• Ex-PM Brown terms Musk’s allegations ‘complete fabrication’
• Humza Yousaf reminds X boss how Pakistani MP helped secure extradition of murderers
LONDON: Tech billionaire Elon Musk seems to be playing a dangerous game, whipping up furore over a historic grooming scandal in what appears to be an attempt to target the Labour government of UK PM Keir Starmer.
Over the past week, the tech entrepreneur has attacked the UK government over grooming gangs, using his platform X to accuse one key Labour leader of being a “rape genocide apologist”, and calling for her and Starmer to be jailed.
On Monday, Starmer had hit out against politicians and activists “spreading lies and misinformation” over grooming gangs, accusing opposition lawmakers of “jumping on a bandwagon” and “amplifying what the far-right is saying” to gain attention.
Online debate had now “crossed a line”, resulting in threats against parliamentarians, including Safeguarding Minister Jess Phillips, he said.
“We have seen this playbook many times — whipping up of intimidation and of threats of violence, hoping that the media will amplify it,” Starmer said.
“Those who are spreading lies and misinformation as far and as wide as possible are not interested in victims, they’re interested in themselves,” he added.
Debate around grooming gangs was reignited this week after it was reported that Phillips rejected Oldham Council’s request for a government-led inquiry into historical child sexual exploitation in the town, in favour of a local investigation.
The grooming scandal, which came to light in the 2010s, involved the systematic abuse of thousands of girls in towns such as Rotherham, Rochdale and Oldham. A 2014 report estimated that 1,400 children were exploited in Rotherham between 1997 and 2013, primarily by men of Pakistani heritage.
Keir Starmer, as head of the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) from 2008 to 2013, revised CPS policies to improve responses to such cases, but some early decisions not to prosecute remain controversial.
Musk’s allegations reference a misinterpreted 2008 Home Office memo, suggesting officers allowed abuse to continue. However, Nazir Afzal, a former prosecutor who secured convictions in these cases, clarified that no such directive existed. Afzal also credited Starmer for reforms that raised CPS conviction rates for sex abuse cases. Musk also claimed that the Labour PM at the time issued a circular to UK police forces effectively telling them not to prosecute rape gangs.
But Gordon Brown, who was PM at the time of the incident in question, claimed that allegations made by Musk about how he dealt with child grooming gangs are “a complete fabrication”.
Kriss Donald case
Also on Tuesday, one of Musk’s retweets prompted a response from the former First Minister of Scotland, Humza Yousaf, who responded to a comment regarding the racially motivated murder of 15-year-old Kriss Donald in 2004.
Musk quoted a post about the incident by Keith Woods, a far-right Irish activist, expressing that it was “the first time [he’d] heard of this.”
Responding to Musk, Yousaf posted: “Let me also be the first to tell you that it was a Scottish-Pakistani MP at the time, Mohammad Sarwar, who travelled to Pakistan to ensure Kriss Donald’s evil killers were extradited back to Scotland to face the full force of the law.”
In March 2004, Donald was abducted in a random attack from Glasgow by five men linked to a local British Pakistani gang. Two men were convicted over the murder, but three of the accused fled to Pakistan, which lacked an extradition treaty with the UK at the time.
Mohammad Sarwar, who was MP for Glasgow Central at the time, played a crucial role in persuading the Pakistani government to extradite the fugitives. The suspects were subsequently returned to Scotland where they faced criminal sentences.
Kriss Donald’s family consistently opposed the far-right’s exploitation of the tragedy. His mother emphasised that her son was a victim of gang violence, urging the public not to target the Asian community.
Despite her appeals, far-right groups, including the British National Party (BNP) and Patriotic Alternative, have used Donald’s case to promote their agendas.
Keith Woods, the far-right activist whose post Musk shared, also has a history of promoting anti-Semitic and white nationalist narratives.
Published in Dawn, January 8th, 2025
