‘England should drop Broad or Anderson’

Published
0

LONDON: The fallout from England’s heavy defeat to Pakistan at Lord’s has continued, with former captain Michael Vaughan suggesting one of James Anderson or Stuart Broad should be dropped for the second Test.

The nine-wicket thumping at the Home of Cricket has already cost opener Mark Stoneman his spot, with England confirming on Monday that the out-of-form left-hander has been replaced by Lancashire’s Keaton Jennings.

But Vaughan says England’s problems have “gone beyond just changing the opening batsman” and says axing one of their star quicks, who have taken 946 Test wickets between them, could shake the side from its malaise.

“Perhaps England have to make a bold call this week at Headingley and consider leaving out one of James Anderson or Stuart Broad,” Vaughan wrote in The Telegraph.

“Anderson’s record at Headingley has improved in recent years but neither has particularly enjoyed bowling in Leeds, which requires a fuller length. I am sure England will pick both of them but it might be an idea just to consider doing something different because at the moment it is not working.

“England are losing. The Test team are just not playing very well and something has to be done. Anderson and Broad are brilliant bowlers but it would be a wake-up call if one was left out.”

Vaughan added “the easy call” would be to replace Mark Wood with Chris Woakes for the clash in Leeds, but that England need to look to the future and back in the pacey right-armer.

“Having three senior players in the team in Anderson, Broad and Alastair Cook is very difficult for Joe Root to manage ... [but] the one thing they cannot be doing is just hanging on until the end of the Ashes [next year],” he wrote.

“They have to buy in and lead the team.

“Those three have to drive England’s rebuilding before they [retire]. They have to give a lot more than just turning up and playing.”

Speaking later on BBC, Vaughan said Broad should be the one to make way if Woakes returns.

“If England want to play Chris Woakes on Friday, I’d make the tough call that Broad doesn’t play,” he said.

“This is just a think tank to drop Broad or James Anderson and I hope people within the team and the management think, ‘Could it make a just a little difference?’ You never know.”

Published in Dawn, May 30th, 2018

Opinion

Editorial

Fixing bond markets
Updated 01 Oct, 2026

Fixing bond markets

Pension funds, insurance companies, mutual funds, retail investors, and eventually, foreign investors must become bigger participants in the market.
Call centre rackets
01 Oct, 2026

Call centre rackets

A NUMBER of recent raids conducted by the authorities in different cities point to the growing threat fraudulent ...
Homeward bound
01 Oct, 2026

Homeward bound

FIVE months after Somali pirates captured an oil tanker carrying a 19-member multinational crew, Somali maritime...
Kashmir unresolved
Updated 30 Sep, 2026

Kashmir unresolved

The just solution lies in India addressing the issue through a trilateral dialogue involving the legitimate representatives of the Kashmiri people and Pakistan.
Water shortage
30 Sep, 2026

Water shortage

THAT the country is entering the Rabi season with an anticipated water shortage of nearly 25pc, the lowest carryover...
Young hearts
30 Sep, 2026

Young hearts

THE observance may have passed, but the message of World Heart Day should not fade with it. The occasion is a useful...