Conversations close to the heart adorn walls in India, Pakistan

Published
Zeenat Kulavoor’s mural ‘Insaan pareshaan yahaan bhi hai wahaan bhi’.—Sidharth Paurana
Zeenat Kulavoor’s mural ‘Insaan pareshaan yahaan bhi hai wahaan bhi’.—Sidharth Paurana

KARACHI: There is a wall mural in the compound of a rundown textile mill located in the Hindu-majority Mahalaxmi area of Mumbai that carries a haunting verse penned down by Urdu poet Muqtida Hasan Nida Fazli in the aftermath of Partition: “Hindu bhi sukoon se hai Musalmaan bhi sukoon se, Insaan pareshaan yahaan bhi hai wahaan bhi” (Hindus are at peace, Muslims are too, it’s the humans who are worried here [India] and there [Pakistan] too).

The 'Pehle Aap' mural by Zeenat Kulavoor.— Photo by Zeenat Kulavoor
The 'Pehle Aap' mural by Zeenat Kulavoor.— Photo by Zeenat Kulavoor

While it is rare to come across such reminders of coexistence on the streets of India and Pakistan, it is even less common to chance upon the Urdu nastaliq script in the Hindu-dominated areas of India. Recently, however, artists Zeenat Kulavoor in Mumbai and Sanki King in Karachi, intent on bringing the language to the fore, initiated the project Pehle Aap to convey messages close to their hearts using the art form of murals, and in the process, draw their communities together.

Using their distinct forms and perspectives, the two artists began a conversation in Urdu through murals on four walls — two each in Mumbai and Karachi. “You get to see the Urdu script in India only in Muslim-clustered areas and, that too, as part of signage holders for stores or outside a masjid. With the location of my wall, I wanted to break this Muslim-centric aspect and use Urdu in a neutral and artistic manner in a space where the younger minds can relate to the message and appreciate it,” Kulavoor told Dawn.

Zeenat Kulavoor’s mural ‘Insaan pareshaan yahaan bhi hai wahaan bhi’.—Sidharth Paurana
Zeenat Kulavoor’s mural ‘Insaan pareshaan yahaan bhi hai wahaan bhi’.—Sidharth Paurana

To begin the conversation, Kulavoor painted Pehle Aap in her first mural in the compound of Shakti mills. She began the conversation with the phrase which translates to “after you”, as a sign of respect towards popular street artist Abdullah, commonly referred to as Sanki King.

Sanki, a close follower of Pakistani poet Jaun Elia’s work, responded to Kula­voor’s mural with a series titled Inqilaab, which has been inspired by a poem by Elia.

“Both of my walls are painted in North Nazimabad in Karachi, where I live. One of my murals reads: “Pak o Hindustan ke funkaro; Aqal o deewangi ke dildaro; Bin tumhare hai shauq ke rumna; Tum se hai aab e Jhelum o Jamna” (O artisans of Pakistan and India, the ones enamoured by wisdom and insanity, zest amp and zeal go astray without you, the flow of Jhelum and Jamuna is there because of you),” Sanki King said, adding that he had already planned two other murals in a different area to keep the conversation going.

Sanki King's mural 'Inquilab 1'.— Photo by Shaikh Danial
Sanki King's mural 'Inquilab 1'.— Photo by Shaikh Danial

Given Urdu’s dying popularity and influence in India and other parts of the world, and the cultural disconnect among the youth, what inspired the two artists to begin this conversation?

Recently, Sanket Avlani — the curator of the project — got the chance to tag along with a friend to meet artists who specialised in Urdu calligraphy in ‘purani Dilli’ (old Delhi). The katibs (calligraphers) not only gave them a glimpse into their writing styles but also shared the reason why Urdu script was fading out in the region.

“They believe the language has suffered because it is often linked to a particular people, religion or agenda. And that’s what needs to be changed,” Avlani told Dawn, emphasising the language’s role as a vehicle of peace.

Sanki King's mural 'Inquilab 2'.— Photo by Shaikh Danial
Sanki King's mural 'Inquilab 2'.— Photo by Shaikh Danial

In order to explore the origins and history of the nastaliq script, and to re-introduce it to aspiring artistes, Avlani and his team at Design Fabric — a Mumbai-based arts and design publication — produced the “Urdu Issue”, an audio-visual exhibition involv­ing photography, the work of calligraphers, poetry recitals, short films, and murals — inspired by Urdu.

“Among the various projects introduced under the “Urdu Issue”, the collaborative aspect of Pehle Aap stood out the most. We [the team and Sanki] got to know each other through Skype calls and Facebook, and never expected the output to be this meaningful,” said Madhu­vanthi Mohan, community manager and creative producer at Design Fabric.

The organisers have announced an open call to other artists based in India and Pakistan to join in and continue the mural conversation in their respective cities in order to keep alive the universality of language.

Zeenat Kulavoor's mural 'Pehle Aap' WIP.— Photo by Sanjana Nanodkar
Zeenat Kulavoor's mural 'Pehle Aap' WIP.— Photo by Sanjana Nanodkar

Published in Dawn, November 2nd, 2017

Opinion

Editorial

Quid pro quo
Updated 26 Jul, 2026

Quid pro quo

Accepting Israel would mean legitimising its violence against the Palestinians, as well as its neighbouring Arab states and Iran.
AI in government
26 Jul, 2026

AI in government

THE Prime Minister’s Office has announced the introduction of an AI-powered digital system and directed ministries...
Cautious optimism
26 Jul, 2026

Cautious optimism

THE latest polio surveillance figures offer some encouraging news regarding the difficult fight against polio. The...
Rampant lawlessness
Updated 25 Jul, 2026

Rampant lawlessness

THE brutal slaying of a judge and his guard in Mastung is the latest in a series of blood-drenched events that have...
Daily fuel pricing
25 Jul, 2026

Daily fuel pricing

THE government’s move to daily petroleum price adjustments should make fuel pricing more transparent and more...
The drug problem
25 Jul, 2026

The drug problem

WHILE Islamabad Police chase low-level peddlers, the capital’s kingpins have quietly taken their operations ...