India's sterilisation deaths

Tablets linked to the deaths of more than a dozen women who visited a sterilisation camp in India are likely to have contained a chemical compound commonly used in rat poison, two senior officials in Chhattisgarh state said on Saturday.

Preliminary tests of the antibiotic ciprocin tablets were found to contain zinc phosphide, Siddhartha Pardeshi, the chief administrator for the Bilaspur district, told Reuters.

The antibiotics were handed out at the mass sterilisation held a week ago in the impoverished state. At least 15 women have died, most of whom had attended the camp. — Reuters

Our readers are at the heart of everything we do.
Do you have a thought to share or a way we can improve? We’d love to hear it. Reach out to us at feedback@dawn.com.

World

Iran reviewing US response to 14-point plan; Trump says Washington having 'very positive' discussions with Tehran

Israel court extends detention of two Gaza flotilla activists; lawyers say pair subjected to 'severe physical abuse'

US Secretary of State Rubio to visit Vatican, Rome after Trump's row with Pope

Ganga Din

Nov 15, 2014 06:04pm

At least they reached Mars with a very low budget. This is nothing. These are just poor insignificant lives. Well done. At least your health care is on earth.

Recommend 0

Indian

Nov 15, 2014 06:10pm

Is there no policy of sterilization in Pakistan ?

Recommend 0

Zak

Nov 15, 2014 07:35pm

@Ganga Din you mean the Russian acquired probe made it.

Recommend 0

Safwan

Nov 15, 2014 08:51pm

@Indian No government in Pakistan ever tried to sterilize its people, birth control has always been pursued with other means.

Recommend 0

rohan

Nov 15, 2014 09:08pm

@zak I see you around,I'm noticing a lot of jealousy....was your visa to India denied

Recommend 0

Nov 15, 2014 09:51pm

@Safwan Indian government gives the *option* of free sterilization procedures. It also gives the option of non-invasive methods such as pills, IUDs and Norplant.

Recommend 0

N. Sid

Nov 15, 2014 10:19pm

15 deaths so far must be very insignificant for India. After all they went for sterilization. In the last 3 decades there is about 12 million female infanticides in India, means 12 million girls killed. Do some Google search.

Recommend 0

syed wasim haider

Nov 15, 2014 11:23pm

They were the poorest of poor women and were murdered by the Medics. Very very sad. Culprits must be punished.

Recommend 0

No Malice

Nov 15, 2014 11:56pm

@Ganga Din, How are the two correlated - mars mission and sterlisation disaster? The deaths are a result of corruption.

Recommend 0

PatakaGuddi

Nov 16, 2014 12:29am

@Zak What's with Pakistanis being so ignorant? I remember telling some other guy about the same mars mission. You guys should read up on it. If nothing, you'll be quite impressed with the way it was created. And btw, it was completely Bharatiya.

Recommend 0

AYZA

Nov 16, 2014 04:27am

Truly sad, is this what Modi-ites envisioned for their country? At least in Pakistan, this type of sterilization would not be tolerated even by progressives.

Recommend 0

Neeraj

Nov 16, 2014 08:21am

We have lot of problems and are dealing with them. We are not a super power like Pakistan

Recommend 0

Meet

Nov 16, 2014 09:51am

@Neeraj lol, super power pakistan!!!!

Recommend 0

mihir

Nov 16, 2014 10:04am

i remember a few years back in pakistan drugs made by afroze chemicals wiped out few hundred patients in punjab, this seems to be a similar incident , anything happend to afroze chemicals and its directors after that ?

Recommend 0

Ahtesham

Nov 16, 2014 02:56pm

So shame on Indian. What's going on???

Recommend 0

Dr Carla

Nov 16, 2014 04:03pm

@Zak First gain some GK then comment. China tried Russian equipment and failed to reach Mars NOT India (I wish India could afford expensive equipment from Europe, US and Russia), India could not afford expensive foreign equipment they are all indigenous . You must be in primary school but still expect some basic GK.

Recommend 0

Dr Carla

Nov 16, 2014 04:06pm

@Neeraj You are right, Pakistan is Superpower part of G1 nations. India is long way to go to reach Pakistan, India is still lurking in G20 (in 10th position)

Recommend 0

M. Siddique

Nov 16, 2014 08:40pm

The country which has aspirations to be a super power and threatening its neighbors to no end must look inward and take care of its own people first.

Recommend 0

G. Din

Nov 16, 2014 09:18pm

Although this sort of negligence is indefensible but negligence does occur occasionally even in a rich and advanced country as the US. Remind yourselves, Pakistanis, of the recent death of a celebrated comedienne, Joan Rivers, in a New York clinic after a very routine procedure.

Recommend 0

sohnamal

Nov 17, 2014 01:34am

wow just india reaches to Mars and whats going on in india'spoor ?

Recommend 0

Rajesh

Nov 17, 2014 08:52am

Such gross negligence should not be tolerated.. I am however afraid that Indians will lose faith in contraception, due to such occurrences.. We have to aggressively raise awareness on Small Families (2 children max).. We have to reduce the total national fertility from 2.4 to 1.5 in 10 years time.. & for that these most backward states (Bihar/MP/CG/JH/Raj/UP) are crucial..

Recommend 0

Nov 17, 2014 11:26am

Why only women? sterilize the men too! Pakistani or not, human above all.

Recommend 0

Waqar Ahmad

Nov 17, 2014 03:47pm

I am appalled by the hateful comments under this tragic news. A tragic incident which can happen anywhere regardless of country or nation but playing politics over such news is a shameful act. Sterilisation is a effective birth-control method optimal for under-developed countries and communities with low or no education and it was very good initiative by Indian Govt. The only thing which scares me that this incident will spread panic among masses and this campaign will be affected badly. We are grown up and should act like that.

Recommend 0

sky

Nov 17, 2014 04:53pm

No No No....india is a"Great" democracy this news should be wrong......ohhh yes...if its Pakistan than its a true......

Recommend 0

Abbas Ali

Nov 17, 2014 05:22pm

I am surprised at some of the comments. People have died, and it is not time for fun. I fail to understand, what was rat poison doing in the antibiotic manufacturing process. Life is so cheap. These people will end up as statistic with the passage of time.

Recommend 0

Sunil

Nov 17, 2014 10:23pm

Indian government hospitals in the cities, and state government clinics are in worst shape, dogs either roaming in the wards or sleeping under the patients beds, lavatories over flowing, with foul smell. Pharmaceutical companies, with worst quality drugs are supplied in these hospitals, whose owners have political connections.

Recommend 0

Kamal

Nov 18, 2014 08:10am

@Indian@ We have but not like the embarrassed one of Chhatisgarh,India.

Recommend 0

A For A

Nov 18, 2014 08:39am

@N. Sid Google news is also written by some arrogant, stupid human being. Don't think Google is God and its all words come out of God's mouth

Recommend 0

A For A

Nov 18, 2014 08:41am

@AYZA Pakistan has lots of 'suicide bombers' to control its population. No need to 'sterilize' the women ....Huh.

Recommend 0

Naveed I

Nov 18, 2014 12:49pm

India's defense reinforcement obsession is in vain, what would one get from invading a poverty-plagued India? Send a ambulance to rescue of these victims instead of space-craft to Mars.

Recommend 0

Billu

Nov 18, 2014 07:34pm

Both Indian and Pakistanis are so quick to criticise each other, especially in forums such as these. Furthermore, both India and Pakistan have their share of social problems and challenges to tackle. One day perhaps instead of fighting against each other over petty arguments, they could fight together to tackle the problems that they each face... Insha'Allah...

Recommend 0

Danish Haider

Nov 19, 2014 01:23am

Sad news. I feel sorry for the unfortunate ladies. Any practical Muslim cannot make fun of deaths. Life regardless of religion is very precious as per the divine book - Al Quran.

Recommend 0

Anser Azim

Nov 19, 2014 06:55am

Over 100 patients sterilized using same tools with only spirit to sterilize the tools. I believe even Somali medics have some better surgical ethics. Lives have been lost and some Indian citizens are trying to defend this horror. it's not an indo-pak cricket match. Just get over it Mars mission ! what a joke when half the population lacks clean water and basic sanitation and eases in the open.....

Recommend 0

A C Rao

Nov 19, 2014 07:47am

As a surgeon I pointed as a comment on first day of this unfortunate event in one of the paper ' surgery alone is unlikely cause of this unfortunate event whole team is culpable ' . Safety is every ones responsibility . In western countries like in USA , Joint Commission , state and federal health departments sets the standards , follows the events corrects them , end less on going process . In India or Pakistan do not have have such organizations with power o over see all health related issues and activities , arresting the culprits will not salve the problem , with out adequate supervision of health professionals .

Recommend 0

Human

Nov 19, 2014 03:00pm

I wonder how people start commenting without any reading or knowledge. Deaths were due to an adulterated antibiotic ciplofloxacine.. no relation to surgical procedure at all. This medicine is given for non surgical work also throughout the world. But here the medicine batch was contaminated. No faults of doctor or surgical procedure.. life never comes cheap and the culprits who passed this batch need to be punished.

Recommend 0

Chanakya

Nov 20, 2014 01:01am

Poverty is a curse, everywhere.

Recommend 0

Dr Carla

Nov 20, 2014 01:13pm

Why these thing happence only in particular states? people in those states are corrupt.

Recommend 0

Branded Content

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa expands climate action with one Million Tree Drive and forest reforms

The province is turning policy into action through a series of large scale programmes aimed at rebuilding ecosystems and improving resilience against rising climate pressures.

Taptap Send, Arshad Nadeem partner to highlight Pakistan’s unsung champions

The initiative comes at a time when cricket continues to dominate national attention, often overshadowing achievements in other sports.

NexGen Auto (Nishat Group) to Introduce iCAUR in Pakistan

As one of Pakistan’s leading business groups, Nishat Group operates across key sectors including textiles, cement, banking, insurance, power and agriculture.