ISLAMABAD. The Auditor General of Pakistan (AGP) has declared payments amounting to Rs329.92 billion, made to Independent Power Producers (IPPs) by the Federal Consolidated Fund on the advice of the finance division, as 'unconstitutional' and against treasury rules.

The present regime paid the amount to IPPs, to overcome the energy crisis prevailing in the country, without consulting the Auditor General and without pre-audit checks, according to a report compiled by the AGP for the fiscal year 2014-15.

The report says that irregular direct payments were made from the Federal Consolidated Fund on the advice of the finance division.

The audit has observed that article 170 (1) of the constitution states that the account of Federation and Provinces shall be kept in such form and in accordance with such principles and methods as the Auditor General may, with the approval of the president, prescribe.

Section 5(b) of Controller General of Accounts (Appointment, Functions and Powers) Ordinance, 2001 states that it is the function of the Controller General of Accounts to authorise payments and withdrawals from the Consolidated Fund and public accounts of the federal and provincial accounts against approved budgetary provisions.

Other relevant rules also emphasise that unless the government ─ after consultation with the Auditor General ─ directs, money may not be withdrawn from the Federal Consolidated Fund or the public account of the federation without written permission of the Treasury Officer or of an officer of the Pakistan Audit Department authorised in this behalf by an Accountant General.

The Manuscript of Appropriation Accounts of Federal Government for 2013-14 revealed that payments amounting to Rs329.92 billion were directly made from the Federal Consolidated Fund on the advice of the finance division.

According to the report, the auditor observed that the payments were made without consultation with the Auditor General and without pre-audit checks as required under Section 5(b) of Controller General of Accounts (Appointment, Functions and Powers) Ordinance, 2001 which was a violation of Article 170(1) of the Constitution and resulted in financial indiscipline.

Finance division management has not made any reply on the matter, the report says.

Read: Audit gives clean chit to Rs342bn payment to IPPs

The Auditor General of Pakistan has recommended that payments should not be made without pre-audit checks which are a violation of constitutional provisions and the Federal Treasury rules.

Follow Dawn Business on X, LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business, finance and tech from Pakistan and across the world.

Opinion

Editorial

Energy shock
Updated 05 May, 2026

Energy shock

The longer the crisis persists, the more profound its consequences will be.
Unchecked HIV
05 May, 2026

Unchecked HIV

PAKISTAN’S HIV surge is no longer a slow-burning public health concern. It is now a system failure unfolding in...
PSL thrills
05 May, 2026

PSL thrills

BY the end of it all, in front of fans who had been absent for almost the entire 11th season of the Pakistan Super...
Interlinked crises
Updated 04 May, 2026

Interlinked crises

The situation vis-à-vis the US-Israeli war on Iran remains tense, with hostilities likely to resume if the diplomatic process fails.
Climate readiness
04 May, 2026

Climate readiness

AS policymakers gather for the Breathe Pakistan conference this week, the urgency is hard to miss. Each year, such...
Kalash preservation
04 May, 2026

Kalash preservation

FOR centuries, the Kalash people have maintained a culture, way of life, language and belief system that is uniquely...