Singh tells Bush India not yet ready for N-deal

Published
0

By Jawed Naqvi and Anwar Iqbal

NEW DELHI/WASHINGTON, Oct 16: Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has told US President George W. Bush that there were “certain difficulties” in operationalising the civilian nuclear deal with Washington, news reports said on Tuesday.

They quoted Dr Singh’s media adviser travelling with him in Nigeria that the prime minister came out with the ‘explanation’ when Mr. Bush called him up in Abuja.

The Left parties, whose support shores up the United Progressive Alliance government, on Tuesday hailed Dr Singh’s ‘communication’ to the US President and hoped the message would be conveyed officially at the UPA-Left panel’s October 22 meeting.

Describing the prime minister’s conversation with Mr Bush as a “positive development”, the leaders of the Left Front told United News of India the government should inform the nation about it and come clean on the deal that led to a major standoff.

The government has yet to convey officially to the Left parties its decision to put the deal on hold.

Meanwhile, India’s Ambassador to the US Ronen Sen will be summoned by the Privileges Committees of the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha for his controversial remark in which he had described the MPs opposed to the deal as ‘headless chicken’.

The Left parties had strongly urged the government not to operationalise the deal that involved negotiating a safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency.

The Indian embassy in Washington posted a seven-paragraph statement on its website, outlining the conversation between Mr Singh and Mr Bush.

The White House did not announce that the conversation took place until asked about the Indian embassy statement -- and then confirmed it in language almost identical to the Indian press release.

US officials acknowledged deep disappointment over the development and spent the weekend trying to revive the deal.

“We believe that this is an arrangement that is a positive one and a good one for the United States, for India and for the broader efforts of non-proliferation,” State Department spokesman Tom Casey told a briefing in Washington.

“Certainly, there are steps that … the Indian government will need to take and that we’ll need to take on our side as well to complete this,” he said.

Asked if the Singh government caved in to domestic pressures, Mr Casey said: “I’ll let other people do the Indian political analysis for you.”

Mr Casey said the US administration has had “a number of good conversations” with other nations in the 45-nation Nuclear Suppliers Groups and the IAEA to get their endorsement for the deal.

But the formal discussions with the NSG and IAEA will have to wait until India is ready to move ahead with the deal, he added.

The Left and opposition politicians in India are particularly concerned about a clause in the deal that could end America’s nuclear cooperation with India if New Delhi conducts another atomic test.

The Washington Post, however, reported on Tuesday that the main obstacle did not involve the specific terms of the agreement but India’s internal politics, including fears of leftist parties that India is moving too close to the United States.

“Besieged over the past two months by growing opposition to nuclear energy cooperation with the United States, Prime Minister Singh indicated over the weekend that he would rather save his coalition government than the nuclear pact,” the newspaper said.

Opinion

Editorial

Restructuring plans
Updated 29 Oct, 2026

Restructuring plans

The primary reason for governance failure in Pakistan is not the geographical size of the existing provinces but the reluctance of provincial capitals to empower local bodies.
Polluted priorities
Updated 29 Oct, 2026

Polluted priorities

Enforcement must continue, but decisions should follow evidence, not the visibility of machinery on city roads.
Continuing genocide
29 Oct, 2026

Continuing genocide

FOR the people of Gaza, despite the ‘ceasefire’ reached last October, the genocide never really ceased. This ...
Regional security
Updated 28 Oct, 2026

Regional security

Iran and the Makkah pact states should pledge not to let external actors use their soil to launch aggression against each other.
Rate hike
28 Oct, 2026

Rate hike

THE SBP’s decision to raise its policy rate by 50 basis points to 12pc was largely expected. It is also justified...
Press solidarity
28 Oct, 2026

Press solidarity

PAKISTAN’S journalists have seldom lacked organisations speaking in defence of press freedom. What has been ...