Outrage in India after ‘experiment’ remark on ethanol-mixed fuel

Published Updated
A worker fills a car with petrol as he gestures towards the fuel barometer for the passenger to check, at a fuel station in Kolkata September 15, 2011. — Reuters/File
A worker fills a car with petrol as he gestures towards the fuel barometer for the passenger to check, at a fuel station in Kolkata September 15, 2011. — Reuters/File

NEW DELHI: The Indian government sought to contain a growing backlash on Friday against its mandatory use of 20 per cent ethanol-blended petrol, as consumers unhappy about lower fuel efficiency and vehicle performance planned a protest against the policy.

The mandate to use the blend, called E20, came into force last year, but is now one of the biggest political flashpoints for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government and motorists in the world’s third-biggest car market.

The controversy intensified this week after Attorney General R. Venkataramani told a court hearing that E20 was an “experiment” whose results would only come out next year.

The government denied the remark was ever made, but video of the court hearing showing Venkataramani saying the words has since gone viral on social media.

Venkataramani said he used the term “experiment” in the context of the volume of ethanol supplies, not the ethanol petrol policy itself.

This has done little to quell public anger, with opponents of the policy accusing the government of rushing its rollout.

The government’s press office dismissed the criticism as “wild claims” on Friday, asking people to not “fall for the rage bait”.

Seeking to reassure motorists, Petroleum Minister Hardeep Singh Puri on Thursday compared ethanol fuel to its use in motor racing.

“They use it in racing cars also, the acceleration increases. Mileage, yes, it may drop a little,” Puri said.

Protest planned

Tehseen Poonawalla, a New Delhi-based socialite and Congress party supporter, said he was planning a protest against the E20 policy in New Delhi on Sunday, and had received interest from thousands of people wanting to join in.

Many motorists are frustrated that they no longer have a choice at fuel stations and have seized on the attorney general’s comment to vent their anger on social media.

Priyank Kharge, a state minister in India’s opposition Congress party, said on X that the E20 policy rollout lacked consultation and that the government “cannot challenge citizens to prove damage when your own data is still pending”.

Hundreds of motorists have posted complaints on X alleging reduced fuel efficiency and increased wear and tear of car parts from E20.

In one video on X viewed over 500,000 times, an agitated motorist who identified himself as Manish Kashyap stands in a workshop with his car saying in the post it needed repairs after being damaged by E20 fuel.

“I have spent a lot of money on this car and paid taxes only to find that after two months my car is not working,” he said.

The government says E20 helps to reduce carbon emissions, cuts crude imports which saves foreign exchange, and supports farm incomes by increasing demand for agricultural feedstocks used in ethanol production.

Published in Dawn, July 4th, 2026

Opinion

Editorial

Agri-tax failure
Updated 04 Jul, 2026

Agri-tax failure

THE first year of Pakistan’s unified agriculture income tax regime has produced an outcome that should surprise no...
Deadly roads
04 Jul, 2026

Deadly roads

THE horrific bus crash at the Balochistan-KP border on Friday should prompt greater scrutiny of road safety ...
Terrorism numbers
04 Jul, 2026

Terrorism numbers

AS Pakistan continues to grapple with the menace of militancy, the number of terrorist attacks present a mixed...
Unfinished business
Updated 03 Jul, 2026

Unfinished business

THE landmark 18th Amendment and seventh NFC Award radically reshaped Pakistan’s fiscal federalism by transferring...
Abuse cycle
03 Jul, 2026

Abuse cycle

LULLED into a sense of false security by its own denial and apathy, Pakistan is a long way from achieving tangible...
Closing the gap
03 Jul, 2026

Closing the gap

THE numbers are encouraging, yet one cannot help but rue the opportunities still being lost. The GSMA’s Mobile...