Convicted UK baby killer’s lawyer presents ‘fresh’ evidence in bid to clear her name

Published April 3, 2025
A photograph of convicted child killer Lucy Letby. — AFP/File
A photograph of convicted child killer Lucy Letby. — AFP/File

A lawyer defending Lucy Letby on Thursday handed over “fresh” medical evidence to an independent body aimed at clearing the name of the former nurse, whose convictions have made her the most prolific child serial killer in modern UK history.

Letby, 35, is serving 15 whole life sentences for the deaths of the babies at a neo-natal unit in the northwest of England where she worked between 2015 and 2016.

Letby was convicted of murdering seven newborn babies and attempting to kill seven others at the Countess of Chester Hospital neonatal unit.

Her lawyer Mark McDonald delivered the findings of a 14-strong international panel of neonatologists and paediatric specialists to the offices of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which investigates potential miscarriages of justice.

The CCRC has the power to refer cases back to the Court of Appeal if it determines there may have been a miscarriage of justice.

The doctors, all leaders in their field who reviewed the evidence without payment, presented their findings in London in February.

“In our opinion, the medical opinion, the medical evidence doesn’t support murder in any of these cases, just natural causes and bad medical care,” said retired Canadian doctor Shoo Lee.

Letby, who has always maintained her innocence, was accused of attacking the babies by various means, including insulin poisoning and injecting air into their bloodstreams which caused an air embolism that blocked the blood supply and led to sudden and unexpected collapses.

McDonald will also deliver a separate report to the commission’s offices in Birmingham from seven other medics which claims the results of insulin tests on two infants were unreliable.

One test used in both cases “can give rise to falsely high insulin results” due to the presence of antibodies which can interfere with the outcome, the medics say in the new report.

“Our inescapable conclusion is that this evidence significantly undermines the validity of the assertions made about the insulin and C-peptide testing presented in court.”

McDonald said the two reports constituted “fresh evidence” that “totally undermines the prosecution case at trial”.

Letby lost two bids last year to challenge her convictions at the Court of Appeal.

Opinion

Editorial

Diplomatic resolve
Updated 30 May, 2026

Diplomatic resolve

Iran, too, must engage seriously and provide credible assurances about its nuclear programme if it wants sanctions relief and a more stable relationship with the outside world.
Weaponising water
30 May, 2026

Weaponising water

CLIMATE Minister Musadik Malik’s warning against what he described as “water aggression” indicates ...
Rabies toll
30 May, 2026

Rabies toll

EVERY year, rabies, the deadliest zoonotic disease, kills more than 59,000 people worldwide. In Pakistan, it is one...
Pressure politics
Updated 28 May, 2026

Pressure politics

The attempt to connect the Iran conflict with the Abraham Accords makes little sense.
Eid’s true spirit
Updated 27 May, 2026

Eid’s true spirit

Pakistan celebrates Eid while grappling with economic strain that continues to weigh heavily on ordinary households.
Cotton crisis
Updated 29 May, 2026

Cotton crisis

We need a coherent long-term cotton strategy or else, Pakistan might lose a key pillar of its export economy.