IT was a moment foretold many times over but nevertheless came as a surprise. On Thursday morning, former military dictator General Pervez Musharraf headed to the Islamabad High Court for his bail application in the judges’ detention case. Perhaps he expected a positive response — a day earlier he had been given bail in the Benazir Bhutto murder case. But he was in for a disappointment: the IHC rejected his application and ordered that Musharraf be arrested but the former chief of army staff’s security personnel whisked him out of the court premises and rushed him to his farmhouse.

It is hard to believe that he had not foreseen this. The lukewarm reception he received on his return; the rejection of his nomination papers from one constituency after another; the disdain with which the media and civil society reacted to his return even as political parties maintained a silence — indeed, it had been evident that “everyone ended up finding his place in the world, everyone except him”. If nothing else, as a man who had been part of the political system for so long, Musharraf should have realised that no guarantees — from any quarter — could have ensured how he was treated upon return. He could simply have recalled the fate of his ‘deal’ with Benazir to understand this. But now that he has miscalculated once more, Musharraf — who has time and again said that he would abide by the law — needs to toe the legal line. He should hand himself over and court arrest; anything short of that will reflect badly on him. Indeed, the jokes that were circulating about the commando who ran away on Thursday should be enough to convince him that the honourable course lies in surrendering before the law rather than defying it.

At the same time, it is necessary to caution the judiciary. With the history of the courts’ clash with the dictator still fresh in our memory, the former should be careful as the cases against the latter are heard. Not for a moment should anyone be able to accuse the courts of pursuing vengeance rather than justice. The general has already been judged by history. Had he been allowed to contest the elections and been delivered a sound defeat, there would have been little that the law could have added to this. Indeed, the people’s verdict would have sealed his fate far more effectively than any legal order that still runs the risk of making a martyr out of him.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Continuing impunity

HRCP observed that while disappearances have decreased in Balochistan, incidents in KP and Sindh have gone up.

Thar drought

The Thar region is once again in the news for the drought and starvation that are taking their toll on the inhabitants.

Comments (28) (Closed)


Ijaz
Apr 19, 2013 05:38am
Unfortunately, judges seem to be too "Honorable" to understand it - though Musharraf will be on his way out :)
Imran Ali
Apr 19, 2013 05:44am
It is very surprising that Musharraf is doing all this on consultation of those people who are know losers. I think if he uses his own mind, it wont be that bad
Farhan
Apr 19, 2013 05:52am
"Not for a moment should anyone be able to accuse the courts of pursuing vengeance rather than justice" - too late for this since the court is obviously running a vendetta.
M Rafique
Apr 19, 2013 06:09am
Festival moments for media and so called civil socities
Javaid Bashir
Apr 19, 2013 06:11am
Sound editorial. I have already said in my comments on tjhe face book that judiciary should be cautios in its approach and not lat him become a martyr. Given the history and bad blood between the two there is every likelihood that jusdiciary's actions will be perceived in different light. The general should get a fair trial in every case against him . The due process of law must be maintained. It was coming that his bail could be cancelled and arrest warrants be issued. But all these offences are still bailable offences.. the S>C will grant the bail. We must not clsash on these matters. He should bre allowed to contest elections as there is no conviction against him, mere allegations are not enough basis for the rejection of papers. Apart from criminal acts he still has clear and lean record. Morally and legally there is no ground to stop him from contesting elections .Let us be fair to all the candidates. Javaid Bashir Lahore
Ahmed
Apr 19, 2013 06:13am
Finally, Pakistan is moving towards closing the dictatorial chapter.
Mohammad Saleem
Apr 19, 2013 06:20am
Martyr or not, Musharraf should face music. This will put other would-be usurpers on notice that similar disdain and disgraceful fate await them if they try to follow in the former footsteps
Khizr
Apr 19, 2013 07:17am
A nameless editorial..
Saeed
Apr 19, 2013 08:11am
At first place who had stopped police to arrest him if it wanted to. Media rhetoric that he has ran away runs contrary to the TV seen itself, when he was seen escorted to his home by the Police and rangers themselves.
M. S. Alvi
Apr 19, 2013 08:44am
The thinking behind this article is true. Musharraf should be left alone and allowed to run in elections. If people reject him, let be it. The drama being played is a big shame.
peace
Apr 19, 2013 09:01am
This is the fate of all dictators, they never realize that people do not love from their heart - disgrace is their destiny, be it Zia or Mobarak or Gadafi et al.
Zak
Apr 19, 2013 10:01am
Remember all the good musharaf did for Pakistan and it was a far better time than the last 5 years. Musharaf is in politics and I hope he keeps his commando spirit and battles the legal process. The more vindictive the judiciary, the more the public will see the injustise from the legal fraternity. Most likely, nawab and the pro Taliban parties are pushing their cronies in the judiciary to humiliate musharaf rather than try him with sincerety. Enough is enough.!
Zak
Apr 19, 2013 10:03am
Musharaf will bounce back, he should leave a committee to run APML affairs until cleared.
Iqbal
Apr 19, 2013 11:11am
early conclusions
Sayed Inam Ali
Apr 19, 2013 12:06pm
if the people of Pakistan desire to have equal rights for all than Musharraf must be brought to book and it might open doors to common for justice because at present the influential treat themselves above the law.
Zafar Malik
Apr 19, 2013 02:01pm
Cases against him are all politically motivated. He did a great job as President. Dawn is expected to be more balanced and objective but I am disappointed.
Kalidas
Apr 19, 2013 02:31pm
I wonder if this drama is a finale to a forced chaos in the making before the elections and some smart general to say what the heck is going on. Time for a military takeover. Or maybe politics has reached much maturity for this to be a non-event.
Syed Ahmed
Apr 19, 2013 02:36pm
Nawaz Sharif states that Musharraf should be tried as a common criminal ? what is special about Sharif and associates? Musharraf didn't rob the nation nad made them into paupers.
gangadin
Apr 19, 2013 02:57pm
I would love to know what this guy is smoking. Does he really think that he is electable? Did he study Pakistani politics? I think his career is over in disgrace. A corrupt, coward and illegal commando.
Assad
Apr 19, 2013 04:51pm
No charges of corruption stand against him, which in Pakistani political landscape is a unique case altogether. How is he a coward? That he left Pakistan after giving up on government is cowardice? He is more of a commando than you can ever dream of becoming or understanding. He will always be remembered for his legacy as a straight talking, personally honest Pakistani who was not afraid to face the courts.
Arshad Jamil
Apr 19, 2013 04:53pm
A very poor sub-standard editorial. No surprise, for Dawn to also follow the band wagon, and try to settle some score. Looks like, that it was written in haste. It needed a scholarly touch, some history, some of his deeds and misdeeds, some reflection, activism of Juditiary, and flaundering of constitution in 4 hiurs by ZAB and all others. Did not expect this from DAWN of Altaf Hussain, proclaiming " Batil sey dabney......" Dawn is only helping to get the head of Musharaf. Go, rejoice.
imran
Apr 19, 2013 05:04pm
most unbiased opinion, that i've seen on the media, but still a little late for some of the actions by parties are already in progress like vendetta
john
Apr 19, 2013 05:34pm
His Karma is Catching up mate,
Bharat
Apr 19, 2013 06:05pm
How did this man ever get to the top?
MOHAMMAD
Apr 19, 2013 06:14pm
you are wrong. you should mind your language. MUSHARAF IS A BRAVE COMMANDO WHO HAS THE CAPACITY TO FACE THE COURTS BRAVELY. HE COULD HAVE DECIDED NOT TO COME BACK BUT HE CAME, WHICH HE PROVES THAT HE WAS NOT CORRUPT OR COWARD. DO NOT WORRY THAT IS A GOOD PRECEDENT IN PAK HISTORY THAT EVERY BODY IS EQUAL BEFORE LAW.
MOHAMMAD
Apr 19, 2013 06:18pm
COURTS SHOULD NOT INDULGE IN POLICY OF REVENGE. HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO RUN IN THE ELECTIONS AND LET PEOPLE DECIDE. LET SUPREME COURT GIVE HIM BAIL AND HE BE ALLOWED TO CONTEST ELECTIONS. TO ERR IS HUMAN AND TO FORGIVE IS DIVINE. LET S NOT FORGET THAT HE WAS A NON-CORRUPT SINCERE PRESIDENT.
MOHAMMAD
Apr 19, 2013 06:22pm
WE SHOULD RESPECT THE DECISION OF JUDUCIARY . WE HOPE TYHAT COURTS SHOULD NOT INDULGE IN POLICY OF REVENGE. HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO RUN IN THE ELECTIONS AND LET PEOPLE DECIDE. LET SUPREME COURT GIVE HIM BAIL AND HE BE ALLOWED TO CONTEST ELECTIONS. TO ERR IS HUMAN AND TO FORGIVE IS DIVINE. LET S NOT FORGET THAT HE WAS A NON-CORRUPT SINCERE PRESIDENT.
MOHAMMAD
Apr 19, 2013 06:23pm
WE SHOULD RESPECT THE DECISION OF JUDICIARY . WE HOPE THAT COURTS SHOULD NOT INDULGE IN POLICY OF REVENGE. HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO RUN IN THE ELECTIONS AND LET PEOPLE DECIDE. LET SUPREME COURT GIVE HIM BAIL AND HE BE ALLOWED TO CONTEST ELECTIONS. TO ERR IS HUMAN AND TO FORGIVE IS DIVINE. LET US NOT FORGET THAT HE WAS A NON-CORRUPT SINCERE PRESIDENT.