Aid groups frustrated as foreign staff told to leave Palu

Published October 9, 2018
In this photo, rescuers go down a steep slope as they recover a body at the earthquake-damaged neighborhood of Balaroa in Palu on October 7. — AP
In this photo, rescuers go down a steep slope as they recover a body at the earthquake-damaged neighborhood of Balaroa in Palu on October 7. — AP

Indonesia on Tuesday told foreign aid workers that their help was not needed in disaster-ravaged Palu and they should go home, frustrating relief efforts after a quake-tsunami killed more than 2,000 people.

Foreign teams on the ground were told new rules barred them from searching for the dead in hard-hit parts of Palu, where thousands are missing since the Sept 28 twin disaster.

Indonesia initially refused international help but President Joko Widodo reluctantly agreed to allow in overseas aid once the picture became clearer on Sulawesi island.

Foreign aid poured into the ravaged city of Palu where authorities believe 5,000 people could be missing and 200,000 survivors desperately need food, water and other life-saving supplies.

But international search and rescue teams were prevented on Tuesday from accessing hard-hit parts of Palu, where thousands are believed to be buried underneath rubble.

Ahmed Bham from South African charity, Gift of the Givers, was told that new rules barred foreign urban search and rescue teams (USAR) from playing any part in retrieving the dead.

They were told, "all foreign USAR teams should make their way obviously back to their countries. They don't need them in Indonesia", he said.

"We've got experienced search and rescue teams here in Indonesia with really specialised equipment. I'd like to use them," he told AFP in Palu.

Their 27-strong team arrived in Palu three days ago from Johannesburg, but days of delay frustrated their wish to join the search for the dead.

"A lot of days were wasted where we could have assisted and used our expertise and skill," Bham said.

"There seemed to be — I won't say red-tape — but it was just like, 'you can't work here, you can't do this, you can't do that'. It's something we haven't experienced in other major disasters like this."

'They can't work'

Indonesia's disaster agency issued a set of rules over the weekend instructing international staff to leave Palu and requiring foreign donations be channelled through local partners.

"The truth is that they have put out a statement saying foreign personnel should be withdrawn," World Vision Australia Chief Advocate, Tim Costello, told Australian broadcaster ABC on Tuesday.

"It is very odd as foreign journalists are free to walk around and report. This is what's very strange."

He said aid was reaching survivors but, "it is still, for us who are used to these crises, too slow".

Bham said most of the international teams he had seen in Palu were at the airport.

"They can't work. They are starting to make their way back to their countries," he said.

Disaster agency spokesman Sutopo Purwo Nugroho said no foreign aid workers had been asked to leave Palu yet.

"But in Lombok, there were many (asked to leave)," he told reporters on Tuesday.

A string of earthquakes in Lombok in eastern Indonesia over the summer killed more than 550 people, sparking a major aid response.

"The president said we didn't need foreign aid anymore but they kept coming."

Getting vital supplies to the affected areas has proved hugely challenging as flights into Palu were limited by its small airport, leaving aid workers facing gruelling overland journeys.

More than 70,000 people have been displaced since the 7.5-magnitude earthquake and subsequent tsunami tore through Palu.

Opinion

Editorial

Spread of hate
Updated 18 Jun, 2025

Spread of hate

HATE speech is not confined to words; in fact, there is a causal link between hateful rhetoric and real-world...
Big challenges
18 Jun, 2025

Big challenges

BALOCHISTAN’S Rs1.028tr budget, featuring a public development investment of Rs245bn and provincial surplus of...
Rampant disinformation
Updated 18 Jun, 2025

Rampant disinformation

WITH the arrival and proliferation of digital media, the creation of information is now a decentralised function,...
Window dressing
Updated 17 Jun, 2025

Window dressing

Meanwhile, the provinces lack the resources and expertise to implement adaptation measures effectively.
No revenue effort
17 Jun, 2025

No revenue effort

WITH the ruling PML-N’s next budget unfolding large infrastructure schemes, and expenditure focusing on service...
Pomp and circumstance
17 Jun, 2025

Pomp and circumstance

THE sight of columns of tanks rolling down a boulevard, accompanied by troops goose-stepping in lockstep, was a...