Stone Wars and Drone Wars

Published August 2, 2013
Protestors clash with police in Srinagar.—Photo by AFP
Protestors clash with police in Srinagar.—Photo by AFP
Indian Policemen detain an activist of The All Parties Hurriyat Conference, an umbrella group of separatists, outside a hotel in Srinagar, India.—Photo by AP
Indian Policemen detain an activist of The All Parties Hurriyat Conference, an umbrella group of separatists, outside a hotel in Srinagar, India.—Photo by AP
The government of Kashmir has rejected wide-scale DNA testing of bodies in thousands of unmarked graves despite pleas by the families of those who disappeared during two decades of fighting in the restive region. The Tombstone reads, "unidentified fifteen year old boy shot and killed by Border Security Force soldiers on 5th September 2003."—Photo by AP
The government of Kashmir has rejected wide-scale DNA testing of bodies in thousands of unmarked graves despite pleas by the families of those who disappeared during two decades of fighting in the restive region. The Tombstone reads, "unidentified fifteen year old boy shot and killed by Border Security Force soldiers on 5th September 2003."—Photo by AP
A US Predator drone flies over the moon.—Photo by AP
A US Predator drone flies over the moon.—Photo by AP
A woman grieves in Kashmir, as a major fire gutted a 200-year-old, revered Sufi Muslim shrine in Indian Kashmir, sparking clashes between police and residents in the region's summer capital Srinagar, police said.—Photo by AFP
A woman grieves in Kashmir, as a major fire gutted a 200-year-old, revered Sufi Muslim shrine in Indian Kashmir, sparking clashes between police and residents in the region's summer capital Srinagar, police said.—Photo by AFP
People shout pro-freedom slogans in Indian occupied Kashmir. Authorities imposed an indefinite curfew in Indian Kashmir ahead of a separatist rally, the latest in a series of protests against Indian rule in the disputed Himalayan region.—Photo by Reuters
People shout pro-freedom slogans in Indian occupied Kashmir. Authorities imposed an indefinite curfew in Indian Kashmir ahead of a separatist rally, the latest in a series of protests against Indian rule in the disputed Himalayan region.—Photo by Reuters
Volunteers remove debris from a damaged shrine that held a few relics from Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jeelani after it caught fire in downtown Srinagar, India.—Photo by AP
Volunteers remove debris from a damaged shrine that held a few relics from Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jeelani after it caught fire in downtown Srinagar, India.—Photo by AP
Tribesmen hold pieces of a missile at the site of a missile attack in Mir Ali on the outskirts of Miranshah near the Afghan border.—Photo by AFP
Tribesmen hold pieces of a missile at the site of a missile attack in Mir Ali on the outskirts of Miranshah near the Afghan border.—Photo by AFP
Post drone attack in Miranshah, Waziristan.—File Photo
Post drone attack in Miranshah, Waziristan.—File Photo

Mohammad Junaid’s evocative essay “The Stone Wars” was published last week by Guernica Magazine. Taking readers into the strike-afflicted, trash strewn streets of an Anantnag under curfew, Junaid presents the oddity of a war that has become old but whose wounds remain freshly inflicted on every generation.

The boys of today’s Kashmir, like the boys who came before them, are still fighting but the weapons are different, if not new. When night falls on curfew days, they gather stones in large piles. It is with these stones and from a distance that they pelt the Indian forces stationed next to schools and inside bazaars. Stones, instead of rifles or bullets, are the weapon of Kashmir’s newest fighters. They choose stones because stones make their point, pieces of earth fighting for the pieces of earth that are occupied, that must be freed.

When a war is fought for a long time, when it recedes from the memories of others who do not live its realities, it is perhaps this inversion between age and tactic that results. There is no longer a need for an innovative weapon, the groundbreaking technology that will turn the tide of the struggle. There are no new guns that will further a cause, be the inventive measure that carries over to decisive victory. There is a repetitive choreography to old wars; and Junaid reveals it. The boys who throw the stones do not intend to hurt the soldiers, and they rarely do. Their war is against an idea, the idea of domination that persists, that is fought with piles of stones gathered from the valley that cannot be free.

As the random juxtapositions of email would arrange, I read “The Stone Wars” soon after I had concluded reading a press release regarding US Secretary of State John Kerry’s visit to Islamabad. Drones are on the agenda, the news item proclaimed, and the leaders were expected to discuss their future. The drone war is not as old or as complicated as the Kashmir conflict, with its iterations of agreements, counter agreements, cease fires, and lines of control, and its many thousands dead and disappeared. Its choreography of inaction, of either side being cemented into a position of domination and submission, is however beginning to be just as apparent. The Americans know what they are doing; they make paeans and platitudes and affirm support and declare respect. The Pakistanis protest, hem and shrug. Like the occupation in Kashmir, the drones go on. Sometimes they stop, for a week or a month, and then they begin again, unleashing with the slickness of their superior spying, strikes that kill unknown numbers.

The stone wars of Kashmir, and the drone wars in Pakistan have this little bit in common, the vast chasms of power between those that dominate and those that bear domination. As wars become old, the steps in this choreography become important, even more crucial than victory. In the steps and pauses becomes entrenched a moral message that seeks to defeat the powerful, the unthinking, the domineering— not by the force of what is mightier but what is right and fair and just. In the hours before Secretary Kerry landed in Pakistan, where he would be hushed away to one high-level meeting after another, Amnesty International made a call for accountability, for any move forward, and an investigation on the serious allegations of unlawful deaths occurring in the valley. It was like a stone, a small pebble thrown against an edifice of silent, persistent injustice that has not budged much, that seems here to stay. Those who will take up the call sign a petition, write an article, register their protest are those that believe that there are other ways of warfare than only annihilation.

Opinion

Casualties of war
17 Sep 2021

Casualties of war

As we ruminate over the consequences of America making a mockery of international law, it is equally important to take an inward
Love of wealth
17 Sep 2021

Love of wealth

Those obsessed with wealth are likely to be involved in corrupt practices.
Pro-rich growth
17 Sep 2021

Pro-rich growth

Spin doctors will continue to tell tales of prosperity.

Editorial

TTP amnesty?
Updated 17 Sep 2021

TTP amnesty?

Before the pros and cons of any amnesty offer are considered, it would be wise to examine the major ‘achievements’ of the TTP.
17 Sep 2021

Media regulation

THE needless controversy over media regulation may finally be heading for a resolution. In a meeting with ...
17 Sep 2021

Refusing audit

THE continuous resistance put up by several public-sector organisations to submitting their accounts for audit by ...
Aid for Afghans
16 Sep 2021

Aid for Afghans

Humanitarian aid can resume even if the world decides to hold back on formal recognition of the regime for now.
16 Sep 2021

Wheat price

THE government’s decision to raise the wheat release price, or the rate at which provinces issue their grain ...
16 Sep 2021

Keeping the press out

ON Monday, the government yet again displayed its rising contempt for the freedom of press — this time in...