Letter shows CIA had doubts about Iraq link to 9/11 attacks

Published December 13, 2014
The towers of the World Trade Center pour smoke shortly after being struck by hijacked commercial airplanes in New York in this September 11, 2001.— Reuters/file
The towers of the World Trade Center pour smoke shortly after being struck by hijacked commercial airplanes in New York in this September 11, 2001.— Reuters/file

WASHINGTON: The CIA declassified a letter on Thursday that suggests US intelligence had grave doubts about part of the case made by former president George W. Bush’s White House to justify the war in Iraq.

In the run-up to the March 2003 invasion, US officials including then vice president Dick Cheney alleged that 9/11 hijacker Mohammed Atta had met an Iraqi spy in Prague before the attacks.

The alleged meeting was cited as evidence of a possible link between Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein and the Sept 11, 2001 attacks on New York and Washington.

But, in a letter sent to US Senator Carl Levin in March this year and just now declassified, CIA Director John Brennan said field agents had “expressed significant concern” over the report.

The letter said US agents had not established Atta was in Prague — evidence suggest that he was not -- at the time he is supposed to have met Iraqi agent Ahmad Khalil Ibrahim Samir al-Ani.

The letter was first reported by McClatchy newspapers.

Levin said on Thursday he had asked the CIA to declassify the document to show how the former Bush administration ‘misled’ the country before the invasion of Iraq.

In a Senate speech, Levin said the “alleged meeting was a centrepiece of the administration’s campaign to create an impression in the public mind that Saddam was in league with the Al Qaeda terrorists who attacked us on 9/11”. “On multiple occasions, including national television appearances, Vice President Dick Cheney cited reports of the meeting, at one point calling it ‘pretty well confirmed’,” Levin said.

Levin said he raised the issue to give “the American people a full account of the march to war as new information becomes available”. Levin added that the revelation “is about warning future leaders of this nation that they must not commit our sons and daughters to battle on the basis of false statements”.

Published in Dawn, December 13th, 2014

Opinion

Editorial

Petroleum subsidy
Updated 21 Mar, 2023

Petroleum subsidy

The govt seems more interested in reviving its political capital through ad hoc measures rather than fixing economy.
Country on edge
21 Mar, 2023

Country on edge

THE country is tearing itself apart. With politics being conducted with unprecedented venom and vitriol, there is...
Afghan funding cut
21 Mar, 2023

Afghan funding cut

AS the world grapples with multiple crises, the miseries of the people of Afghanistan seem to have been relegated to...
Trading for peace
Updated 20 Mar, 2023

Trading for peace

It remains to be seen whether the current army leadership pursues Bajwa doctrine for Pak-India peace or has other ideas.
A thrilling finish
20 Mar, 2023

A thrilling finish

IT was a Pakistan Super League final that had everything: thrills and spills, enthralling drama and a tantalisingly...
Covid-19 threat
20 Mar, 2023

Covid-19 threat

THE National Command and Operation Centre’s recent recommendation that people wear masks at crowded public places...