Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


A spectacle ends


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

WHAT changed four days later? The ECP remained intact. So did the assemblies and the government. The process of appointing a caretaker government remained essentially unchanged. The conditions for individuals contesting polls will continue to be those listed in the constitution already. This being Pakistan, we had plenty of conspiracy theories, from threats from anti-democracy forces to the ruling party trying to set up a political spoiler in Punjab. But did anything useful come of the drama the country has been alternately captivated by and exhausted of these last few days?

For one, both the opposition and the ruling coalition managed to pull some maturity out of their hats. In the final analysis, the opposition didn’t take the opportunity to destabilise the current set-up, instead declaring their stand against unconstitutional moves while still pointing out the many ways in which the administration has failed the people of Pakistan. The ruling party managed an important balancing act, refraining from physically restraining the protesters as they made their way closer to parliament and responding to Dr Qadri with a commission high-profile enough to demonstrate that it took him seriously, but ultimately without allowing any disruptions of the constitution. The familiar accountability-before-elections concept wasn’t allowed to delay a democratic transition — at least not yet — but Dr Qadri’s demands, if implemented, might yet lead to closer scrutiny of election candidates and a weeding out of at least the obviously rotten ones.

And while it may have ended with a whimper, in many ways the protest strengthened the system it was suspected — and not unjustifiably, given Pakistan’s history of establishment interference — of threatening. Tens of thousands of people, some with their children, took out several days from life and work to suffer the Islamabad winter. They may not have fully understood the maulana’s demands any more than the rest of us did, and many, if not most, were simply following the orders of their spiritual leader. But they were also there in a democratic spirit: to register their grievances against an elected government. Many of the problems they listed — corruption, lack of law and order, energy shortages, unemployment — are precisely the kinds of things that a nation has the right to complain about. Dr Qadri’s series of unreasonable deadlines and his shifting agendas may have been irresponsible. But in a country where a mob of a few dozen people cannot express outrage without violence or rioting, the conduct of his followers did stand out as an example of Pakistanis peacefully exercising their democratic right to protest.

Comments (5) Closed

Dr. D. Prithipaul Jan 19, 2013 10:56pm
Qadri's peaceful movement has still a very long way to go to match Mahatma Gandhi's non-violent struggle against a mighty empire, or Jaya Prakash Narayan's protest against Indira Gandhi's Emergency rule. The difference consists in the Gandhian action being simply animated by ethical imperatives, while Qadri's initiative, resting on traditional religious impulses, will only go this far. Islam and ahimsa are antithetical. Jinnah proved it. Pakistan is the proof. As the sons of Jinnah, the Mullahs will absorb Qadri's so called revolution - if they have not already done so.
DrTK Jan 19, 2013 04:09pm
At last a sane appraisal. Surely, it was not all about Dr. Qadri; what about the tens of thousands who, as you put it " took 4 days out of their time to brave the Islamabad skies" and register their protest? The Anchors on TV talk shows do them a great disservice when they call them poor gullible people! Its not Dr. Qadri, but these people whose demands should be taken seriously. There are millions like them who did not participate but they do feel like them. This is the writing on the wall, and future people who want to offer themselves for the leadership of this Nation, had better take heed!!!
Syed Ahmed Jan 19, 2013 03:42pm
Dr. Qadri proved that Pakistani's can put across their legitimate demands in a very peaceful and organized manner despite Dr. Rehman Maliks instigating actions.
khanm Jan 19, 2013 08:33am
No need to be serious. it was just a stage show. We have the president and no one can out smart him......
Iftikhar Husain Jan 19, 2013 12:40pm
The editorial has expressed the situation correctly it is a wake up call for all the political parties that they have understood the real cause of their troubles. They will strike back if not heard.