Ardern and Bhutto: Two leaders, two very different pregnancies

Published June 22, 2018
BAKHTAWAR Bhutto standing next to the portrait of her parents Benazir Bhutto and Asif Ali Zardari. Her mother told almost no one she was pregnant while in office as prime minister until Bakhtawar was born on Jan 25, 1990.
BAKHTAWAR Bhutto standing next to the portrait of her parents Benazir Bhutto and Asif Ali Zardari. Her mother told almost no one she was pregnant while in office as prime minister until Bakhtawar was born on Jan 25, 1990.

AUCKLAND: Instagram posts, national excitement and well-wishing from political rivals: Jacinda Ardern’s journey to motherhood was very different to that made three decades earlier by Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, the only other world leader to have given birth while in office.

Ardern’s daughter came into the world on Thursday, 28 years after the late Bhutto’s daughter Bakhtawar was born.

New Zealand’s youngest-ever prime minister announced her pregnancy in January, posting a symbolic photo on social media and sparking warm words from across the political spectrum.

“I’ll be prime minister and a mum,” she said on Facebook, adding that her partner Clarke Gayford, who hosts a television fishing show, would be a “stay-at-home dad”.

“I think it’s fair to say that this will be a wee one that a village will raise, but we couldn’t be more excited,” she added.

The intervening months have seen a frenzy of excitement from New Zealanders, many of whom took to the web on Thursday to express their happiness.

Twitter user @zaichishka, who describes herself as a Welsh-Kiwi, wrote: “4.693 million New Zealanders (give or take) just became aunts and uncles.”

‘Delivered democracy, also delivered a baby’

It was all a far cry from 1990, when Bhutto, the first woman to head a democratic government in a Muslim-majority nation, told almost no-one she was pregnant until Bakhtawar was born on January 25.

“None of us in the cabinet virtually knew that this prime minister was about to deliver a baby,” Javed Jabbar, a member of her cabinet, told the BBC recently.

“And then lo-and-behold suddenly we learn that she has not only gone and delivered democracy she’s also delivered a baby.”

Opposition leader Syeda Abida Hussain had called Bhutto “greedy” for wanting to have “motherhood, domesticity, glamour and whole responsibility” rather than make sacrifices for her country.

News that Ardern was expecting prompted then New Zealand opposition leader Bill English to send his congratulations and hope that she was given “the space to be able to conduct relatively normal family life”.

A HEAVILY pregnant New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern at the Buckingham Palace to attend a dinner for the Commonwealth heads held on April 20 this year.
A HEAVILY pregnant New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern at the Buckingham Palace to attend a dinner for the Commonwealth heads held on April 20 this year.

He said Ardern should be allowed to acclimatise to motherhood and not be held to higher standards because she was prime minister.

“It is an incredible privilege to be a parent. A new child will bring real joy to their lives. We wish them all the best,” he said.

Defining moment

Ardern will be taking six weeks maternity leave before returning to office, with her deputy Winston Peters assuming the reins, although she will remain on call for any matters of significance.

In contrast, Bhutto, fearing she was in danger of being overthrown, travelled incognito to a Karachi hospital, underwent a Caesarean section, then returned to work.

“The next day I was back on the job, reading government papers and signing government files,” she later wrote.

“Only later did I learn that I was the only head of government in recorded history actually to give birth while in office. It was a defining moment, especially for young women, proving that a woman could work and have a baby in the highest and most challenging leadership positions.”

Bhutto, however, was dismissed from office eight months later. She returned as prime minister from 1993 to 1996 and was assassinated in 2007.

Had she lived, Thursday would have been her birthday.

James Shaw, the leader of New Zealand’s Green Party, which is a member of New Zealand’s ruling coalition with Ardern’s Labour Party and New Zealand First, said the birth of the prime minister’s child represented New Zealand values.

“That a woman can be the prime minister of New Zealand and choose to have a family while in office says a lot about the kind of country we are and that we can be — modern, progressive, inclusive and equal,” Shaw said.

Published in Dawn, June 22nd, 2018

Opinion

Editorial

Budgeting austerity
Updated 16 May, 2025

Budgeting austerity

The past policy of squeezing salaried classes and fully documented corporations to collect taxes will not work any longer.
A ‘new’ Syria
16 May, 2025

A ‘new’ Syria

THE American embrace of the post-Assad Syrian regime is complete, with President Donald Trump meeting the Arab...
Business of begging
16 May, 2025

Business of begging

IT is a matter of deep embarrassment that Pakistan has become an ‘exporter’ of beggars. Over 5,000 have been...
Rebuilding trust
Updated 15 May, 2025

Rebuilding trust

Both countries will have to restart the dialogue process. One major step India can take would be to honour the IWT.
Political off-ramp
15 May, 2025

Political off-ramp

IN the midst of every crisis, there lies great opportunity. With the nation basking in the afterglow of Pakistan’s...
Awami League ban
15 May, 2025

Awami League ban

BANGLADESH stands at a key crossroads. While the ouster of Sheikh Hasina Wajed’s government and the formation of ...