Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


In transit


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

AS I write this on the terrace restaurant of a hotel in the hills in Sri Lanka, there’s a small river tumbling over huge boulders a few feet away. The sound of rushing water is constant. There are only four rooms in this remote spot, and no Internet. None of my Sri Lankan friends have even heard of it.

We arrived here on Saturday, driving straight from Colombo airport on our way back from Hanoi. Gamini, our driver and friend, took a little known route through some spectacular forests and rubber-tree plantations. Over the years, one of the delights of spending time in Sri Lanka has been the discovery of out of the way spots and byways.

After spending a fortnight in Vietnam, I have been reflecting on the cultural and social differences between Southeast and South Asia. And while I have yet to visit Singapore, Cambodia, Malaysia and Thailand, talking to friends who have, and reading about the region, I have the impression that people are more inclined to follow the rules than they are in South Asia.

In Vietnam, for instance, we used taxis to get around constantly. Not only are they cheap, but run strictly according to their meters; not once did we get the impression that our drivers were deliberately taking the long route to jack up the fare. Tips were neither demanded nor expected.

Although the two hotels we stayed at were fairly basic, everything worked and cleanliness was of a high standard. The staff were helpful, and again, made no demands for tips. Language was a problem, though: very few people in the tourism industry spoke any English or French.The lack of the latter was a surprise as Vietnam was part of the French empire until 1954, so I expected some vestige of French cultural influence to have lingered, much as it has in ex-British colonies. But apart from some splendid colonial architecture in Hanoi, there is little else to indicate that Vietnam was ruled for a long period by the French. No doubt the bitterness of the parting has something to do with this.

But the colonial era buildings are the only redeeming architectural feature in Hanoi. Other structures are of either hideously overpowering, Soviet-style design, or cheap, shoddy modern constructions. And despite the general adherence to rules and regulations, traffic seems to be chaotic with scooters, bicycles and motorbikes competing for road space with cars in what seems an utterly suicidal manner.

The lack of English-language skills is odd because there are, according to the Viet Nam News, 284 tourism schools in the country, with demands for more, given the constant increase in the number of tourists flocking to this destination. One of the most popular sites is Halong Bay. This corner of the South China Sea is dotted with nearly 2,000 tiny uninhabited islands composed largely of spectacular sandstone rocks, with vines and shrubs clinging to the vertical sides.

We got on a junk to tour this fascinating seascape for two days, and were very well looked after by the staff. I asked our English-speaking guide how he felt when he was taking American tourists on tour. He replied that he felt no resentment or anger, despite the devastation caused by the United States in the war of liberation that ended in 1975. “And how about the Chinese?” I asked.

He laughed and replied that every Vietnamese hated the Chinese. It is important to recall here that for centuries, China has been viewed as the regional bully: soon after the Americans pulled out in 1975, there was a short but fierce war between Vietnam and China which saw the latter suffering heavy casualties.

Another English-speaking Vietnamese I met was very depressed about the lack of political choices his people had: nothing ever changes here, he said. The same faces, the same party, he went on to complain. The people have no rights. I mentioned that we in Pakistan have too many political choices, and most of them are bad. Rather bad choices than none, was his view.

But in Sri Lanka, the ruling party and the ruling family are progressively taking over the political landscape in a most alarming manner. The media and the opposition have already been bullied and bribed into silence. And now, the government is in a bitter struggle with the judiciary in its ongoing attempt to sack the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

Ms Bandarnaike, the Chief Justice, has refused to back down from a number of rulings challenging the government’s intention to pass legislation to further strengthen its grip on power. In retaliation, the government has moved a number of corruption cases against her and her husband.

Although a government appointee, Ms Bandarnaike has committed the cardinal sin of challenging the government, and as a result, there is a deadlock that is being watched here and abroad as an indicator of the direction Sri Lanka is taking. This resonates deeply with Pakistanis, given our experience of a judiciary that has made governing virtually impossible.

In contrast with the bit of Southeast Asia I have just travelled in, South Asia seems chaotic and almost dysfunctional. And yet, for me at least, this freewheeling spirit is an essential part of our DNA. In Hanoi, the officialdom we came into contact with at the airport was stone-faced bureaucrats with not a smile or a word of welcome. Visas and passports were carefully scrutinised, and in my case, the top immigration officer was summoned to examine my green Pakistani passport and the visa it contained.

No such scrutiny in Colombo where, as always, we were waved through with the most casual of examination: once we had paid the visa fee, nobody was much concerned about anything else. And nor were our passports demanded at every hotel here the way they are in Vietnam.

After years of being hassled by immigration officials in different parts of the world, there’s much to admire in a system that takes a more laid back approach to visitors.

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (13) Closed

Tony Jan 07, 2013 01:36am
Mr Irfan Husain, I am a Catholic originally from Goa, India. I always read your articles with a lot of interest. And in most cases I find myself in agreement with most of the views expressed by you. It appears you love travelling and writing from various locations of the world. I would love you visiting India some time and writing your experiences from there. But there is one thing about can not generalize about anything in India, because it is a continental country like Europe, where there is huge diversity between various States. Not just in weather, like extremely hot desert climate of Rajasthan to the wettest place in the world of Cherrapunji in Meghalaya where you see thick jungles. then snowing mountains of Himachal/ Ladakh / Sikkim / Arunachal / Uttarakhand to hot humid sea shores of Tamil Nadu. Food habits, clothing, languages, culture...everything so different in various States, as if you are visiting different countries. In your article you mentioned that South Asia is chaotic and disfunctional. This Statement can not be applied to whole of India, which is the centre of South Asia. . Therefore, I will not agree with you on this... Your statement might be true for say some areas of Manipur State or Assam.... but even in North East, States like Mizoram and Meghalaya, which are very peaceful and orderly. Same is the case with say Goa, Kerala or interior parts of most states, which are quiet, orderly and far from chaotic and certainly not disfunctional. Cities like Kolkata might be chaotic, but a city like Chandigarh is orderly and very functional.
Rashid Sultan Jan 07, 2013 04:07pm
What else would you expect Irfan, another Pakistani or me to travel on???
rich Jan 07, 2013 12:24pm
as usual irfan saab only post agreeable to ur views are posted
Avi D. Jan 07, 2013 04:37am
I liked the comment the local Vietenamese made "Rather bad choices than none, was his view". I think this applies to most of the countries in the world, probably with exception of Scandinavian countries. In the US, the Tea Party which an integral part of the Republican party, leaves practically no choice but to vote Democrats who are reasonable. In SE Asia there are more parties than people. In India most of the regions/states have 3-4 regional parties which paralyze the central governance. Indeed!! most of the people in the world are left with the bad choices as talented individuals are staying away from politics.
Nasah (USA) Jan 07, 2013 04:08am
You have great life Irfan Husain -- eating in Vietnam -- sleeping in Sri Lanka
Baber Khan Jan 07, 2013 11:58am
Mr. Irfan, I honestly have problem comprhending the following statement from your writeup: "This resonates deeply with Pakistanis, given our experience of a judiciary that has made governing virtually impossible." What "governing" are you talking about that our judiciary has made impossible? Did any such thing as "governing" ever existed during our present democratic era?
milind Jan 07, 2013 02:39am
The article is good how ever one thing i just catch my eyebrow why vitenam immigration offical ask and verified your passport and visa compare to sri lanka so that means pakistan earn very good reputation in western world and carried to south asian country brave confession by author
Paras Jan 07, 2013 11:09am
I too am from India and have traveled far and wide, but in my experience most cities are pretty much similar when it comes to refusing to abide by basic rules, e.g. traffic rules. In deep south it is even worse. Corruption level, government slackness etc. are pretty even across the country.
george Jan 07, 2013 09:32am
For two months we have lived on street food in Jakarta. And believe me, no problem we had. The people in those part of the world are far more cleaner. Even the maids who knock at your door every morning, are neatly dressed. It is the question of taste. Those south east asian people are also more polite and courteous. they also speak in a lower tone unlike south asian people.
g.a.shirazi Jan 06, 2013 11:01pm
Seems like you are having a great time in SE Asia. Clean hotel and cheap food what else you need. I was in Sehwan Shreef in Sindh recently where I could not find neither clean hotel or cheap food. Enjoy it while you can. I am surprised that you still travel on the green passport.
peddarowdy Jan 08, 2013 01:19pm
I envy your travelling exploits. Also, your success with writing. I love the way you write. Its opinionated but you cannot disagree with whatever you say.
Tribal Manto Jan 07, 2013 07:56am
It is always a pleasure to read your articles, sir. As you travelled so extensively, hopefully, you would have compiled a book of your itineraries by now, and that would be a feast to read as well.
Ariff Jan 07, 2013 03:14pm
Mr.Tony, It will be extremely for Mr.Irfan Husain to visit as he holds a Pakistani passport. For Indians and Pakistanis who are common citizens, it almost impossible to get a visa to visit each others country. What you read in the newspapers is propaganda. A Pakistani friend who applied for an Indian visa, was granted one after three months and that also for only two cities; with police reporting. I hope this will change in the near future but at this time it is not possible to visit each other. Regards, Akram Ariff