Is it our own?

Published October 25, 2021
The writer has a doctorate from the University of Oxford and is graduate of the Harvard Kennedy School of Government.
The writer has a doctorate from the University of Oxford and is graduate of the Harvard Kennedy School of Government.

MANY parents in Pakistan try to inculcate a sense of the importance of hard work in their children by employing the simple narrative of effort and reward: if you work hard in life you will end up being successful in whatever way society defines the term. A natural extension of this line of thinking is that your success is completely a result of your own efforts.

Once you grow up however, you come to realise that the structural barriers determined by the accident of birth are the more important determinants of success in life. Factors such as the income of your family, the type of education you received, the environment in your household, the fields that society at large values are not in your control.

While the above is true, a much more fundamental philosophical question is whether in the absence of these structural barriers, would you really ‘deserve’ your success. It is only once we have thought about the pure link between effort/ability and success that we would be in a position to truly see whether the linear narrative of success taught to our children makes sense.

In today’s world, the link between effort/ability and success is so common that we often do not take a step back to question this.

It is fair to ask what truly determines our success.

For this purpose, let us conduct a thought experiment. Assume a hypothetical world where there are absolutely no structural barriers to success. In this utopian world, every individual will end up being successful based on a combination of hard work and naturally endowed ability. From a philosophical perspective, can we say that the individuals who end up earning more in this society completely ‘deserve’ their success or earnings?

While you might be tempted to say ‘yes’, consider the following line of reasoning. To assert that the individuals completely deserve the fruits of their labour, we would need to say that their ability and effort were completely their own.

Starting with the simpler case of naturally endowed abilities, we know for a fact that we have no control over these abilities given to us at birth. If these abilities were not completely our own, how can we claim that we deserve the success that comes from them?

One might say that effort is completely in the control of the individual. However, philosophers have argued that even the effort you exert throughout your life is determined to a large extent by factors that are outside your control: the values that were inculcated in you, how supportive your family was, and so on.

A larger concern is that even in this hypothetical world, society will place value on certain careers/fields, which is completely out of our control. If you happen to be born in a society that values playing professional cricket, and you luckily have a natural ability to play the sport well, you are clearly very fortunate. How about being born with the same abilities in a society that does not value sports?

Naturally, if ability and effort are determined mostly by accident of birth, can we really claim that our success is of our own making? Philosophers argue that we cannot.

If even in a world without structural barriers, we cannot completely say that we deserve our earnings, where does that leave us? In today’s world where the common linear narrative of success is a far cry from what philosophers have argued, what does all of this imply? The real world is also one with widespread structural barriers to success where the accident of birth largely determines your outcomes in life.

To my mind, there are two important lessons for us in our daily lives from this exercise. The first is that if we truly believed our success was largely out of our control, we would be much humbler in our attitude towards others, while still working very hard for the little that we did control. It is quite unfortunate to see that individuals who end up more fortunate can also end up being more arrogant precisely because they incorrectly believe that they deserve their success.

Second, we should be much more open to recognising that our success to some extent also belongs to the people around us. In practice, this can take various forms, such as a greater willingness to accept income and wealth redistribution.

We can raise our next generations by imbuing in them the value of hard work. At the same time, we can make sure that they also understand their success isn’t theirs alone. If we also inculcate in them the value of humility and recognising what we owe to our society, we will not only ensure that hard work is valued but in a morally cognisant manner.

The writer has a doctorate from the University of Oxford and is graduate of the Harvard Kennedy School of Government.

Twitter: @KhudadadChattha

Published in Dawn, October 25th, 2021



20 Jan, 2022

Too great a divide

THE government’s offer of talks to the opposition on electoral and judicial reforms is a welcome development in a...
Military inductees
Updated 20 Jan, 2022

Military inductees

Giving preference to military personnel for appointments in civilian roles is exposing them to unnecessary controversy.
20 Jan, 2022

Suu Kyi charges

MYANMAR’S ruling junta seems determined to spin a complicated legal web around Aung San Suu Kyi to ensure that the...
UAE targeted
Updated 19 Jan, 2022

UAE targeted

MONDAY’S deadly drone strikes by Yemen’s Houthi rebels targeting the UAE, and subsequent retaliatory attacks on...
19 Jan, 2022

New province debate

THE private bill introduced by a PML-N senator seeking a new province in south Punjab amounts to oversimplification...
19 Jan, 2022

Omicron in Karachi

WITH the wedding season in full swing, it is no surprise that the Covid positivity rate in Karachi has been touching...