Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


A requiem for music


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

WHAT was a Czech violinist Jaroslav Sveceny doing in Lahore recently?

Was he just another Raymond Davis-type of subversive, camouflaging his weaponry like an Italian mafia hit man in a violin case? Or was he something more sinister, a musical reactionary intent on disturbing our cultural complacency?

The moment Sveceny tucked his prized violin under his chin that evening and began playing, he reminded his audience (all graying and on the wrong side of 40) that he did not simply come from another country. He came from a different world, a world in which its citizens express themselves in sound, in colour and in musical notes. We in Pakistan by contrast are reconciled to thinking in silence. We view life in monochrome. We speak in a monotone. The only notes we recognise are bank notes.

It was not always like this. For thousands of years, we have laughed and sang and danced. One needs to remind oneself that the female figurine discovered at Mohenjodaro was a dancing girl, not some lacquered doll pouting on talk shows.

Over the millennia, our artistic traditions have mutated. Miniature paintings have moved from the intimacy of hand-held muraqqas to flaunting canvases, chosen all too often because they match the colour of a drawing room wall. Dance is performed only when exuberance overtakes self-consciousness. Men and women dance if in private, behind drawn curtains, or if in public, then male with male, females with other females, rarely in an ensemble.

Music is the last bastion of the performing arts. The time-honoured concept of a gharana, ideally, should have served as a crucible for talent. Inevitably music, like our brand of politics, succumbed over time to congenital imperatives. A son followed his father even if he was not gifted, but because he was assumed to have inherited his parent’s vocal chords.

But even in such a familial atmosphere, innate talent was not enough. It had to wait its turn. Asad Amanat made his formal debut only after the death of his father Ustad Amanat Ali Khan. Similarly, Rahat Fateh Ali was confined to the periphery of Ustad Fateh Ali Khan’s troupe until the maestro’s death, after which Rahat took the place he deserved, centre-stage.

Had talent been genetic, Prince Charles would not have been playing the cello, or Thai King Bhumibol jazz on his clarinet. Our own royalty is said to be musical. It is rumoured that a twice-elected prime minister enjoys singing Indian film songs, a penchant he shares with a provincial governor, though they seem to find it impossible to sing in harmony.

No nation treats its inheritance of classical music with disdain such as ours. Even the puritanical Mughal emperor Aurangzeb cared enough about music to order it to be buried, buried so deep that its sounds would never be heard again. If music is alive today, it is not a miracle of resurrection but of nature. It is the desert flower that sprouts in the sand, a triumph of tenacity.

Music needs continuous rebirth. So when should a nation introduce its next generation to music? Some believe that one can never begin too soon. Familiarise a foetus through the walls of a womb to sounds and rhythm. Others start that process before the age of three. In the US, some schools make musical proficiency a pre-requisite to admission. Most schools anywhere in the world offer music as an elective, leaving a child to discover his or her own musical bent. The benefit of exposing every child to music is two-fold: the best become professionals, the worst become better audiences.

It is not accidental that in India, there is a reverence for music that is almost religious in its observance. Children learn any instrument for which they have an aptitude. The aim is to equip them with a tempering skill, to encourage them to play as a member of a team, not simply as a soloist.

Nothing typifies our separateness as much as our musical preferences. The Indians can handle the variety inherent in an orchestra, in which each musician is expected to play in harmony. We on our side prefer the qawwali, in which one singer leads, and the others repeat the line he has just sung. There, a leader functions as a conductor, a coordinator of different sounds. Here, the noise of our leaders is parroted by their followers.

Gradually, whether we accept it or not, we are losing our finer sensibilities. At one time, every house claiming gentility boasted a piano. Today, they are all silent. One cannot find a piano tuner anywhere outside Karachi, and he is ageing irreversibly. At one time, families looked within themselves to provide entertainment. Now, family entertainment is that rare television programme considered safe for viewing by all generations. And there was a time when one could lose oneself in a sublime piece of music. Now, in any pop performance, one is in danger of losing one’s hearing.

The silence perceptible during the performance by the Czech violinist that evening was not because the venue happened to be a five-star hotel. The quietude came from an awareness that, in the midst of terrorist attacks and suicide bombings, here was a living reminder of the enduring values of civilisation — the nobler, humanising values every society should live for, fight for, and if need be, die for.

The final piece played by Jaroslav Sveceny was Ave Maria, composed by Franz Schubert. In the front row of the audience sat the principal of one of Lahore’s leading missionary schools. There could not have been a more poignant reminder that in our country music lovers, like Christians, have become an endangered minority.

The writer is an author.

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (9) Closed

Haroon May 17, 2012 11:48am
moistened my eyes
Maroof Alam May 17, 2012 09:02am
thank you for such a nice piece.... though the hall might not be acoustically suitable, mere fact that a violin performance took place in Lahore is rejoicing...
Khurram May 17, 2012 12:26pm
Brillianty written Fakir Sahab as always!
Farrukh May 17, 2012 12:59pm
Sir, any chance of introducing music as an art to be learnt at Aitchison? Farrukh
Dr V. C. Bhutani May 17, 2012 01:14pm
Sir, I cried a thousand tears when I read your paper. I can hardly see what i have typed.
Siraj Khan May 17, 2012 03:41pm
I found the reference to Qawwali in Pakistan, perhaps a little hard and unfair and yet it combines reality with humor. Looking at the glass as half full, I feel that if the music which is being produced in PK these days is assessed in conjunction with the landscape and the political climate in which it is being produced in, I find it commendable and I am sure Fakir Sb does too. In particular, Coke Studio's efforts in this context are laudable!
Irfan Husain May 17, 2012 04:22pm
Sadly, we have turned our back on our subcontinental cultural heritage, and have found only shopping malls to replace it.
Jawa T. May 17, 2012 04:52pm
I wonder if the Indian and Pakistani governments could put in place an exchange of musical talent. Indian musicians could visit Pakistan for a few weeks and get a select set of students started either on vocal or instrumental basics. The training could continue using the likes of Skype. The same could go for sufi/qawwali/ghazal musicians from Pakistan. I know that this would be limited to those who have access to the internet. But it would be a start......
Paul MacAlindin May 17, 2012 08:13pm
Really excellent, and resonates with us in Iraq