SHOOTING the messenger is an almost perfect crime in Pakistan, a nation consistently ranked among the most hazardous for the pursuit of journalism. Today, the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists, is an apt occasion to recognise how abysmally this country fails in its duty to protect mediapersons — and to push for change. According to the Freedom Network’s latest report, 53 journalists were murdered in the country during the decade between 2012 and 2022, but only in two cases have the killers been convicted. In other words, 96pc of such murders go unpunished. The lack of accountability is staggering, all the more so considering that in 2013, Pakistan endorsed the UN Plan of Action on the Safety of Journalists and the Issue of Impunity. A free and independent media plays a vital role in holding authorities to account. But when there is no justice for murdered journalists, it casts a pall on the media landscape. To speak truth to power in such an environment means gambling on one’s life, knowing the other side has an unassailable advantage.
According to the report, only 31 murders of journalists out of the 53 made it to court. The trial was completed in a mere 12 cases and convictions were obtained in only two, or 4pc. As per the report, the cases of about two-thirds of journalists murdered in KP and Punjab are likely to never even get to trial stage. One may well wonder whether that is only due to shoddy police investigation, or a lack of will. After all, the report describes “mysterious, nameless and unidentified actors” (28pc) as the “worst enemies of journalists”. Organised crime was responsible for 24.5pc of the murders, and militant groups were behind the killing of 10 journalists. Sadly enough, at least some of these deaths could have been prevented. In more than half of the cases, the journalists did not inform their employers, unions, etc about advance warnings they may have received, but several did — to no avail. Had more robust protections been in place, had those attempting to intimidate the journalists been taken to task at that early stage, they may not have lost their lives. Media protection laws enacted at the federal and Sindh levels must not remain only empty words. If those involved in the murder of journalists are not brought to justice, the culture of using violence to silence the media is unlikely to come to an end.
Published in Dawn, November 2nd, 2022


























