuters
A Palestinian man views the rubble of buildings destroyed during the Israeli offensive, amid a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip on February 4. — Reuters

Opinion

Editorial

Swat bombing
Updated 04 Aug, 2026

Swat bombing

IT is a bitter irony that terrorists struck a protest against violence in Swat on Sunday, causing at least 17...
Tariff blow
04 Aug, 2026

Tariff blow

FOR an export sector already squeezed by high production costs, the additional 10pc tariff on top of the existing...
Perilous peaks
04 Aug, 2026

Perilous peaks

THE deaths of 10 climbers in an avalanche on Broad Peak is a sad reminder of the perils that many mountaineers face...
Farewell to arms?
Updated 03 Aug, 2026

Farewell to arms?

PALESTINIAN resistance group Hamas recently made a major concession by agreeing to give up its weapons. It should be...
Unplanned future
03 Aug, 2026

Unplanned future

A PROJECTION that Pakistan’s population could reach 400m by 2040 should not be treated as another dramatic number...
No more torture
03 Aug, 2026

No more torture

EVEN the best laws on the books are worth little unless the state shows the willingness to enforce them. This is...