Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


KCR project at a standstill


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

WILL the revival of the Karachi Circular Railway remain a pipe dream in a city in dire need of a mass transit system for millions of commuters? Over the years, there have only been half-hearted moves to resuscitate the KCR. The question at the moment is whether the government’s decision on Wednesday to exempt the KCR from a number of taxes to make it financially viable will help expedite the project. Undertaken during the Ayub era, the KCR was a useful project. It transported workers from the outlying colonies to the industrial area, which was connected to the harbour and to the railway main line for cargo movement. Over the decades it suffered ruination, especially because of ticketless travelling. More important, the city grew rapidly, and what was a railway line on the periphery now runs more or less through the city. This is an advantage and should be utilised to ease pressure on the buses and other type of vehicles to give Karachi a mass transit system, even if in an embryonic form.

The Japanese International Cooperation Agency has shown more interest in the KCR than the governments in Islamabad and Karachi have. The JICA offer has been there for more than a decade, but somehow there has been a considerable lack of interest at our end. It has offered a soft loan — $2.4bn at 0.2 mark-up payable in 40 years — but bureaucratic delays and the absence of political will have stood in the way. When — and if — completed in 2017, the KCR’s first phase, partly elevated and partly underground, will carry 700,000 passengers daily. A general election is round the corner, and it would be a pity if bureaucratic or other administrative changes serve to delay a project meant to ease the pressure constantly witnessed on Karachi’s roads.

Comments (4) Closed

ali Mar 09, 2013 04:48am
Let us send Shehbaz sharif there.
Keti Zilgish Mar 09, 2013 12:03pm
From whatever personal experience I have I can suggest that our best bet for preventing ticketless travelling is to run electric trains which is possible only if some changes take place in political parties like the PPP which have been voted to in power only because they promised free electricity to their voters. Pilferage and wastage of electricity has strangulated Karachi.
Shahid Mar 09, 2013 03:58pm
I can't agreee more with the need for a viable KCR. It is shameful that public transportation has been abondoned for this a city of 15 Million. I think this issue should be on top of the MQM agenda for this election since they represent, more or less, the entire city and both PPP and ANP should converge with MQM on this one issue since this will benefit all. While the project planning goes on, an easy first step is to establish a reliable commuter service on the Landhi to City station corridor with a stop a Kalapul. The track is there and this merely an issue of will and a few local trains. This will provide releif to a large number of communities along the track and can become a show piece for the main project and can help in getting financing from donor organizations for infra-structure projects
Iqbal Mar 09, 2013 04:42pm
law and order is the main hindrance. Forget about tax holidays and investments.