SYDNEY, May 5: An Australian kidney specialist sparked a bitter medical ethics row on Monday by calling for organ sales to be legalised to stop patients travelling overseas to buy them on the black market.

Nephrologist Gavin Carney said Australia should allow the sale of organs, which currently carries a penalty of six months jail and a 4,400 dollar (4,092 US) fine, to help cut the bloated transplant waiting list.

Fit, young and healthy people should be allowed to peddle their kidneys for up to 50,000 dollars to save lives and money and to discourage needy patients from going to developing countries such as Pakistan and India to buy black-market organs for up to 30,000 dollars, he told the Sydney Morning Herald.

Australian kidney transplant patients currently wait for up to 10 years for a healthy organ.

But organ transplant groups slammed Carney’s controversial suggestion that Australia legalise a practice outlawed in most of the world, saying it would be open to abuse and would leave the poor vulnerable to exploitation.—AFP

Opinion

Editorial

War & deception
Updated 09 Mar, 2026

War & deception

While there is little doubt that Iran is involved in many of the retaliatory attacks, the facts raise suspicions that another player may be at work.
The witness box
09 Mar, 2026

The witness box

IT is often the fear of the courtroom and what may transpire therein that drives many victims of crime, especially...
Asylum applications
09 Mar, 2026

Asylum applications

BRITAIN’S tough immigration posture has again drawn attention to the sharp rise in asylum claims by Pakistani...
Petrol shock
Updated 08 Mar, 2026

Petrol shock

With oil markets bracing for more volatility, more price shocks are inevitable in the coming weeks.
Women’s Day
08 Mar, 2026

Women’s Day

IT is a simple truth: societies progress when women are able to shape them. Yet the struggle for equality has never...
Rescuing hockey
08 Mar, 2026

Rescuing hockey

PAKISTAN hockey is back to where it should be. Years of misses came to an end on Friday with a long-awaited...