Minister promises probe but not halting the bulldozers

Published August 1, 2015
A boy sits on the wall of his demolished house in I-11. The other picture shows a family loading their belongings on a truck as they move out of the katchi abadi. — Photo by Tanveer Shahzad
A boy sits on the wall of his demolished house in I-11. The other picture shows a family loading their belongings on a truck as they move out of the katchi abadi. — Photo by Tanveer Shahzad

ISLAMABAD: The Capital Development Authority’s demolition of the ‘katchi abadi’ in Sector I-11 and the violent resistance to it echoed loud in the National Assembly on Friday, with the government promising an inquiry into alleged excesses, but without halting the bulldozers.

While the house did not have much other business at hand before adjourning for a two-day weekend, several members, mostly from the opposition, alleged brutality by police and Capital Development Authority (CDA) staff.

But voices of support for the operation were also raised from both sides of the house before the Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Sheikh Aftab Ahmed promised an inquiry into alleged ill-treatment of the residents of the illegal settlement who, according to witnesses, had violently resisted the bulldozing of their ramshackle huts in the southwestern I-11 sector of Islamabad at the start of the operation on Thursday.

“We are ready for an inquiry,” the minister said in response to some members’ demand for such a course, adding that its report would reveal facts about the operation as well as protesters’ claims of casualties and alleged arrest of a human rights activist with a two-year-old son.

Some MNAs, like Abdul Qahar Khan of the government-allied Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party from Balochistan province and opposition Jamaat-i-Islami’s parliamentary leader Sahibzada Tariqullah from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, complained that Pashtun residents of the settlement of many years were wrongly labeled as Afghan refugees and became the main sufferers.

Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) chief whip Shirin Mazari and a party colleague from Karachi, Arif Alvi, objected to conducting the operation without providing an alternative site to the slum dwellers to go to.

But another PTI member, Ghulam Sarwar Khan, from the nearby Rawalpindi district, supported the operation.

Like the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-N members from the area, Malik Abrar Ahmed and Tahira Aurangzeb, he too called for extending the operation to clear other encroached sectors.

The two PML-N MNAs described the targeted ‘katchi abadi’ as a den of criminals, drug traffickers and arms smugglers.

Sheikh Aftab said the operation was neither sudden nor aimed at any particular ethnic group. It was conducted after many warnings to people occupying land belonging to others and their persistent refusal resulted in the Islamabad High Court ordering their eviction, he said.

How the authorities could look the other way if criminals make their dens in cities like Islamabad and Lahore, he asked.

A Muttahida Qaumi Movement MNA from Sindh, Dr Nighat Shakeel, who was the first to protest the CDA operation and demand an alternative place for the katchi abadi residents, asked why similar action was not taken against the owners of farm houses around Islamabad for violating the city laws.

Her MQM colleague Sajid Ahmed demanded a similar operation against what he called “the crime dens” in Karachi.

Published in Dawn, August 1st, 2015

On a mobile phone? Get the Dawn Mobile App: Apple Store | Google Play

Opinion

Editorial

Deepening conflict
Updated 15 Jun, 2025

Deepening conflict

Some media reports say that the US had shipped hundreds of missiles to Israel before the attack on Iran.
Some strides
15 Jun, 2025

Some strides

THE PTI government in KP is not known for sound public service delivery in a province whose economy has been ...
Air India tragedy
15 Jun, 2025

Air India tragedy

THE black box of the ill-fated Air India flight AI171 has been recovered, and that should reveal in the coming days...
‘Declaration of war’
Updated 14 Jun, 2025

‘Declaration of war’

Israel's provocative behaviour has, once again, brought the Middle East to the precipice of a full-blown war.
A mixed bag
14 Jun, 2025

A mixed bag

SINDH’S Rs3.45tr budget for the next fiscal year seeks to combine populism with provincial tax reforms while also...
Water-starved city
14 Jun, 2025

Water-starved city

IT is an injustice that finds few parallels. Karachi, home to a burgeoning population of over 20m and the primary...