Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Minority Fights

Published Jan 19, 2012 07:03am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

A few years ago, I was visiting a friend’s house in Lahore, and while sitting in his room we could hear the muffled sounds of singing. We assumed it was a wedding, or a dholki, and left it at that. Later, when we found ourselves on the roof, we could hear the songs clearly. They were Christmas carols being sung in a church nearby. And they were in Punjabi.

For a Karachiite whose experience of the world was largely informed by TV and magazines, Punjabi was the language of comically bad films, and carols were sung by American-accented anthropomorphic woodland creatures in cartoons. To hear them both come together felt so bizarre that I burst out laughing.

But before you ring the Political Correctness Police, hear me out for a bit more.

The reason I was laughing was that despite the inherent diversity of languages, cultures and beliefs in Pakistan, we have done a very good job of pretending that there is an unstinting homogeneity spanning from the coast to Khyber post. And so when confronted with realities (such as Punjabi Christians practicing their faith in their native language), which our preconceived notions can’t process, we blurt out in manners that are clearly troubling.

Such as blaming children for singing too loudly.

Yup, that’s the excuse trotted out by a maulana in a mosque in New Mianwali to explain why a group of worshippers from one sacred area had decided to go and trash, deface and desecrate the sacred site for another group of worshippers, who they beat up as well – just to be on the safe side. Peace was finally brought about when the underprivileged, persecuted and demonized group of worshippers decided to agree that they indeed were the side to blame.

Now I ask you - what should our reaction be to an incident like this? An incident that involves the stomping of a Holy Book, an incident that involves the destruction of a religious site, and an incident that recalls the grim savagery we decry elsewhere in the world.

Well, since we are discussing this on the internet, I suppose we can start a Facebook page, or post a link to our wall, or tweet about it and email our friends abroad.

Some people would say that such actions are futile, and perhaps they are. But for a few minutes last week, it seemed like those ‘some people’ would finally be proven wrong.

After all, hadn’t the internet been responsible for taking what had been a private tale of anguish and despair to the institutions that matter, and ensured that a man who risked his life for us, who had lost his children for us, would have to suffer no more?

As Ahsan Butt pointed out recently, Pakistan is the place where the most delusional, cynical fantasies come true. And so it was that the man whose stoic gaze had moved us all was no more than yet another compatriot with a superhuman capacity to defraud and cheat.

The entire episode made you wonder - what is wrong with us? How and when will we change?

Most of the time when we dream of change, we catch ourselves looking towards the west. Our longing gaze often flies long-haul, stopping-over in Dubai or Riyadh, before disembarking in some shiny capital. For the past year, it keeps pausing at Cairo, soaking in the atmosphere of Tahrir Square, and beseeching that heady sense of liberation to drift over to us.

Surely, a revolution would be able to rid our society of all these assorted ills.


If anything, we’ve had more revolutions than most tyrants have had Westernised, blood thirsty successors.

Which brings us back to square one - once we’re done with uncomfortably laughing at those different from us, how do we get around to providing them a space where they can feel free to be who they are without getting beaten, maimed and killed for it?

I am not one to ring the clarion call for revolutions, because the revolt is the easy part - what’s more difficult is sustaining it’s heady slogans and internalising them. So if our call goes out preaching for equality, then it has to start with us.

Next time you meet someone different, don’t offer them platitudes about how we are all the same, or how you feel their pain. Try and listen instead to whatever they have to say. Try and listen to their pain or their joy. Try and ask a question, and instead of feigning interest, attempt to locate what you can learn from.

And most importantly, don’t proceed with the weight of unattainable principles bearing down on you, but instead, proceed with love. We practice these great delusions about the power/futility of our actions in the bigger picture, without ever realising that the only picture that matters is the one we paint ourselves.

Ahmer Naqvi is the Brian Lara of his generation – he’s a genius but his team usually loses. He blogs on his own property in Blogistan, and makes short films you can see here and here.

The views expressed by this blogger and in the following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Author Image
Ahmer Naqvi is the Brian Lara of his generation – he’s a genius but his team usually loses.

He tweets @karachikhatmal

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (15) Closed

MANOJ Jan 19, 2012 01:56pm
GOOD 1............
Sanjay Mathur Jan 19, 2012 02:20pm
Why no Blasphemy case against those who desecrated the Bible ? After all Jesus is mentioned as a prophet in Quran and as far as I know your Blasphemy law can be invoked against any disrespect to any of the prophets.
Ali Jan 19, 2012 03:07pm
Truer words could not be spoken. Very well written article brother.
Ronnie Dsouza Jan 19, 2012 04:57pm
Rightly said so, Sanjay, but at times like this, for the poor Christian Minorities, BLASPHEMY does not come in for the majority in Pakistan
Lawrence Jan 19, 2012 06:05pm
@Sanjay Mathur:Issa of Quran is different from Jesus-the Messiah of the Gospels.Issa never died on the Cross according to Quran.He never was burried or rose from the dead which defies the eye witness accounts and written seven hundred years later by some one who was illiterate by their own admission.
BRR Jan 19, 2012 08:01pm
Well written, the only writer I have come across who advocates first "being the change" that one wants to see in the world. Personal transformation needs to precede a revolution, otherwise, it is just a sham.
Khizr Jan 20, 2012 01:05am
Pakistan is a pseudo-Islamic country, where the laws and the society is more un-islamic than some of the countries in the West. Illiterate people are exploited at the name of religion by Mullahs who claim to be champion of Islam. If Pakistan was an Islamic country, it would have given the rights to minorities, women and the weak. May Allah help us get out of this grave situation.
Prudent Injeeli Jan 20, 2012 06:49am
Thanks for voicing these concerns of the minorities. A minority member
TLW Jan 20, 2012 07:52am
Yaar, Ahmer, the last two paragraphs are the most important. To LISTEN to what the other person has to say, and not to labour constantly under massive ideologies, and to let a sense of love or belonging guide the way.
Raja Waheed Jan 20, 2012 10:06am
Correction Lawrence. The Quran was not 'written' by an 'illiterate' by your count. The Quran is a divine book as the Bible was. The only difference is that the Quran is still the same after 1400 years but the Bible has many versions!
Malay Jan 20, 2012 10:25am
Very well said Lawrence. I appreciate your staright talk
A.J.Siddiqui Jan 20, 2012 12:10pm
Mr.Lawrence! First of all, the reading and comprehension that you mentioned about the Bible and the Quran is not accurate. According to Quran Hazrat Issa (Pbuh) was never put on to the Cross (saleeb in Arabic), and the stories mentioned about this mighty messenger of God in the Bible is based on hearsay. No first-hand eyewitness's record is preserved in the Bible. And secondly, you delicately refering to Prophet Mohammad (Pbuh), without mentioning his name,as "seven hundred years later an illiterate(unlettered) man" is actually the exact fulfilment of a prophecy given to Prophet Moses(Pbuh) about the Prophet Mohammad(Pbuh) in the Bible. May God guide us all to see the truth as it is. Ameen
Shahbaz Jan 20, 2012 01:29pm
Good contribution towards the voice for humanity and religious tolerance. We should appreciate the step one then we go on to next.
Lawrence Jan 21, 2012 03:37pm
Sohaib Jan 23, 2012 01:05pm
You'll be surprised. It varies from country to country. Here in Australia you cant file blashpemy until its something against christianity (ONLY).