OSLO, Oct 11: The award of the 2002 Nobel Peace Prize to former US president Jimmy Carter for his conflict-solving efforts was also a “criticism of the position” of the current US administration, the head of the Nobel committee said on Friday, sparking controversy even among his colleagues.

Gunnar Berge, chairman of the Nobel Committee, told reporters that honouring Carter “can also be interpreted as a criticism of the position” of the administration of President George W. Bush.

However Committee member Inger Marie Ytterhorn, who is close to Norway’s right-wing populist party FRP, was quick to dissociated herself from the comment.

“The way I see it, that was not the intention of the Committee,” she told NRK radio.

Berge also said that the prize decision was a signal “to all the other countries which have adopted the same position” as the United States.

Ytterhorn said Berge’s comments showed that he “lacks professionalism”.

Another Committee member, Hanna Kvamo, who is close to the Socialist party, also declined to back Berge. “In the committee we did not discuss what interpretation should be given” to the Carter award, she said.

However, a third member of the body, the Bishop of Oslo, Gunnar Staalsett, came to Berge’s rescue.

“There is no reason at all to criticize Berge over this business. He is well within his role when he says what he said,” the bishop, who is close to the centrist party, was quoted by Internet journal Nettavisen as saying.

The choice of Carter for the prize “should absolutely be read” as a criticism of the Bush administration, even if the desire to criticize “was not the motivation” for awarding the prize to Carter, the bishop added.

There was a voice of protest from within the Norwegian government, with Foreign Minister Jan Petersen saying he was “a little surprised” by the judges’ stated motives.—AFP

Editorial

Updated 05 Aug, 2026

State of confusion

FROM the looks of it, America has no exit strategy to extricate itself from the disastrous war with Iran. US...
05 Aug, 2026

Pension decision

THE government’s decision to formally operationalise the new Defined Contribution Pension Fund Scheme is a step...
05 Aug, 2026

Preventable deaths

THE deaths of 144 children from measles and diphtheria in Karachi during the first seven months of the year expose a...
Updated 04 Aug, 2026

Swat bombing

IT is a bitter irony that terrorists struck a protest against violence in Swat on Sunday, causing at least 17...
04 Aug, 2026

Tariff blow

FOR an export sector already squeezed by high production costs, the additional 10pc tariff on top of the existing...
04 Aug, 2026

Perilous peaks

THE deaths of 10 climbers in an avalanche on Broad Peak is a sad reminder of the perils that many mountaineers face...