THIS is apropos of the Gallup survey that reported Singapore as being the most emotionless society (Nov 23). The main fallacy of this survey is that it treats all Singaporeans as a single entity, which they are not.

Singapore has three main ethnic groups, Chinese, Indians and Malays. They vary in their emotional response to grief, pain, merriment, etc.

I am reminded of an obstetrician colleague who used to say just standing outside the delivery room that one could guess if the patient is an Indian or Chinese, as the shrieks of the Indian would be many octaves higher.

It is not proper to generalise but my impression after many years of teaching both in the National University of Singapore and the Aga Khan University is that AKU students are more vocal than those of NUS.

I am sure this is a cultural phenomenon and depends on the values taught from childhood. People of the subcontinent are obsessively vocal and gossip is their favourite pasttime. This is not the case with the Chinese who are more reserved and do not interfere in other people’s private affairs or religious matters.

This gives the impression that they are relatively emotionless. In this respect it is worth knowing the views of Confucius who has had enormous influence on the Chinese thought.

He says: “One should be quick to act but slow to speak”. I wish more Pakistanis would follow Confucius’s advice.

In my humble view it is better to be ‘emotionless’ than to be overwhelmed with emotions which leads to nothing but trouble.

Even if this survey is correct, it is a credit to Singapore, not a debit.

DR VIQAR ZAMAN Karachi


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Physicians & patriarchy

THIS is with reference to Rafia Zakaria’s article ‘Physicians and patriarchy’. At face value, you cannot but...

HCV: oral drug

The news carried in your paper of Nov 21 about the availability of an oral drug for the treatment of Hepatitis C...

Pemra rules & channels

ACCORDING to Rule 24 (4) of Pemra Rules 2002, the duration of advertisement breaks in TV programmes shall not be ...

Comments (3) Closed




M K Sufi
Dec 20, 2012 07:31am
Any person could be emontionless so long a situation does not effect him/her directly. The people world over gossip. The face book has given a wider scope
observer
Dec 20, 2012 05:45pm
Okay Sir. Will do so in the future. Order taken Sir.
Sam
Dec 21, 2012 01:18am
Karachi is best example of emotionless society where several innocent people are killed daily.