The biggest US bank explains why it’s not too big to fail

Published
0

NEW YORK: JPMorgan Chase is the largest bank in the country by assets. Its profit hit an all-time high last year, $24 billion, and it has more than 200,000 employees.

And the New York-based bank wants its shareholders to know one more thing: It’s not too big to fail.

In a Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Thursday, JPMorgan asked shareholders to reject the populist drumbeat calling for the breakup of Wall Street banks.

Since the 2008 financial crisis, JPMorgan and other large banks have been at the centre of a debate about whether they are so large that they could pose a threat to the economy.

But that drumbeat has become louder in recent months. Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders has made the issue the centre of his campaign. Even Neel Kashkari, who managed the $700bn Troubled Asset Relief Program used to rescue banks during the crisis, has piled on. Now president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Kashkari said the issue needs to be studied.

“You can never eliminate all risk, and I don’t think we would want to, but I think we can go further than we’ve gone,” he said in an interview with CNBC this week.

Amid that backdrop, JPMorgan is fighting a proposal from one of its shareholders — Bartlett Naylor, a financial policy advocate for Public Citizen, a liberal activist group — that would direct the bank to establish a panel of its independent board members to study a breakup of its assets. Under the proposal, the massive bank would be broken into two smaller companies, one focused on lending to businesses and consumers, the other on investment banking.

Naylor pointed to some of JPMorgan’s most embarrassing missteps over the past few years to make his argument. In 2013, the bank lost more than $6bn after its London traders placed bad bets on credit derivatives. The bank also has paid $30bn in fines “because bank managers failed to prevent misconduct in a variety of operations,” Naylor said in his proposal.

“The crisis and subsequent events have also demonstrated that JPMorgan may be ‘too big to manage,’” Naylor said.

JPMorgan rejects that argument. In fact, the bank says, its size is a benefit.

“Clients and customers choose JPMorgan Chase because of the breadth and quality of the services we provide. It is what they want and what they need,” the bank said in its response to Naylor’s proposal.

“Our diversification and scale are the key to this and enables us to serve our customers and clients, which include nearly 50pc of US households and approximately 80pc of Fortune 500 companies.”

The company said it studied the benefits of a breakup last year. The study “concluded that splitting off one or more businesses would likely negatively impact long-term shareholder value,” JPMorgan said.

In a separate letter to shareholders, JPMorgan chief executive Jamie Dimon, who is fond of calling the bank’s balance sheet a fortress, also defended the bank. “Nearly every year since the Great Recession, we have improved virtually every measure of financial strength, including many new ones,” he said.

Shareholders can vote on Naylor’s proposal at the company’s annual meeting in May.

Bloomberg-The Washington Post Service

Published in Dawn, April 10th, 2016

Opinion

Editorial

Expanding conflict
31 Jul, 2026

Expanding conflict

WITH neither of the belligerents willing to back down, and the theatre of conflict expanding geographically, the...
Spoils and spats
31 Jul, 2026

Spoils and spats

A FIGHT over assembly seats in Azad Jammu and Kashmir has laid bare what seem to be some deep resentments between ...
Unfair tax system
31 Jul, 2026

Unfair tax system

THE disclosure that the FBR collected nearly Rs1.9tr in sales and income taxes through electricity bills over the...
Debt that stays
30 Jul, 2026

Debt that stays

THE power sector’s circular debt grew by Rs61bn in the last fiscal year, taking the total to roughly Rs1.67tr from...
HIV warning
30 Jul, 2026

HIV warning

THE HIV infections detected around two SESSI-run hospitals in Karachi demand far more than another hurried committee...
End trafficking
30 Jul, 2026

End trafficking

MODERN slavery, in the form of human trafficking, is among the state’s gravest failures. Scores of Pakistanis are...