THIS is with reference to the article ‘Eternal optimists’ (April 23). I was appalled by the twisted logic on display that not only mocked optimism, but also contributed, knowingly or unknowingly, to the very environment of despair that the article so critically examined.

Ironically, the article attacked a quality that has historically been the bedrock of progress — optimism. It ridiculed those who, despite recognising the country’s ills, dare to believe in its recovery. This is not blind faith, as suggested. Rather, it is a conscious refusal to succumb to hopeless- ness, a determined act of resilience in the face of adversity.

The writer conflated structural critique with fatalism, and, in doing so, dismissed optimism as naïve and counterproductive. This is a grave error. Pessimism, if left unchecked, breeds inaction. It paralyses. It is a sin we can ill afford in these difficult times. To call out our national ailments is necessary, but to believe in our ability to recover and reform is equally vital. Without hope, what incentive remains for effort, for change, for staying behind and building instead of fleeing?

Optimism is not a miracle cure; it is a moral stance. It refuses to abandon the idea that we, as a people, are capable of learning, adapting and doing better. Shining the light of optimism is not a delusion, it is, in fact, the only right and responsible thing to do.

I seem to be part of a shrinking tribe of optimists, perhaps, but I remain proud of this allegiance. We believe that despite the odds, this nation will survive. And not just survive, Pakistan will thrive.

Tughral Yamin
Islamabad

Published in Dawn, May 15th, 2025