Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Tales of woe

Published May 19, 2013 10:00am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:


They say that Pakistan is witnessing a literary renaissance; be they from small villages or urban metropolises, Pakistani fiction writers are winning accolades on many a literary platform. Recently, Intizar Husain, one of Pakistan’s greatest literary voices in Urdu, was published by the New York Review of Books and is also a finalist for the Man Booker International Prize 2013. However, the refrain in all these stories is the lack of presence of Pakistani publishers.

Writer and translator, Musharraf Ali Farooqi summed up the dilemma in a single statement: “[The] publishing industry does not exist in Pakistan in any meaningful sense.” Farooqi’s novels, translations as well as one of his illustrated works have all been published outside the country: mainly in India. “Publishing in India is a proper industry with all the protocols and standards one expects. It is the largest publishing industry in South Asia, and worldwide it is the only publishing market that is showing strong growth. I have published different projects with six publishers in India over a period of 13 years and the experience has been great.”

The situation is not totally bleak, however. ILQA Publications is the new kid on the block — they have recently published the Urdu translation of Bapsi Sidhwa’s The Crow Eaters, titled Junglewala Sahib as well as her latest short story collection, Their Language of Love. Sidhwa fondly talked about the experience of being published in Pakistan: “[ILQA] bought the rights to Their Language of Love from Penguin, India, and published and distributed it well. They also bought the rights to publish my previous novels from me. I found the terms they offered were fair and they paid the advance promptly.”

ILQA’s publishing quality may not be at par with international standards, with concerns being raised regarding their editing quality and distribution networks, however, they are targeting a larger audience with their low-cost paperback as well as hardcover publications. Amir Riaz, general manager at ILQA elaborates: “Our publishing venture is young, yet in less than four years we have published more than 45 titles catering to children including fiction, poetry, research, classics as well as books targeting young adults. Majority of what we publish is fiction, both in English and Urdu.

“As there is no institution in Pakistan that helps to develop professionals for book publishing and its related fields like editing, proofreading, jacket designing and layouts, we find it very difficult to hire. Locally published books are badly edited, be they in English or Urdu, with glaring errors and unattractive cover designs. With our experience in dealing with foreign books and publishers, we are consciously trying to bring our standards at par.”

Bina Shah, with four novels and two short story collections to her credit, is probably among a handful of English fiction writers to have been published in Pakistan — by Oxford University Press, Karachi and Alhamra in Islamabad. Though she did not face any major glitches, according to her, “marketing and distribution have always been in need of more support and attention, with not enough people to do the job. You really have to do a great deal of self-promotion. In addition, in recent years, with Alhamra and even SAMA going inactive, and OUP deciding to no longer publish original fiction, writers in Pakistan are pretty blocked in their attempts to break-through.”

With only a few names sought out by international as well as local publishing houses, new and upcoming writers face a grim reality: “Publishers and agents abroad are not that interested in Pakistani writing, no matter what they may have said. Once they have one or two Pakistanis on their lists, they’re not really looking for any more. And once the ‘war on terror’ changes focus or locus, Pakistan will no longer be ‘terrorist flavour of the month’ and there will be even less attention on whatever commercial fiction might have served that need,” adds Shah.

Ayesha Salman, whose debut novel Blue Dust was published by Roli Books in India, recounts the trials of being a first time writer searching for a publisher in Pakistan: “The publisher I tried, quite a prominent one in Pakistan I might add, did not want to take a chance on the book by funding it so the editors suggested that I pay for the publication myself. I was disheartened and angry about the whole thing and so I refused. I was also aware that being published in Pakistan would not expose me to the wider market so I turned my attention to India.”

Her experience is India was no better when, two years after being accepted by one of India’s largest publishing houses, she was informed that her novel was “not really for them anymore.” It was then that Roli Books accepted the manuscript.

“Publishers in Pakistan believe there isn’t a market for English literary fiction in Pakistan so they worry about losses. I refute that. I think readership of English fiction in Pakistan is huge, especially for new and emerging Pakistani writers and it is growing all the time. We need to encourage our writers to become part of the international landscape of fiction writers.”

With regards to Urdu, many claim that it is dying out and so are its readers; in reality, the state of the Urdu publishing industry in Pakistan is much more optimistic. Sang-i-Meel Publications, though they publish in English, are known for their high-quality Urdu paperbacks and hard-covers. Managing director Afzaal Ahmed elaborates: “We normally publish Urdu fiction, history, Urdu criticism, travelogues, and also reprint rare books about pre-Partition times.” Talking about the problems Urdu writers face while trying to get their work published locally, he pointed out how, “If someone approaches publishers without good references like already published pieces in newspapers, journals or literary magazines, he cannot convince the publisher easily. Because very few books even manage to break even, new authors get de-motivated”.

Apart from battling piracy and copyright issues, publishers here are also faced with a constant threat and so monitor what they publish. Controversial topics are avoided at all cost, and as a result, many stick to publishing non-fiction. Grants and funding on an institutional level have encouraged research-based books to be published widely but fiction clearly lags behind.


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (16) Closed

Naresh May 19, 2013 04:12pm
India of today is not merely made by Hindus. I'm a Hindu by the way. Every country on earth strives to be the best in all fields. So please don't look down on any other country just because we are ahead of them.
Pakistani May 19, 2013 05:31pm
Every country in the world has its merits and demerits. No country is perfect. India has been there for about 66 yrs, and just became bombing market in last 20 yrs and so, and thats mainly because of American outsourcing and Internet.
Ahmed May 19, 2013 10:40pm
I thought after going through three wars and proxy wars, we have come to realization that the only way we both could grow and help 300 million people (and growing) sleeping on the roads by joining hands. And here we are again talking indu and Muslim.... and still claim we are better...
Akram khan May 19, 2013 09:50am
Thanks to India for helping pakistani writers.
Pakistani May 19, 2013 05:25pm
Islam is not against knowledge, literature, books, buplishing etc. therefore, secularism has nothing to do with this. It's ignorance of the people, both in and outside of the Pakistan.
Ali May 19, 2013 11:18pm
Likewise, Earth should not compete with Moon?
Ali May 19, 2013 11:19pm
Hopefully we can get Pakistani publishing industry on track otherwise it is just lost business for Pakistani economy. Tomorrow countries like UAE may provide even better service but that wouldn't do any good to Pakistani economy --- we need these services in Pakistan.
Mustafa Razavi May 20, 2013 12:15am
Arun; India is much bigger market for what? Certainly not what is called literature bu Urdu speaking people.
Arun May 19, 2013 05:51am
Haneen Rafi needs to accept India for what it is, swallow her pride, and move on. India is a much bigger market than Pakistan. When your ancestors decided to separate from India, it was like the Moon separating from Earth. The Moon should not try to compete with the Earth. It should accept it for what it is, and accept itself for what it is. All the fantasies of Pakistan being better than India in every respect is just that: fantasies. They were propagated by people who underestimated Hindus (and continue to). Pakistan will be better than India in some things. Cherish those, and accept where you are not.
Aniket May 19, 2013 06:45pm
@Naved: Of course the publishers are out there to make money. Just like any other industry. Every industry is out there to make money. Making money is a good thing, unless someone adapts unethical means to earn it. It is the lack of systems wherein an industry could develop, that you are complaining of. Really, it's a shame that a country the size of Pakistan does not have a proper publishing industry. What have the Governments been doing all this while? What have the educated classes, universities, businesses, intellectuals been doing all this while? Beats the imagination, really.
Madhu Shanmughan May 19, 2013 07:13pm
Arun, when we talk about publishing business, just talk about that - don't drag other narrow stuff into the discussion. People like you are spoiling the image of India and Indians.
AHMAD May 19, 2013 08:35pm
Your writing is full of hate. Pakistan is a reality and you can not deny it. We live in real world ( some us do not ). We know that there has never been any match between India and Pakistan. India is a huge country with is blessed with resources such as wealth, education and natural resources. It is our politicians who nearly destroyed Pakistan. We never wanted to be, who we are not. We simply wanted to make model secular Istamic state for our children and grand children. At least that my parents tought they were doing. I hope God the Almighty will fulfill my parents dream. My parents did not hate Hindus or India.
umesh bhagwat May 19, 2013 01:39pm
literature knows no boundaries!
Naved May 19, 2013 11:11am
Two years back I got my first book ( a collection of essays ) published in Pakistan. First of all almost all publisher whom I contacted refused to print the book on their expenses without even seeing the contents. Although around 50% of my essays were printed in a newspaper before. Unfortunately, our publisher are out there just to make money. Its totally commercial affair. No patronage what so ever is available for the new writers. You spend a lot of your time and utilize your talent to write some thing meaningful and then spend your own money to get the book printed. After that look for the platform to market it. This is the story of most of the new writers in Pakistan, who have no connections in the field. Financially speaking, writing a book is not a viable activity for majority of the writers in Pakistan, specially for the new ones.
alan May 19, 2013 03:25pm
is this the country that Jinnah wanted...absolutely not...
Avtar May 19, 2013 12:02pm
If memory serves me right, even Musharraf and Nawaz Sharif published their autobiographies in India. This is despite the fact Musharraf and his generals considered India to be their arch enemy. A shift toward secularism in Pakistan may help change the environment for publishing industry.