Facebook spreads hate, insider tells British lawmakers

Published October 26, 2021
FRANCES Haugen, a former Facebook employee, appears before a committee of the British parliament examining legislation to regulate social media companies.—Reuters
FRANCES Haugen, a former Facebook employee, appears before a committee of the British parliament examining legislation to regulate social media companies.—Reuters

LONDON: Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen told UK lawmakers on Monday that posting content featuring anger and hate “is the easiest way to grow” on the social media platform as she urged better regulation.

Haugen, who earlier this year shared a trove of internal documents alleging Facebook knew its products were harming children’s mental health, argued the platform was “unquestionably” fuelling hate.

Haugen said Facebook used “engagement-based rankings” prioritising the most clicked — and invariably divisive — content.

“It pushes you to the extremes and it fans hate,” she told a panel of British MPs probing regulatory options, weeks after she testified to US Congress.

“Anger and hate is the easiest way to grow on Facebook... bad actors have an incentive to play the algorithm, and they figure out all the ways to optimise Facebook.” Haugen worked for companies including Google and Pinterest before starting at the world’s largest social media platform in 2019 with the hope of helping Facebook change course.

However, the 37-year-old data scientist has said she became increasingly concerned about the choices she saw the company making and left in May.

She then shared documents with US lawmakers and The Wall Street Journal that showed failures by Facebook to address misinformation, hate and other toxic content.

They also alleged that it knew its products, including Instagram, were harming young girls, especially around body image.

“I am deeply worried that it may not be possible to make Instagram safe for a 14-year-old and I sincerely doubt it’s possible to make it safe for a 10-year-old,” Haugen told the UK lawmakers.

In a wide-ranging assessment of its failings, she said Facebook was failing to regulate larger groups with hundreds of thousands of users where misinformation proliferates.

Meanwhile, she said, the social media giant is also underinvesting in its non-English language products, endangering societies already suffering from deep ethnic and religious divisions.

“We have to care about societal harm, not just for the ‘Global South’ but our own societies,” she said.

“Facebook has been unwilling to accept even little slivers of profit being sacrificed for safety, and that’s not acceptable.” Haugen said a raft of up-to-date and “flexible” regulations were needed as content and social media companies evolve.

“We need ways to hold these companies accountable,” she added, calling for more human intervention instead of algorithms and artificial intelligence.

As part of forthcoming legislation on online safety, the UK government is considering criminal sanctions against company executives who fail to tackle harmful content on their platforms. Haugen said such sanctions could play an important role because they “act like gasoline on the law”.

“It makes executives take consequences more seriously,” she noted.

Asked if Facebook was “evil”, Haugen said it is overwhelmingly staffed by “conscientious, kind, empathetic people”.

But she added: “There was a real pattern of people who are willing to look the other way, are promoted more than people who raise alarms.” Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg has previously rejected Haugen’s claims, saying her attacks on the company were “misrepresenting” its work.

Published in Dawn, October 26th, 2021

Opinion

Editorial

New IMF programme?
Updated 03 Jun, 2023

New IMF programme?

The tranche’s release is crucial to the government’s plans to provide relief to the public in the budget.
Pemra’s edict
03 Jun, 2023

Pemra’s edict

IN an effort to mould the narrative, and prevent “undesirable” opinions from making it to the airwaves, Pemra ...
Crypto dreams
03 Jun, 2023

Crypto dreams

THOUGH the majority of the global financial community has wholeheartedly embraced the promise of cryptocurrencies,...
Balanced approach
Updated 02 Jun, 2023

Balanced approach

Only a legitimate government may be able to take the country out of its present crisis.
Rise in attacks
02 Jun, 2023

Rise in attacks

AN enduring security dilemma for Pakistan has been the issue of cross-border havens in Afghanistan for militants,...
Narrowing the gap
02 Jun, 2023

Narrowing the gap

THE rupee made a substantial recovery of 11.5 against the dollar in the open market a day after the State Bank...