Afghan aid workers likely to bear the brunt after MSF hospital bombing

Published October 9, 2015
At least 22 patients and MSF staff were killed on Saturday when a U.S. aircraft attacked the hospital. —AFP/File
At least 22 patients and MSF staff were killed on Saturday when a U.S. aircraft attacked the hospital. —AFP/File

Afghan aid workers and civilians will suffer the most after the deadly U.S. bombing of a hospital run by the charity Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) in the northern city of Kunduz, experts said on Friday.

At least 22 patients and MSF staff were killed on Saturday when a U.S. aircraft attacked the hospital during fighting between Afghan government troops and Taliban forces.

MSF, which wants an independent international probe into the airstrike, says it has withdrawn its staff from Kunduz and is reviewing all its operations in Afghanistan “to carefully weigh the safety and security of staff and patients.”

“MSF's decision to withdraw (from Kunduz), which is unfortunate but completely understandable, could have catastrophic consequences for civilians in the broader region,” said Michael Kugelman, senior programme associate for South Asia at the Woodrow Wilson Center.

Also read: Obama apologises to MSF for air strike on hospital: White House

“There are medical facilities in Kunduz and throughout northeastern Afghanistan, but the MSF hospital was the only one that could handle major war injuries. And yet at least for now it has closed down.”

Kugelman said he feared that with the Taliban emboldened by its brief seizure of Kunduz, it will step up its offensives in surrounding districts and result in more civilian casualties.

Local Afghan charities will need to take on an even greater burden than they already bear, with the very real threat of diminished international humanitarian assistance, he added.

Know more: 'Bombing at hospital was a mistake made by US chain of command'

MSF, which has been in Afghanistan since 1980, pulled out for a period after five staff were killed in 2004. It has already shut down its hospital's operations in Kunduz and has given no indication of when it might reopen.

The Aid Worker Security Database, a project set up by the research consultancy Humanitarian Outcomes, says 65 aid workers have been killed in attacks in Afghanistan so far this year, compared to 127 the previous year.

Humanitarian Outcomes' Adele Harmer said recruitment has long been one of the most difficult challenges for humanitarian agencies, and in dangerous or hardship posts like Afghanistan, the challenge of attracting experienced staff is still greater.

“For the most part however, it is important to recognise that it is national and local staff who are doing the majority of the field work in Afghanistan, not internationals,” said Harmer.

“Local staff are often motivated by a desire to help within their own communities, and don't always see the risks as the same, nor do they necessarily see these contexts as 'hardship' posts.”

Opinion

Editorial

Rigging claims
Updated 04 May, 2024

Rigging claims

The PTI’s allegations are not new; most elections in Pakistan have been controversial, and it is almost a given that results will be challenged by the losing side.
Gaza’s wasteland
04 May, 2024

Gaza’s wasteland

SINCE the start of hostilities on Oct 7, Israel has put in ceaseless efforts to depopulate Gaza, and make the Strip...
Housing scams
04 May, 2024

Housing scams

THE story of illegal housing schemes in Punjab is the story of greed, corruption and plunder. Major players in these...
Under siege
Updated 03 May, 2024

Under siege

Whether through direct censorship, withholding advertising, harassment or violence, the press in Pakistan navigates a hazardous terrain.
Meddlesome ways
03 May, 2024

Meddlesome ways

AFTER this week’s proceedings in the so-called ‘meddling case’, it appears that the majority of judges...
Mass transit mess
03 May, 2024

Mass transit mess

THAT Karachi — one of the world’s largest megacities — does not have a mass transit system worth the name is ...