US denies public was lied to about Afghan war progress

Published December 21, 2019
Secretary of Defence Mark Esper holds an end of year press conference at the Pentagon on December 20 in Arlington, Virginia. — AFP
Secretary of Defence Mark Esper holds an end of year press conference at the Pentagon on December 20 in Arlington, Virginia. — AFP

Top US defence officials denied on Friday that the military had for years hidden from the public its lack of progress in the Afghan war.

Defence Secretary Mark Esper and Joint Chiefs Chairman General Mark Milley rejected allegations that the Pentagon and other government agencies had falsely reported progress while internally officials were deeply skeptical about the war.

"This has been very transparent. It's not like this war was hiding somewhere," Esper told reporters.

"Between all the folks looking at this conflict over the years, some type of insinuation that there's been this large-scale conspiracy is just, to me, ridiculous," he said.

"I know there's an assertion out there, of some sort of coordinated lie over the course of 18 years [...] I find that a mischaracterisation," added Milley.

"I know that I and many, many others gave assessments at the time based on facts that we knew at the time," he said.

"And those were honest assessments and they were never intended to deceive either the Congress or the American people."

Last week The Washington Post began publishing what it called "The Afghanistan Papers," a trove of internal government documents documenting the failure to defeat the Taliban group and to strengthen the Afghan government.

The Post said the documents "contradict a long chorus of public statements from US presidents, military commanders and diplomats who assured Americans year after year that they were making progress in Afghanistan and the war was worth fighting".

'Very good' journalism

Milley called the Post reporting "a very, very good piece of investigative journalism".

But he insisted that documents were "backwards-looking" interviews and assessments made to review the US experience and not to mask it — unlike the Pentagon Papers, which when leaked in 1971 showed much more manipulative behaviour by the government over the Vietnam war.

Milley said US forces have been successful in rooting out Afghanistan-based Al-Qaeda, which was behind the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States, and to punish their protectors, the Taliban.

"Our original objective going into Afghanistan on the seventh of October, 2001 was to prevent Afghanistan from ever again becoming a platform to launch terrorist attacks on the continent of the United States," he said.

"And that's what we set out to do and to date that's been successful.

"For years we have clearly stated that there's not going to be a rational, reasonable chance of a military victory against the Taliban or the insurgency," Milley said.

"President Bush said that, early on, before Christmas in 2001. And that remains true today."

US mission still not complete

With 13,000 US troops still in the country and the Taliban as strong as ever, Milley called the situation a "strategic stalemate" that can only be solved by a negotiated peace settlement between the Taliban and the Kabul government.

He emphasised that the United States had a "vital national security interest" to be in the country.

"Our soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines who have given their lives in Afghanistan have not given their lives in vain."

Esper said the Pentagon had an important reason to be present.

"We have a mission in Afghanistan that is to ensure that it never again becomes a safe haven for terrorists," he said.

"So until we are confident that that mission is complete, we will retain a presence to do that."

Opinion

Editorial

Plugging the gap
06 May, 2024

Plugging the gap

IN Pakistan, bias begins at birth for the girl child as discriminatory norms, orthodox attitudes and poverty impede...
Terrains of dread
Updated 06 May, 2024

Terrains of dread

Restored faith in the police is unachievable without political commitment and interprovincial support.
Appointment rules
Updated 06 May, 2024

Appointment rules

If the judiciary had the power to self-regulate, it ought to have exercised it instead of involving the legislature.
Hasty transition
Updated 05 May, 2024

Hasty transition

Ostensibly, the aim is to exert greater control over social media and to gain more power to crack down on activists, dissidents and journalists.
One small step…
05 May, 2024

One small step…

THERE is some good news for the nation from the heavens above. On Friday, Pakistan managed to dispatch a lunar...
Not out of the woods
05 May, 2024

Not out of the woods

PAKISTAN’S economic vitals might be showing some signs of improvement, but the country is not yet out of danger....