Glad your fighting against this PTI! But sadly we will always bow down to Saudia Pressure!

Valid arguments by imran khan.

Please do not meddle in non issues. You have a province to work on, there is only a year left.

for once Imran Khan is right.

I generally despise Imran Khan and his PTI fanatics, but this time he is right. We should remain neutral, and this new alliance is very clearly an anti-Iran alliance.

Dont put your leg in other countries business

Being paid back for not raising finger in 2014 dharna.

Why Khawaja Asif and its pmln are so eager to please former COAS because they wanted to get rid of him as soon as possible, infact a major reason was his determined action against militants outside and inside.

Agree with Imran on this issue. After a long time he has stood for something meaningful

@Ranjit Haripur Imran is always right.

This is the first time I see IK is talking sense and I support his logical stance. Hope he stick with his stance.

Agree with IK 110%.

Love you Imran but here I am for General saab. have been thinking of such an alliance for a long time and finally some got their heads together...

Seems like Sharifs are looking for a way out from Panama hence ready to put the country into mid-east crisis.

@PAtriot being right all the things times is humanly impossible!!! Treat him as a human being!!! Stop being another MQM

@nuh But Principle is principle and must be pursued.

IK called spade a spade.
This is actually a Nawaz's conniving move to get the General out of the way and out of the country. General Shareef, during his service became the most popular person in the country, had he ran for the public office, the entire nation would have lined up behind him any day. That would have been catastrophic for Nawaz & company and Zardari along with their cohorts.
This for sure puts Pakistan in a bad position with Gen. Raheel heading this so-called alliance. Pakistanis need to stop being tunnel visioned and look out for Pakistan.
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD! PAKISTAN PAINDABAD! PAKISTAN FIRST always.

Valid argument but imran khan some complicated questions in Exam we pass or not attend to answer . So I suggest imran khan should wait and watch of it. Don't oppose because lots of followers of Raheel Sharif. If general Raheel Sharif is ready then what you can do. I am a pti supporter

Can Imran Khan ever gove a statement without the same 100 faces behind him? Do these hangers around ever do anything else but hover around him? How about going to your people who vote for you and see how they live, work and die?

@Farhan need to wake up, Saudis are our Muslim brothers, we are surrounded by enemies and you attack Saudi brothers? Stop watching Bollywood movies, they are corrupting your brain.

@PAtriot no he is not, most of the time his ideas are very weak, they look good on paper but are foolish, he was against war on Taliban, and they kept creeping up all the way into Swat, finally the Army broke their teeth, now Imran is quiet, what is he right about? He needs to fix KPK, stop worrying about the country, Nawaz was elected to do that.

I think PMLN has done a mistake. They should give a statement that they have refused NOC. Then you know IK had opposed that. He has only issue with PMLN.

Agree with Imran Khan on his stance, all respect to Saudi but this looks more like Sharif's interest over National Interest.

Agree with Imran Khan on this. He is echoing the voice of normal Pakistanis. We are still paying the price of fighting other people proxy wars, better we avoid getting into the danger zone

Govt has taken right decision don't listen to PTI always negative politics

Great somebody questioned the decision.

Finally something sane by PTI.

@Atif what Pakistan is doing right now ?

If coalition forces plan attacks against Itanian interests in future, will Raheel take charge? Unfortunately we are putting all our eggs with China/Saudia which is dangerous in the longer run...

It is not in the best interest of our country to let our former army chief get involved in Saudi schemes. The Middle East is currently an awful mess and will remain so for a long long time. Whoever will enter into this muddle would not come out whole. Our best approach would be to stay out of it.

Seems strange.

Why is PML-N picking fights with PPP and bring up non-issues when Panama decision is pending?

Maybe the courts will decide against them?

Imran Khan is absolutely right, Khawaja Asif alone should not issue NOC, bring this matter in parliament and let all the members decide if Raheel Shareef should be allowed to take job working for Saudi King.

Don't turn a simple posting of the coalition into ,shia and sunni thing. It is not. It is about overhauling useless armies into some kind of fighting force. In every middle east nation, every challenge or uprising has led the armies to collapse. That's why they want a professional army to train them to some standard and hence the appointment of Gen Raheel.

@nuh This is a very critical issue of national security!

One thing will lead to another. Don't go into it. We have bigger problem to take care of.

Very good Imran. You are fighting on all issues.

Imran just wants to stay in news, let him do that.. dont get bothered by what he says.

A stupid stance. Just opposition for the sake of opposition.

I am not a supporter of Imran Khan but on this issue, I support him 100%. The appointment of Gen Raheel is against the interest of Pakistan and NOC must not be approved.

sometimes this guy seems to be the only patriot in the country who only cares for Pakistan and Pakistanis

PTI is once again shooting itself in the foot! Majority of Pakistanis side with Saudis and are sympathetic to their ideology. Dont do this!

Pakistan should be extremely careful to not get involved in any kind of sectarian group. We should try to stop civil wars between Muslims, not become part of one !

It will be in best interest of All Muslim Countries to have a such a Great Commander like Mr. Raheel Sharif who will never fight against any Muslim country. No other Commander can do this.So IK please try to understand this and don't object to NOC.

It will be in best interest of All Muslim Countries to have a such a Great Commander like Mr. Raheel Sharif who will never fight against any Muslim country. No other Commander can do this.So IK please don't object to NOC.

Absolutely correct stance, it seems we haven't learned from Afghanistan experience!!!

@nuh ....is it a non issue, huge money is also involved here.

PTI should 1st stop millions workers already working in KSA. Can PTI or its supporters give them job.

Surprise, surprise. PTI on the right side of the history.

@Atif .. Who exactly are you referring to. Raheel Shareef or Imran Khan?

Am glad that PTI is sensing the responsibility, has the wisdom, taken the initiative to stand up against it.

Raheel will bring job for 2 to 3 Division of Pakistani Soldier and thousand for Civilian fighter who are ready to fight for Saudi King. Good earning!

Since the inception of PTI, I had never, I mean never supported the party. I have to say I am amazed by this bold instance by Imran Khan. I am a firm believer that Pakistan must be neutral in the Middle Eastern war, otherwise, their fire will burn our house. I fully support Imran Khan on this issue. No other party had any guts to disagree with the government on this issue.

@M. Khan .. Right now two Muslim countries are fighting each other. Saudi Arabia and Yemen. Do I have to mention Iran and Iraq who in recently history fought for years. Mr. Khan, please review what you have written.

@helabu - extremely far fetched argument.

Talking Sense.

How shocking , I am with PTI on this issue.

IK is right. "Thousands of Yemenis rally in Sanaa on war’s second anniversary"--over a hundred thousand according to Reuters--just look at the picture. Today's Dawn.

As a muslim nation, i think it will be better for Pakistan to join the 39 nation islamic military alliance. On the one hand this alliance will unite the muslim nations to tackle the burgeoning issues confronting the muslim countries. On the other hand it would also be a matter of pride for Pakistan to have its Former Army chief made head of this alliance. A matter of Great Pride for Pakistan. We should not stake this great opportunity for the interest of only one country Iran.

This man is inpiring lot of people by his sensible arguments. Weldone IK

The General will not be working as a representative of Pakistan, he has already retired from Pakistan Army. Letting him work does not mean Pakistan is endorsing any side in the conflict. Millions of Pakistanis work in Saudi Arabia and Gulf States, that does not mean Pakistan support all their policies. The no objection certificate simply means that the government of Pakistan has no objection on Raheel Sharif working there, it does not affect Pakistan's neutrality in any way. If Iran offers a job to a retired Pakistani general too I am sure the government will issue a NOC.

38 nations are only participating and don't want to nominate anyone to lead the group and thus take responsibility for any future wrong actions. Better to mind own business instead of volunteering and asking for trouble.

We Indians admire this step of Imran Khan. This is a good step for the safe future of brother Pakistan.

@Be yourself

Brother very well said.

Raheel sharif is hero of Pakistan and its a history of Pakistan and some bad people always against Pakistani Heros now New Imran Khan is wrong in this decision.

To my understanding its better to allow Raheel Sharif as he has taken this job on his personal capacity and not as a Government appointee. Its better Raheel Sharif stays out of the country, else he will keep medalling in internal politics.

Is it a quid pro quo between multiple stakeholders?

Taking command of forces to attack Yemen, very shameful decision.

Pmls tactic of divide and rule!

There is a conflict of interest here; a retired General should not seek any foreign appointment for at least years after retirement.

Well done Imran Sb

I hope Gen (retired) Rahil Shareef shall be wise enough to understand the gravity of middle east on going proxy wars. Pakistan or Pakistani by all mean shall keep them self neutral from this game.

I appreciate Imran Khan statement. what ever you say about Imran Khan but one thing is sky clear that his wisdom shine.

@pashtoon imran don't care who has supporters who does not have he says what's right as per his ideology. Try to understand the difference between him and others.

At last PTI is learning to bring issues of national importance to parliament for debate. This augurs well for the party.

Imran has a point. Makes sense

@Li-En-Ja

Your reasoning defies logic. The General must not be allowed to join the coalition as this may embroil Pakistan in issues not convergent with its policies.

Being an Indian,this is none of my business but i feel PTI has got logic against the opposition.

the problem with Pakistan is that the govt can do whatever he wants without consensus of Parliament and foreign office.I think for the 1st time IK is right in its stance.

A very sensible decision from PTI.

It is an honor for Pakistan ,why does Imran Khan has to oppose everything? No vision

Some matters are very sensitive, better Imran Khan concentrate on getting his party elected in the next general election & form his government. Imran should concentrate on eradicating corruption, delivering good & transparent governance, empowering national institutions, providing employments to the masses, controlling price hike and bringing very essentials of life such as basic food & utilities, medicine education for poor affordable.

Once again, PTI and Imran Khan stand alone and do the right thing.

Please treat this matter carefully Saudi is our close friend and we have to help them.

The man's post-retirement income is all that matters here. I too wouldn't care about the larger ramifications of my decision on receiving a job offer of USD500,000/annum.

@M. Khan : Mr. Raheel Sharif who will never fight against any Muslim country.

I am a Muslim and let me ask you a simple question. Who are these 39 countries going to fight against?.

@Sarwat In 2006,Musharraf's popularity was 60% but his party did not win a single seat in 2013. You need a party infrastructure to come to power in the center. One person's popularity does not achieve that.

Mr Khan taking it personal i guess otherwise i see no problem in this decision. No single country can handle terrorism and insurgencies plaguing the region for decades. Now its time to put an end to it. We can do it together and the fear Mr khan has about Iran and Russia is baseless because they too has interest in peace and rooting out terrorism.

Middle East is a huge sinking soil. Anybody, venturing in to it will be sucked in and sunk. Super powers like USA , Russia, Turkey, Iran are struggling and are on the lookout for a way out of Middle East. Knowing this, China is also maintaing a distance from it. Beware.

For once PTI shows courage to take up a perhaps unpopular but principally correct stance

@Rizwan

Honest!

Thank you.

Make it just the pension.

No freeloading, free rides or free lunches.

The only one party on Pakistan's political scene that talks sense!!!

Who is Imran Khan (PTI) to oppose NOC for Gen. Raheel? NOBODY. Simple question, when was the last time PTI has ever agreed with anything? NEVER.

PTI is crazy does not understand changing Geo-politics of middle east, this alliance will be bigger game changer for Pakistan than CPEC, no-doubt Iran should be convinced to join the alliance as well. But opposing the alliance is nothing short of insanity.

First take care of your own party and your ideals... PTI has become just a ad hoc party with no clear direction... just wants to make noise for no reason... so disappointed now with such idiotic statements and actions... Disheartened PTI supporter

The government as well as the parliament should stop acting as the Chaudry sahib of the world or the region and first focus internally to make Pakistan strong. Nations become strong with education, elimination of corruption; Justice system which works for the citizens, good governance etc. We should play a non-partisan role by maintaining good relations with the Saudis and even better relations with Iran because Iran happens to be our neighbor which is our natural trade and defense partner with historical ties from centuries ago.

Our foreign policy needs serious course correction in order to prioritize our focus on our own neighborhood for lasting peace and prosperity.

Very Right decision by PTI to oppose the move of officially allowing our former Army Chief to become the HEAD of so-called useless military alliance of 30 odd Muslim countries who have never thought of defending oppressed Palestinians , Lebanese , Iraqis and Myanmar Muslims from grave injustice. This Alliance does not include those Islamic countries who actually fought OR still fighting against Israel and ISIS , so its not wrong to say that this alliance will only deepen the sectarian strife in Muslim world. PAKISTAN by all means should stay away from such controversial and disastrous initiatives by ARAB monarchies whose only objective is to save their own crown and lust of Power in Gulf.

Balanced approach Mr. Khan Nawaz Sharif is acting like king bypassing parliament decision.

@MUHAMMAD FAHEEM KHAN I am not an ahle tash-ee, but I consider Iran to be potentially a very great country, and a brotherly one to us too. It was once a superpower in history and the Arab-Iran rivalry dates back to thousands of years. The west is highly suspicious of Iran and that is why it is using Arabs to suppress Iran. Iran is strategically very important to us due to our proximity to it. Any step we take that smacks of anti-Iranian tilt can prove dangerous for us later on, and may result in continued poverty of our economy.

we have to understand the changing dynamics of international politics and changing Geo-politics of middle east, The Iran is our good friend being an Islamic country .we have to develop a good understanding with iran for the great unity of Islamic ummah and Islamic Brother Hood. The Iran should need to be convinced to become the part of this Islamic Military Alliance Against regional terrorism Through smart diplomatic channels to develop an understanding that This Alliance will be bigger game changer for the prosperity and Regional security of Islamic counties , Iran should be convinced and motivated to join the alliance as well for the unity and solidarity of Islamic countries .The All Islamic countries national sovereignty and security should need to be protected .

For the first time I have seen PTI taking the right stance. With them on this

@silver "PTI is once again shooting itself in the foot! Majority of Pakistanis side with Saudis and are sympathetic to their ideology. Dont do this!" Parliament is the representative of people of Pakistan and they have already rejected this alliance who told you that most of Pakistanis love monarchy ?

Very valid arguments. Not that anyone will care what he says.

@mustafa "Please treat this matter carefully Saudi is our close friend and we have to help them" Yes Saudis are our close friends but we cannot preserve Monarchy at the cost of innocent lives of Yemeni Muslims which is more important than any Monarchy

Agreed with PTI on this stance.

@MUHAMMAD this is honor for Mr. Raheel Sharif as well as Pakistan to lead 39 Muslim countries Military alliance.

I wish Imran khan takes a mature decision sometime in life.

PML-N has played this well ...... it a win-win for them.

This time PTI and Imran Khan seems to be on right track.

The Nation has to manage threats to state. With the trusted man in the chair, both regional and national interest will be served, as opposed to giving it away to someone. To implement the idea the plan will require "enabling" to reach alignment between nations. It is an another barrier added; that reduces demand on our law enforcement agencies. With him instilled, the probability to succeed is the highest; any cons identified are to be managed.

Another non-sense from PTI

I stand with PTI

He is not taking this job on behalf of Pakistan. It is in his individual capacity on his own merit just like any other expatriate. PTI , Stop being childish.

@zak i hate PML N but y they will want to get rid of him? he is no longer army chief.. so pls kindly write ur comments after u do ur homework properly !!

@malik humayoun "this is honor for Mr. Raheel Sharif as well as Pakistan to lead 39 Muslim countries Military alliance" It would have been honour if he leads the 39 Muslims countries alliance against Israel to save the lives of beleaguered Palestinians it is no honour to preserve despotic Monarchy at the cost of innocent Muslims of the region especially Yemeni Muslims

@Guest101 "He is not taking this job on behalf of Pakistan. It is in his individual capacity on his own merit just like any other expatriate. PTI , Stop being childish" very childish comments without knowing the pros and cons and significance / sensitivity of the issue had it been so simple then why he had to take NOC from the Government of Pakistan ? and why Saudi Arabia using Pakistani flag during the parades of this so-called 39 Muslims countries alliance ?

Owning to suc principled stands by Imran Khan , I have gradually become a PTI supporter. Well done Imran Khan for you are absolutely correct.

PTI perspective is right but if middle East crisis do get solved then it would be great achievement for Pakistan. I would say lets take a risk and solve the problem .

@shayan khan "to tackle the burgeoning issues confronting the muslim countries" burgeoning issues not against the Muslim countries otherwsie this allaince would have been formed against US, Israel, India and Myanmar etc but this allaince is to tackle any opposition against Monarchies in Arab world how come saving the despotic monarchies is a service for Muslim world and what s the honour behind it ?

Raheel Sharif’s actions can also affect Pakistan’s relations with Iran, Russia and Turkey

Still short of vision cant think beyond himself.

I don't see any harm if 30+ Muslim countries form a military alliance and one person is chosen to lead it for a certain duration... It is formed to find solutions to "our " issues. We are not going to destroy any country based on their different faith or create phobia against their religion. How can Muslims remain detached in today's world?

@Muhammad What did you do?Spoke to each of 200M Pakistanis? Did a survey?

IK always work against the interest of Pakistan

This debate is futile Taking up a job with a foreign country is a personal decision like a retd.docior. or a aretd.emgineer or any cvil, servant

Pti is losing supporters very fast general can do what he likes he's not under contract with the government also the army will be to solve problems in Yemen Somalia Syria Libya Iraq there's no need to politice everything

For once in the entire political career of Imran Khan I see him doing the absolutely right thing. This collusion with Saudi Arabia is an undisguised threat to regional peace and a sure path to sectarian disharmony and strife if not civil war in our own country.

A very sensible and patriotic decision by PTI.General Raheel should not be allowed to take this job

Saudi Arabia has main role in the creation of both Al Qaeda and ISIS. Now, do they want to fight these two organisations or they want to fight against Iran, who are opposing these organisations?

At first sight,as this military alliance seems to be aimed against Iran, it will do good for anybody

@M. AsGhar , Did you want to say it will not do good to anybody?

At first sight, as this defence alliance seems to be aimed against Iran, I would not amount to anythig, but disarray in the ummah.

@M. AsGhar , The reality is there is no Ummah, as it is vertically divided into Saudi group and Iran group.

@Jamil Why would you as a Pakistani think about matters that don't really concern you?

I think this would be a very bad move. We need unity and cannot afford to upset Iran, Russia and Turkey. We may also have a backlash by the terrorists and they may target Pakistan even though our army will take care of them but the risks are too high. If the Gen has to lead them then the least we should demand from the Saudis is that they ask Iran to come on board too and all other Muslim nations because half measures are not good enough. Pakistan is on the rise now with Gawadar port so we cannot afford any mishaps.

Don t isolate Pakistan. Iran is never with Pakistan. Iran is always hugging india. No matter how hard Irani propaganda puppits try people of Pakistan will always be with their arab muslim brothers. IK rest assured this decision will lift Pakistans image more than 92 cricket world cup

Who cares? Let him go wherever he feels to. He is retired, let him enjoy a few more active years.

We are still suffering from the actions we did in other states, how can we make the same mistake again and again, are we paid gunners....

@Anwar ,Perfect question; Sin committed in Afghanistan still haunting.

39 out of 50 muslim countries have joined the alliance. 80% muslim countries have united and Pakistani general chief of the alliance. CONGRATULATIONS to all PAKISTAN

@Faisal , Remaining 11 Muslim countries constitute 22% of Muslim countries; Iran is very important neighboring country and Russia is their supporter.

the PTI is right in its decision, not only Raheel's decision will ruin the repo of general, it will disintegrate shia and sunni Muslims further. It will create another firm enemy next door, in addition to Afghanistan and India, of Pakistan.

Pakistan should keep off from West Asia sectarian mess.

For Leaders of PTI. Don't see with Iran perspective, also realize Syria, Yemen situations.

@PrincessofDHUMP "What did you do?Spoke to each of 200M Pakistanis? Did a survey?" Mr. Dump there is no need of asking 200 M Pakistanis we have a elected parliament and in democracies parliament is the form to express the people will and parliament has already rejected the idea of this so-called Muslim Countries alliance

@Faisal "Iran is never with Pakistan. Iran is always hugging india" you are totally ignorant of history Iran was the first country who accepted the Pakistan as an independent country in UN, Iran supported Pakistan in all its wars against India moreover Iran is over next door neighbor, whereas Saudi King last year awarded highest civilian medal to Narendra Modi the arch rival of Pakistan they spread extremism is Pakistan resulting in never ending terrorism in Pakistan

@Faisal "39 out of 50 muslim countries have joined the alliance. 80% muslim countries have united and Pakistani general chief of the alliance. CONGRATULATIONS to all PAKISTAN" this is a farce not 39 countries please do some research only few countries mostly Arab and few poor African countries are the part of this coalition secondly Pakistan through its parliament very wisely rejected this idea of so-called Muslim Countries alliance against poor Yemeni Muslims hence no need of congratulating Pakistan

He should not be issued a NOC. We should not be seen as taking sides.

A valid argument by PTI. This alliance tantamount to subjecting our forces to the will of Al Saud. Alliance is primarily against Iran. What business is ours to get involved in this conflict.

agree with IK, Pakistan should maintain a neutral position on the Arab-Iran rivalry in the Mideast. The alliance is nothing less than a Arab venture against Iran

Nice stance by PTI as usuall.we are already facing terrorism just because we did descion like this in past

@Zak .... GRS is a General not some sergeant out to train a bunch of incompetents. Get real...

@Ch. K. A. Nye i havnt wrote this re read

Excellent and bold initiative in national interst

@Khan so your love is reserved for the PPP and N League?

This should be a 40 country coalition. Include Iran and Raheel can lead.

@Zak thats good. Will Iran be a part of the coaltion?

@zak He retired. Give it a rest. Retired men hold no power. No one wants to get rid of him.

@Muhammad thank you for being just sir. We pakistani are afraid that this coaltion doesnt become the monarchs personal bodyguards. After all, they are the ones funding it.

PTI making sense for once.

Imran is right.

without brain

Pakistan should first sort out its interests and advantages without becoming a party to other military conflicts in the region.

You cannot shape an Islamic Alliance without a treaty signed by the interested member states like in the case of NATO, in the first place . And assuming that if that would happen then what would be the aim and objectives of such an Alliance .Certainly terrorism cannot be on the agenda as to tackle that menace is the internal problem of individual countries .You cannot form an armed international Islamic police force to deal with terrorism in each Islamic country. Being hired by rich Gulf states for what ever reason is a different story .Pakistan must not stoop so low for the sake of money as lessons can be learned when we followed the US for earning dollars in the aftermath of 9/11.Greed is a curse..

@Sameer

Hahahaha... Sameer sb., no way the KSA will invite the enemies of the coalition.

NOP if Iran meddle in every middle easern country affairs and even Pakistan! This time PTI will lose badly although I am its supporter in its fight against PMLN and PPP CORRUPTION!

Enough has been said on this controversial stance of the Govt. I will only add "think before you decide". Use super vision. This will be tantamount to ruining Retd. Gen raheel Sharif's reputation. On top of it, it is a 110% correct analysis that this alliance is directed towards Iran. This may become "VERY" controversial in future. Beware Gen. Save yourself from this controversial assignment.

@Changez Khan
Because all PMLN and PPP has given us are lies, corruption, hunger and despair. At least some is talking about truth, accountability and hope.

Maybe you are a benefactor of this system and hate hope