Al Jazeera disputes Israel’s claim about hospital strike

Published October 20, 2023
Children sit in the back of an ambulance at Shifa Hospital after hundreds of Palestinians were killed in a blast at Al-Ahli hospital in Gaza City. — Reuters
Children sit in the back of an ambulance at Shifa Hospital after hundreds of Palestinians were killed in a blast at Al-Ahli hospital in Gaza City. — Reuters

TWO days after the air strike on Gaza’s Al Ahli Arab hospital, the Qatar-based news network Al Jazeera has disputed the Israeli army claim that the explosion at the hospital resulted from a failed rocket launch by the Islamic Jihad.

The Israel Defence Forces have used Al Jazeera’s live feed at the time of the attack as proof that one of the rockets fired from Gaza, as visible in the footage, was responsible for the damage to the hospital.

The broadcaster said its Sanad Agency for fact-checking and digital investigation had analysed the Israeli claims and other “time-coded footage from several sources”, including its own live broadcast.

“The investigation reveals that Israeli statements seem to have misinterpreted the evidence to build a story that one of the flashes recorded by several sources was a rocket misfire,” it added.

After a detailed review of videos, Sanad‘s analysts concluded that the flash attributed by Israel to a misfired rocket was “in fact consistent with Israel’s Iron Dome missile defence system“, intercep­ting a missile and destroying it in mid-air.

As per Al Jazeera’s analysis, there were four Israeli air strikes targeting areas near the hospital between 6.45pm and 7pm on Tuesday.

These strikes were carried out at 6.54pm, 6.55pm, 6.57pm and 6.58pm, around the time of the attack at the hospital.

It added that at 6.59pm, a rocket was fired from Gaza, which Israel claimed hit the hospital. Around 15 seconds later, Al Jazeera’s live feed showed the rocket was intercepted mid-air and “completely destroyed”. It was the last rocket launched from Gaza before the bombing of the hospital, the news channel stated.

“Five seconds after that interception, an explosion in Gaza can be seen, followed two seconds later by a much larger explosion. This is the strike that hit the Al Ahli Arab hospital.”

There were no grounds for the Israeli army’s claim that the strike was caused by a failed rocket launch, Al Jazeera concluded.

Published in Dawn, October 20th, 2023

Opinion

Editorial

Failed martial law
Updated 05 Dec, 2024

Failed martial law

Appetite for non-democratic systems of governance appears to be shrinking rapidly. Perhaps more countries are now realising the futility of rule by force.
Holding the key
05 Dec, 2024

Holding the key

IN the view of one learned judge of the Supreme Court’s recently formed constitutional bench, parliament holds the...
New low
05 Dec, 2024

New low

WHERE does one go from here? In the latest blow to women’s rights in Afghanistan, the Taliban regime has barred...
Online oppression
Updated 04 Dec, 2024

Online oppression

Plan to bring changes to Peca is simply another attempt to suffocate dissent. It shows how the state continues to prioritise control over real cybersecurity concerns.
The right call
04 Dec, 2024

The right call

AMIDST the ongoing tussle between the federal government and the main opposition party, several critical issues...
Acting cautiously
04 Dec, 2024

Acting cautiously

IT appears too big a temptation to ignore. The wider expectations for a steeper reduction in the borrowing costs...