Israeli court declares barrier legal

Published September 16, 2005

JERUSALEM, Sept 15: Israel’s top court on Thursday upheld the government’s legal right to build a barrier through occupied West Bank land, rejecting a World Court ruling that it violated international law and should be torn down.

But the nine Israeli Supreme Court justices also ordered the government to reroute part of the planned 600-km barrier to reduce hardship to Palestinians.

It was the court’s first judgment on the legality of the barrier since the International Court of Justice at The Hague ruled in July last year that the barrier was illegal because it cut into territory captured in the 1967 war.

The unanimous ruling on Thursday drew renewed Palestinian condemnation of the barrier project, which remains a major source of tension following Israel’s completion of its pullout from the Gaza Strip this week after 38 years of occupation.

Israel calls the structure a bulwark against suicide bombers. Palestinians say it is a land grab to deny them a viable state.

The network of fences and walls, now more than half completed, is seen as stark evidence of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s strategy of keeping a permanent hold on areas of the West Bank much larger than the former Gaza settlements.

“It was unfortunate that the Israeli court rejected the decision by the highest international court on earth,” said Palestinian chief negotiator Saeb Erekat.

But Israeli Vice Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told Israel Radio: “The importance is the court made it legal for a fence beyond the Green Line (boundary between Israel and the West Bank) and decided the World Court ruling is not binding.”

The Supreme Court said the World Court’s blanket declaration of the illegality of the barrier was flawed because it had failed to take into account Israel’s security needs.

Israel has faced a campaign of Palestinian suicide bombings and other attacks during a five-year-old Palestinian uprising also marked by fierce army raids in Palestinian areas.—Reuters

Opinion

Editorial

Sustainable path?
Updated 13 Jun, 2026

Sustainable path?

The FY27 budget is the first clear signal that the government is ready to transition from stabilisation to growth.
Prioritising education
13 Jun, 2026

Prioritising education

THOUGH the improvement in the country’s literacy rate may be slight, as highlighted by the Economic Survey, it ...
Poverty’s rise
13 Jun, 2026

Poverty’s rise

AS attention turns to the government’s plans for the coming fiscal year, one set of figures deserves particular...
A difficult story
Updated 12 Jun, 2026

A difficult story

Unless productivity becomes the dominant target of economic policy, Pakistan will continue to oscillate between crises and fragile recovery.
Rough waters
12 Jun, 2026

Rough waters

AMONGST the key potential triggers for fresh conflict in South Asia is water. The Indian state is behaving in an...
Politicised football
12 Jun, 2026

Politicised football

ALMOST three-and-half years since Lionel Messi led Argentina to FIFA World Cup glory, the latest edition of...