RUSSIA and the US are insisting that they want to see a diplomatic solution to the civil war of Syria. Here are four things that Barack Hussein Obama and Vladimir Putin should keep in mind.

First, civil wars do not end quickly. The average length of civil wars since 1945 has been about 10 years. This shows that Syria’s civil war is in its early stages, not in its later stages.

Second, the greater the number of factions, the longer the civil war tends to last.

Syria’s civil war is being fought between the Assad regime and 13 major rebel groups whose alliances are relatively fluid.

This suggests that Syria’s civil war is likely to last longer than an average civil war.

Third, most civil wars end in decisive military victories, not negotiated settlements.

Of these wars, the government has won about 40pc of the time and rebels about 35pc of the time. The remainder tend to end in negotiated settlements.

This shows that civil war in Syria will not end in settlements but will rather end on the battlefield.

Fourth, the civil war that ends in settlement has two things in common: they divide political power among the combatants based on their position on the battlefield.

This means that any negotiated settlement in Syria will need to include both the Assad regime and the Islamists, neither of whom is particularly interested in working with the other.

Successful settlements enjoy the help of a third party willing to ensure the safety of combatants as they demobilise.

This means that even if all sides agree to negotiate, it is unlikely that any country or the UN will be willing to send peacekeepers necessary to help implement the peace.

Is there a likelihood of a successful negotiated settlement in Syria? Probably, close to zero.

DR ZOYA HASSAN BROHI

Karachi

More From This Section

Chinese language project

THIS is apropos the report ‘Confucius comes to Karachi’ (March 7) and letters by Tariq Khoso and Manik Meer ...

‘A veiled warning?’

THIS refers to your editorial ‘A veiled warning?’ (April 9). In any other country under normal conditions the...

Recruitment criterion

BE it government, semi-government, autonomous or private organisations, they are recruiting according to a ...

Nadra smart card

Although I was born in India, after partition my parents migrated to Pakistan in 1950. I have been living in Karachi...


Comments are closed.

Comments (3)

Syed Husain
November 6, 2013 12:46 pm

We need to understand that the war in Syrian is primarily a proxy war. It is being fought between the two super powers and also between Arab vs. Iran, at the cost of Syrian lives and property. If only the outsiders leave the Syrians alone and stop this interference, I am sure that this war will end.

Syed Husain
November 6, 2013 12:54 pm

We need to understand that the war in Syrian is primarily a proxy war. It is being fought between the two super powers and also between Arab vs. Iran, at the cost of Syrian lives and property. If only the outsiders leave the Syrians alone and stop this interference, I am sure that this war will end.

GA
November 6, 2013 5:51 pm

@Syed Husain: It started off as an internal uprising which is not surprising given the despotic nature of these regimes. External meddling mucked it up and now the despot will remain. Not bad considering the Saudi-backed religious alternative.

Explore: Indian elections 2014
Explore: Indian elections 2014
How much do you know about Indian Elections?
How much do you know about Indian Elections?
Cartoons
E-PAPER
Front Page