Use of technology must be in harmony with fair trial provision: PHC

Published Updated
0

PESHAWAR: Peshawar High Court has upheld use of modern technology including video conferencing for recording evidence in criminal trials, but ruled that the same should be in harmony with the constitutional provision guaranteeing fair trial and due process.

A single-member bench of Justice Aurangzeb Khan observed: “The use of technology is a means of facilitating the administration of justice and cannot be permitted to become a source of prejudice to either party.”

“The right to a fair trial and due process is guaranteed under Article 10-A of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973. This constitutional guarantee is not confined to the formal conduct of judicial proceedings; rather, it requires that every party be afforded a real and effective opportunity to present its case, challenge the evidence produced against it and participate meaningfully in the proceedings,” the bench ruled.

The bench issued a 28-page detailed judgement while disposing of a criminal revision plea of a suspect facing trial in a murder case, challenging an order of the trial court in Bannu of Feb 25, 2026, whereby his application for personal appearance of the complainant/prosecution witness instead of through video link was turned down.

Upholds witness appearance through video link, issues directives to trial court

The trial court had on Jan 10, 2026, allowed an application of the complainant for recording her statement through video link as she claimed to have a security threat in Bannu.

The defence counsel had not raised any objection at that time to the arrangement, and the Peshawar district and sessions judge had accorded permission for that purpose.

Accordingly, on Jan 15, the complainant became available through the video link facility at Sessions Courts, Peshawar, while the prosecutor, counsel for the complainant, the petitioner and his counsel were present before the trial court in Bannu.

During the recording of her examination-in-chief, the defence counsel raised an objection that someone was providing instructions to the witness and whenever she forgot something, four advocates standing near the rostrum prompted her.

Thereafter, the defence counsel and the petitioner left the courtroom, and the statement of the witness could not be recorded.

In the judgement, which is of significance due to the growing use of modern technology in trials, the bench has discussed threadbare the provisions of the Constitution, and other laws including Qanun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984, and Code of Criminal Procedure.

It also discussed the procedural framework available through Peshawar High Court Virtual Court Proceedings Rules, 2026.

While allowing the virtual appearance of the complainant/witness, the bench issued multiple directives to the trial court under the said rules so as to ensure fair trial.

The bench ordered that if the requisite safeguards couldn’t effectively be secured through video conferencing, the trial court should consider requiring the physical appearance of the witness or adopting any other mode permissible under CrPC and Qanun-i-Shahadat Order.

The bench pointed out that Article 164 of the Qanun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984, as substituted by Section 12 of Criminal Laws (Amendment) Act, 2023, recognised the use of modern devices and techniques for the purposes of evidence.

“The legislative recognition of modern technology reflects the need to facilitate judicial proceedings, improve access to justice and overcome practical difficulties that may otherwise impede the recording of evidence,” the bench observed.

It said that the introduction of modern technology, however, did not dilute the fundamental requirements governing the recording of evidence.

“Although the mode of recording may change, the essential safeguards relating to the identity, independence and credibility of a witness, as well as the right of an accused to effectively cross-examine such witness, remain intact,” the bench observed.

The court ruled: “Article 164 must, therefore, be interpreted harmoniously with Article 10-A of the Constitution and the other provisions of Qanun-i-Shahadat Order governing the examination of witnesses.”

“The adoption of video conferencing does not relieve the trial court of its responsibility to supervise the process and ensure that the evidence is recorded in a fair, transparent and reliable manner,” the bench maintained.

The bench discussed multiple judgements of superior courts, observing that the principle emerging from it was that physical presence was not an inflexible requirement in every case, provided the arrangement adopted by the court preserved the essential safeguards of a fair trial.

The bench explained relevant rules under the Peshawar High Court Virtual Court Proceedings Rules, 2026, which were notified on March 11, 2026. The bench pointed out that Rule 4 was the principal enabling provision concerning the virtual conduct of judicial proceedings.

It said that sub-rules 12 and 14 expressly provided that all proceedings conducted virtually should be judicial proceedings and that legal formalities prescribed under CrPC, Qanun-i-Shahadat Order and other applicable laws should continue to apply, as they applied to proceedings conducted physically.

The bench referred to Schedule-B of the said rules, observing that it was of particular significance in the present case as it specifically provided that, where the proposed person was appearing from a court falling within the jurisdiction of another district, the virtual assistant (VA) at the virtual court point should be an authorised official nominated by the relevant district and sessions judge.

“Thus, where a prosecution witness is to be examined from the court of the learned district and sessions judge, Peshawar, the arrangement must be supervised by an authorised official nominated by the relevant district and sessions judge.”

DIRECTION TO TRIAL COURT: The bench directed the trial court that it should ensure that permission for virtual examination was granted in accordance with Rule 4 and that the requirements applicable to criminal proceedings under Rule 4(7) had been fulfilled.

The bench directed the trial court to ascertain that an authorised virtual assistant, nominated by the Peshawar district and sessions judge was present at the virtual court point, and that the identity of the witness should be verified in accordance with Rule 8(5) to (7).

The trial judge was further directed to specifically examine the objection already raised by the defence regarding possible prompting or assistance to the witness.

“The learned trial court shall ensure compliance with rules 8(9) and (10), so that no unauthorised person is present or permitted to participate in the proceedings without the permission of the court,” the bench directed.

Published in Dawn, November 16th, 2026

Opinion

Editorial

LG malaise
16 Nov, 2026

LG malaise

THE repeated delays in local government elections in Islamabad expose the reluctance of the government to strengthen...
Smog diplomacy
16 Nov, 2026

Smog diplomacy

EACH winter, Lahore and Delhi engage in a peculiar rivalry, trading places at the top of the world’s air-pollution...
Wild trophies
16 Nov, 2026

Wild trophies

THE elite fixation on housing wild beasts as status symbols is an invitation to tragedy. A farmhouse owner and a...
Muddled hierarchy
Updated 15 Nov, 2026

Muddled hierarchy

The jurisdiction of the two courts and a mechanism for settling disputes between them should be spelt out in law, not left to judges to fight over.
Growing crisis
Updated 15 Nov, 2026

Growing crisis

Calling population growth a national emergency is easy. Ensuring that the response reaches the people who need it is the real challenge.
Organised rackets
15 Nov, 2026

Organised rackets

ON the International Day against Transnational Organised Crime, observed today, Pakistan finds itself in a tight...