French priest gets five years’ jail for assault on boy scouts

Published March 17, 2020
This Jan 13 file photo shows father Bernard Preynat arriving at a court to attend his trial on charges of sex abuse of minors. —Reuters
This Jan 13 file photo shows father Bernard Preynat arriving at a court to attend his trial on charges of sex abuse of minors. —Reuters

LYON: A defrocked Catholic priest was given a five-year jail term on Monday for sexually abusing boy scouts in his care several decades ago, a case that roiled the French Church over claims he was shielded from prosecution by his superiors.

Bernard Preynat, 75, had confessed at his trial in January in the southeastern city of Lyon to “caresses” he knew were forbidden after victims testified of the abuses they suffered at his hands.

The accusers were aged seven to 14 when the alleged crimes were committed between 1971 and 1991, when Preynat was a scout leader in Lyon.

The five-year term was less than the eight years sought by prosecutors, who accused the ex-priest of “shattering” his victims’ lives and profiting from the silence of parents and Church hierarchy.

Victims’ groups had long accused Preynat’s superior, Philippe Barbarin, of covering up the abuse, making him the most senior French priest to be caught up in the global clerical paedophilia scandal in recent years.

Barbarin, a staunch conservative who became archbishop of Lyon in 2002, was handed a six-month suspended sentence in March 2019 for not reporting crimes Preynat confessed to him in 2010.

But in January, an appeals court overturned the conviction, saying that while Barbarin should have informed the authorities, he was not criminally liable for his lack of action.

Pope Francis accepted Barbarin’s resignation earlier this month.

Preynat was allowed to continue working as a priest by the Lyon dioceses until 2015, when initial claims from a handful of alleged victims became a deluge of damning testimony.

He claimed during his trial that he had not touched any children since 1991, and faulted the church for failing to help him get treatment.

“They should have helped me ... They let me become a priest,” Preynat told the court, referring to fruitless therapy in 1967 and 1968.

He also asked forgiveness from the nine victims who testified against him — a small fraction of the alleged 85 people he took advantage of during his career, though many cases were not heard because they exceeded statutes of limitation.

Preynat, who also said he had tried to commit suicide, was defrocked by the Church last July.

The scandal cast a harsh spotlight on Barbarin, who denied last year that he covered up “these horrible facts” and claimed that “I cannot see what I am guilty of.” This month, he said the last four years had been ones of “great, great suffering” for him, adding “it is important that a page be turned.” It became the subject of an acclaimed film last year by director Francois Ozon titled “Grace a Dieu” (Thanks be to God), who collaborated with some of the victims.

Separately on Monday, a court in Saintes, southwest France, suspended the trial of a retired French surgeon accused of sexually assaulting and raping minors in what prosecutors believe could be France’s biggest paedophilia case ever.

Joel Le Scouarnec, 69, went on trial last week on charges he raped or assaulted four children, but prosecutors say he may have abused as many as 349 children over his 30-year career.

His trial was pushed back to October after French authorities closed all courthouses to all but “essential litigation” as part of measures to contain the coronavirus outbreak.

Published in Dawn, March 17th, 2020

Opinion

Editorial

Collective security
Updated 12 Mar, 2026

Collective security

Regional states need to sit down and talk. They must also pledge and work towards collective security.
Spectrum leap
12 Mar, 2026

Spectrum leap

THE sale of 480 MHz of fifth-generation telecom spectrum for $507m is a major milestone in Pakistan’s digital...
Toxic fallout
12 Mar, 2026

Toxic fallout

WARS can leave environmental scars that remain long after the fighting is over. The strikes on Iran’s oil...
Token austerity
Updated 11 Mar, 2026

Token austerity

The ‘austerity’ measures are a ritualistic response to public anger rather than a sincere attempt to reform state spending.
Lebanon on fire
11 Mar, 2026

Lebanon on fire

WHILE the entire Gulf region has become an active warzone, repercussions of this conflict have spread to the...
Canine crisis
11 Mar, 2026

Canine crisis

KARACHI’S stray dog crisis requires urgent attention. Feral canines can cause serious and lasting physical and...